2 ms·
> The whole point is that he is not suppressing the urges. Freud would disagree and so do I. > you snidely suggested that that he must be suppressing some "n
by lazyjones 13y ago
> The whole point is that he is not suppressing the urges.
Freud would disagree and so do I.
> you snidely suggested that that he must be suppressing some "natural urges"
Same thing Linus did in the last paragraph. :-/
> your reply to be a perfect example of what Linus is trying to avoid ("fake politeness[...]"
That makes no sense. I am just trying to analyze and understand his behavior. There's no emotion involved at all.
- pasiaj 13y ago>> The whole point is that he is not suppressing the urges. > Freud would disagree and so do I. So one can not curse out of anger or frustration without there being suppressed urges? I do not think Freud would agree with you.
- lazyjones 13y ago> So one can not curse out of anger or frustration without there being suppressed urges? If the "cursing" involves typing things on a keyboard, then yes, I believe there are some things (urges, actions) being suppressed.
- vacri 13y agoFreud's own work is considered heavily out of date, even by Freudian psychologists. Appealing to his image doesn't really lend weight to your argument.
- jeltz 13y agoFreudian analysis in debate is something I find incredibly rude, one of the rudest things you can do to a person. I realize you might not have meant that way, which is why I generally do not call people out on it. But in this discussion rudeness seemed like a relevant thing to think about. By the way most of the theories of Freud have since long been discredited by the scientific community.