3 ms·
The core problem here is that there are two different ideas about tolerance in play here, which I think is poorly understood as people tend to fling around the
by jerf 13y ago
The core problem here is that there are two different ideas about tolerance in play here, which I think is poorly understood as people tend to fling around the term without understanding that the word can describe almost diametrically opposed things.
Linus is advocating for what you might call personal tolerance; as a human being, you should be prepared for the fact that not everyone in the world is like you, not everyone shares your standards or your culture, and that some people may be abrasive by your standards in a way that is acceptable in their culture or microculture. (And while it is talked about less, the alternative can occur too, where you encounter a culture that is more deferential than you are used too, and similar misunderstandings can easily occur.) It is for each person to accept these differences and learn to deal with them.
The American left/liberalism has embraced a different definition of "tolerance", what I might call social or societal tolerance, which is that each individual is responsible for learning what is offensive to the person you are dealing with, and treating them as the other individual expects. This is what has given birth to the concept of "political correctness", and this is the domain in which "You have offended me" takes on moral overtones; you have abrogated your social responsibilities in that case.
I mention this without endorsing one or the other. (I'll freely admit to thinking the former is generally more scalable and a better idea, but I could easily write an argument in favor of the latter as well. As a personal matter I tend towards a mix of both.) I just don't think you can really understand the full context of this discussion without having this idea clearly in your head.
- jeltz 13y agoThis is similar to the difference between Ask and Guess cultures. http://lesswrong.com/lw/375/ask_and_guess/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/375/ask_and_guess/