5 ms·
You've obviously never worked in an office, or you have taken a big step away from reality. The things Linus mentions are what happens as a result of supposed
by stephenr 13y ago
You've obviously never worked in an office, or you have taken a big step away from reality.
The things Linus mentions are what happens as a result of supposed "professionalism".
People are emotional, reactionary creatures with very different needs.
These people are kernel developers, not 4 year olds. If they commit code that is fucking stupid, they should be called fucking stupid for it. As was shown on a recent post - Linus reverted to swearing in his native tongue because English wasn't sufficiently rude enough for him, and those who let the fuckup slip through all admitted their fault and identified that they would take steps to ensure it didn't happen again.
- oellegaard 13y agoJust a note. Once I worked at a tele provider and I accidentally messed up some contract and we lost $6000 - that was in a very professional working environment. I was called into the office of the manager and was told (not in a specifically pleasant way) how stupid my actions were. This taught me an important lesson about caring for details. In open source, the office is the mailing list. Life is tough. Say sorry and make sure it doesn't happen again. Move on - and outside the US, I think swearing is pretty common if you do something stupid - working environment or not. I don't think this means that we all have to adhere to US standards.
- Tyrannosaurs 13y agoThe important difference is that the mailing list is public, your humbling was private. I'm guessing your co-workers knew you'd been chewed out but how much worse would you have felt (I guess plenty) and how much more would you have learned (I guess nothing) had your dressing down been in public? Much of this isn't about some artificial standard for the sake of it, it's about getting the best out of people. Public beatings have been shown not to do that. If the OSS community wants to behave this way then it can but ultimately it's going to drive a bunch of people away, or cow them into not really speaking up for fear of retribution and as a result will likely miss out on valuable contributions.
- nknighthb 13y agoI much prefer being publicly berated. There's no question of what was said, and there is pressure on the one doing the berating to get it right and not be unreasonable in their expectations. It further urges consistency -- if one person is dressed down for doing X in Y circumstances, failure to do the same to the next person who makes the same error will either reveal obvious bias, or make clear that the original berating was undeserved.
- Tyrannosaurs 13y agoResearch shows that you're not typical - most people find it massively demotivating. There seems to be a thing here with a lot of people saying "I work like this and like it". That's fine but the worst mistake you can make with others is often assuming that everyone else is like you. a lot of management science is bullshit but alongside the nonsense there is actual quantitative research about how people behave and so on. There is possibly a discussion to be had around whether programmers (or more strictly people with the potential to be good programmers as that's what you want to optimise for, rather than the people who are currently programmers) are typical but as a hypothesis I'd rather go with programmers behave broadly as other people do.
- nknighthb 13y ago> Research shows that you're not typical - most people find it massively demotivating What is "it", exactly? Any public criticism? Public belittling (which is severely different from a proper dressing down)? Swearing? There's a lot mixed in here. And does research conclusively establish a significantly different reaction to otherwise identical acts in public vs private? > I'd rather go with programmers behave broadly as other people do. Even if programmers behave broadly as other people do, that doesn't mean they'd have the same reaction to the same behavior in two very different scenarios. Our dressing-downs[1] are as likely to come from our peers as our management. And even when they come from managers, we have a much different relationship with them. We are in positions of relative power and economic security, as well as positions of trust. A manager is more peer or patron than overlord, and we are more agent than minion. This is a very different dynamic than most jobs. I question the relevance of any research on this that doesn't specifically target highly-skilled fields with economically-secure workers. [1] Dressings down? Can you make bandages out of soft feathers?
- nl 13y agoYou've obviously never worked in an office, or you have taken a big step away from reality. Perhaps you have never worked in a good office, on a good team where people respect each other. These people are kernel developers, not 4 year olds. If they commit code that is fucking stupid, they should be called fucking stupid for it. Why? It's rude and additionally it doesn't seem to achieve anything positive that can't be achieved more politely.
- ricw 13y agoYes it can. Direct criticism leads to more honesty, leads to a more productive work environment. Just grow some balls and learn to deal with direct criticism..
- jonahx 13y agothis is a false dichotomy. the choice is not between "be polite and evasive" and "be honest and abusive". it's easy to be direct and honest without being abusive. see my example in another reply: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6051057 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6051057
- flumbaps 13y agoIt's not that hard to give honest direct criticism without being abusive. Not knowing the difference indicates that you're a terrible leader. Belittling anyone who refuses to tolerate abuse as needing to "grow some balls" is utterly ridiculous. I wouldn't work for anyone with your attitudes.
- nl 13y agoI appreciate direct criticism. Fortunately I also have enough balls to refuse to stand for people being rude to me. Politeness does not mean standing for incompetence.
- vacri 13y agoIt's rude and additionally it doesn't seem to achieve anything positive that can't be achieved more politely. It saves time when you don't have to carefully structure each criticism in a compliment sandwich and so forth. It's understood in this environment that that's how the story goes - the excerpts people see of 'linus being rude again' are tut-tutted by a bunch of people who've never read a single other message on the kernel mailing list.
- ealexhudson 13y agoSo lying is a result of "acting professionally", but swearing is natural and ok? I don't buy that "people" need to swear any more than they need to lie, or that the result of swearing is somehow less damaging/more productive than lying.
- gngeal 13y agoI don't buy that "people" need to swear any more than they need to lie, or that the result of swearing is somehow less damaging/more productive than lying. Lying is dishonorable, counterproductive in context of multiple cooperating people, and a really bad idea overall, purely objectively. Swearing, linguistics-wise, is indeed a completely normal ("natural and ok") trait (present to some extent in individuals of all cultures, gender, professions etc., even in some higher animals) that is orthogonal to anyone's performance. How could you possibly equate these two is beyond me.
- paganel 13y ago> How could you possibly equate these two is beyond me. I'd say is a cultural thingie. Compared to other languages English has very few swear words/expressions, for example in my native language you could swear at someone by saying something like "fuck your mother's dead relatives" (it sounds way worse in original, trust me). If someone were to say that to my face my first instinct would be to see if I can beat him right there on the spot (and if yes, would I risk going to prison for hospitalizing him?) and if no then I'd think of swearing back with something even harsher (while looking for an escape route). On the other hand everybody lies, that's why we have things like contracts etc, it's assumed that at some point or another we'll stop telling the truth.
- Jare 13y agoSwearing affects the form; lying affects the content. For obvious reasons, it is much easier to maintain meaningful communication ignoring form than ignoring content. So, yes, swearing can be much less damaging; it doesn't always HAVE to be less damaging, but in the case at hand it seems to work wonderfully.
- pavlov 13y agoYou've obviously never worked in an office, or you have taken a big step away from reality. The things Linus mentions are what happens as a result of supposed "professionalism". When has Linus actually worked in an office? Would he really know what it's like? AFAIK, he moved from Finland to USA in 1998 to work at Transmeta. He was already famous at that time, and presumably could dictate his working terms. I recall reading an interview that suggested he was mostly working from home on the Linux kernel already back then. Maybe that's why his notion that "professionalism" equals neckties and backstabbing seems like a caricature out of a '90s TV show.
- hahainternet 13y agoWhy would it matter? He's correct about office environments.
- pavlov 13y agoNot in my experience. (Anecdotal evidence - we all produce it and it always smells the same.)
- corresation 13y ago"Office politics" is a universally known behavior of most offices, and I suspect that maybe you were simply not paying attention to it if you don't think it exists.
- xradionut 13y agoHow many different varied offices and environments have you worked in?
- cmpxchg8 13y agoBeing professional means you leave emotions at the door (like in poker) and back your argument with data. The algorithm might be stupid, that doesn't make the person stupid. Ad hominem attacks are a very poor way to defend your point and will result in people not wanting to work with you. Saying "grow a thicker skin" won't make it better either. Linus is a brilliant engineer, his people skills not so brilliant. But we all knew that already.
- jonahx 13y agothis is a false dichotomy. it's possible to be succint, harsh, and directly to the point without swearing or being abusive. for example, off the top of my head: "stephen, this code is riddled with basic errors and is completely unacceptable. please fix a, b, and c immediately and know that if you make mistakes like this again, your contributions will no longer be welcome." versus: "stephen, WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH YOU??!?! seriously, a FUCKING JUNIOR DEV would not make mistakes like this. why are you wasting my time with this FUCKING BULLSHIT? FIX IT NOW OR YOU'RE FIRED!" imagine in both cases the person writing to you has only a professional relationship (ie, is not a friend who has the type of relationship with you where the 2nd paragraph would be an establish, half-joking form of communication)
- karma_fountain 13y agoExactly, you can save time, be understood about what is wrong, and not have to "criticism sandwich" everything. You just shouldn't be rude.
- kghose 13y agoI upvoted you and would like to add a reply to emphasize how correct I think this is. honest open criticism != rude dick It takes a little more work, because you have to think carefully about your words and calm down, but that action itself makes a) the criticism more useful b) creates a frame where the criticism is more likely to be acted on and leave no resentment Also, I believe that apologizing is something we should do more often. As in "I don't apologize for my behavior" is not as good a path as "I'm sorry I blew up, but I did have a point".
- newbie12 13y agoIn my experience, the closer you are to action the more swearing (sales, press, front-line dev) and the polite stuff is more for the office bureaucrats who aren't critical to the success of the organization. There's something refreshingly blunt and urgent about the 2nd case. (Edit: My experience includes Fortune 100 in consumer tech and finance)
- jonahx 13y ago
- w1ntermute 13y ago> As was shown on a recent post - Linus reverted to swearing in his native tongue Actually, he swore in Finnish in that post, and as a Swedish-speaking Finn, Swedish, and not Finnish, is his native language. http://www.muktware.com/news/2857/which-linus-torvalds%E2%80%99-native-language-finnish-or-swedish http://www.muktware.com/news/2857/which-linus-torvalds%E2%80...
- EnderMB 13y ago> You've obviously never worked in an office, or you have taken a big step away from reality. I understand the whole "you've obviously never ..." thing that people do to state that their experiences are not representative, but it just sounds dickish in your post. I think it's pretty obvious that the person you are replying to has worked in an office, and has had a good dose of reality.
- kenny_r 13y agoI looked up the mail you're referring to: https://lkml.org/lkml/2013/7/13/132 https://lkml.org/lkml/2013/7/13/132 My Finnish colleague seems to like it. I'm told shouting "Perkele!" is a great stress-reliever.
- kisstheblade 13y agoYeah "perkeleen vittupää" is a pretty "bad" swear/insult. You really have to be upset about somebody to call them that. "Fucking cunthead" is a pretty direct translation :)
- Skalman 13y agoIf they commit code that is fucking stupid, they should be called fucking stupid for it. Why? Wouldn't you achieve the same thing by calling the commit fucking stupid? Why resort to personal attacks?
- flumbaps 13y agoYou really shouldn't call people "fucking stupid" for making mistakes in code. They're clearly not stupid, they're writing complex computer code for a big project. Calling them "fucking stupid" is as much a lie as throwing out empty compliments, and just as counter productive. Smart people don't need to be beaten into shape, just like they don't need to be mollycoddled. If you're being abusive in the workplace, it's because of your own emotional needs, not the people you're being abusive to. If someone commits code that is fucking stupid then by all means call the code fucking stupid. But then actually take the time to identify the cause for the mistake. Is that programmer following best practises? Are they being careless? Are they working on something they don't have the expertise for? Are they spread too thin? If you identify the problem you can try to fix it. Instead of abuse, you should be giving clear and direct instructions on how to not make mistakes like that ever again. If you call someone "fucking stupid" then you incorrectly identify the problem and, moreover, you're being abusive, which can be very harmful.
- scotty79 13y agoWhen you do stupid thing do you carefully watch out to exclaim "I did a fucking stupid thing!" instead of "I am so fucking stupid!"? Calling someone stupid after he did something stupid is different than calling him that as a main point of his semiannual performance review.
- kyllo 13y agoSpeaking of his native tongue--based on my own experiences working with international colleagues, I think there's also a little bit of a cultural component to his behavior. This obviously doesn't hold true for all individuals, but Americans tend to prefer the "Let's all hold hands and sing kumbaya" type of social dynamic. "If you don't have something nice to say, don't say anything." Much emphasis is placed on not hurting anyone's feelings, and maintaining the appearance that everyone likes everyone else. Northern Europeans, meanwhile, tend to prefer the "We're all adults here, so let's cut the bullshit and say exactly what we think." Being honest and genuine is more important than being liked. This part, I find really significant: And hey, I don't actually think we've personally even had any problems. And I realize that you may react very strongly and get nervous about us having problems, but realistically, do you actually expect to like all the other kernel engineers? And equally importantly, not everybody has to like you, or necessarily think they have to be liked by you. OK? That strikes me as a very Northern European view, that is not as likely to be shared by most Americans. It's just not how we're socialized in America. And too often, "professionalism" gets defined as "American style," while anything un-American is deemed unprofessional, which is not quite right.
- gregd 13y agoThose things don't happen as a result of professionalism. They happen because some people can be assholes. Assholes don't care if a workplace is "professional" or a fucking free-for-all.