3 ms·
I fundamentally agree--yet, at the same time, it'd be so nice if a paper could just point to a URL for a Docker container, and you could pull it and immediately
by derefr 13y ago
I fundamentally agree--yet, at the same time, it'd be so nice if a paper could just point to a URL for a Docker container, and you could pull it and immediately execute the program.
- limmeau 13y agoHowever, I fear that a Docker container in 2023 will be as useful as a Plex86 VM image today...
- DannoHung 13y agoThe issue isn't really software then, it's hardware obsolescence.
- limmeau 13y agoThat example still completely in the realm of software obsolescence. The LXC API may not be around in 2023's Linux kernels any more, just like Plex86 has been abandoned (and I doubt that Plex86 runs unchanged on a modern x86_64 machine with a 3.x kernel). But hardware obsolescence is a valid issue, too. That's why I suggested Bochs as a lowest common denominator in another comment.
- DannoHung 13y agoWhy are you limited to using the 2023 version of the kernel? Are they going to erase the 2013 version of the kernel in 2018?
- limmeau 13y agoNo, but maybe your Apple GeForce 5500 graphics drivers and the drivers for the ansible network haven't been backported, so you'd have to run headless and offline. Or in another layer of VM, or two if the VM's virtual hardware is still too new for the old kernel. At some point, you'd just start to believe unseen that the paper's authors were probably right.
- vidarh 13y agoThe point is not that everyone will recompute everything, but ensuring that it remains possible.
- vidarh 13y agoThe point is not for everyone to recompute everything, but to ensure that it remains possible, and with known, well defined hardware platforms capable of running a specific bundle of software, it will likely reman possible for much longer than anyone cares about the specific papers.
- natejenkins 13y agoI am working on a startup addressing this exact problem. Docker sounds really exciting although I haven't played much with it yet. Limmeau's concern below is a valid one. With the popularity of cloud computing centered around VMs, it seems like a wise choice to at least offer a VM as a worst-case option for recomputing an experiment. As mentioned in the article, performance should be secondary when thinking about recomputation. A reasonable solution to the large downloads necessary is to spin up the VM on the server side and allow access to it either through the browser or through a terminal login.
- nickstinemates 13y agoYou should definitely give Docker a try. Drop by the IRC channel and you'll find a great community ready to give you some advice.