3 ms·
I'm not so sure you're interpreting that quote correctly. The Apollo space program didn't really start out with the declaration that "we're going to put a man o
by swombat 18y ago
I'm not so sure you're interpreting that quote correctly. The Apollo space program didn't really start out with the declaration that "we're going to put a man on the moon", it started out with a bunch of rocket scientists in Germany trying to lob bombs onto London. And before that, of course, there were even simpler attempts to build rocket-like devices.
Then, looking at the Apollo program itself, they didn't send someone straight to the moon. There were many simpler missions before they finally culminated in the moon landings.
The point of that quote is that even something so monumentally complex as the Apollo space program started with something simpler that worked, and evolved up from there.
I would suggest that revolutionary start-ups are precisely the ones that need to start simple, because it's not quite clear where they're going, so they need to figure out the simplest thing that works before making it more complex. Evolutionary start-ups, on the other hand, can probably afford to stand on the shoulders of previous attempts and start with something a little more complex, because they already know what works - but even that is risky.
- mixmax 18y agoNo, the Apllo program didn't start with rocks and sticks and built from there: If you go back far enough you can probably assert that everything derives from fire. but I think that's kind of missing the point. Of course they did tests. Of course they fired small rockets in the Mohave desert. But they did it all with one simple goal in mind: Putting a man on the moon. They knew exactly where they were going, and everything they did was just preparations for that. They knew that their final, and only, test would come the day they launched. The difference between evolution and revolution as I described it above lies primarily in whether you know the goal.
- abi 18y agoIt's definitely possible to take the evolution route (I don't quite agree that there's a clear dichotomy between revolution and evolution) and have a goal in mind. I'm sure Steve Jobs had already envisioned the App Store when he was working on iPhone 1.0. The difference between complex and simple lies in focus. The reason it's not possible to build complex systems from scratch is that you just can't focus on so many different parts/components and integrate them together as well. Apple builds successful products because they focus on a few things rather than do everything all at once. As for your other point, I believe Gall's law (your quoted bit) holds true for all cases but the other rule I added about each intermediate step being useful might only be true for some cases (perhaps, more for user-facing products). You're right that the blogpost might only pertain to "evolutionary products and startups". I wrote it with software in mind but my guess is that it's also mostly true for other kinds of things. I need to think further about them.