6 ms·
Do you know how much musicians copy from each other? If you really want to take this logic to it's full extend then be prepared to a much much more diluted pay
by ThomPete 13y ago
Do you know how much musicians copy from each other?
If you really want to take this logic to it's full extend then be prepared to a much much more diluted payback.
Music has become a commodity business. Deal with it.
- tptacek 13y agoThat argument is also stale. Your favorite artists might be Girl Talk and Public Enemy, but Parquet Courts and Neko Case don't do a whole lot of sampling, do they? Again: the problem is not that music is "becoming a commodity business". IT CLEARLY IS NOT, because consumers don't want "commodity music"; they demand Yeezus, Magna Carta, Hail To The King and Random Access Memories. A commodity business is one in which prices are driven down by substitutes. But unlawfully downloaded copies of Daft Punk albums aren't a real market substitute for authorized copies of Daft Punk albums. Instead, music is a market in which middlemen of varying stripes have achieved control over the market sufficient to dominate the returns for recording music in the first place. The middlemen of 2013 are actually worse in some ways than the middlemen of 1990; record labels worked on the VC model and signed artists were often ensured a middle-class standard of living, but today's middlemen are companies like Google that aren't in any way incentivized to compensate artists at all. Music has been made to seem like a commodity by what is in effect a monopsonistic cartel. But that commodity status is an illusion, not a valid market outcome.
- ThomPete 13y agoPeople choose between the choices they have. If Daft Punk didn't exist people would listen to something else and have the posters up on their wall of someone else. They wouldn't instead buy a car. The easier it is to learn and make the music, the more people will make music, the more competition there will be, the harder it is to make money. Music IS the product. That is by all intents and purposes of this discussion a commodity and the music industry which includes musicians copy each other all the time. How do you think musicans learn to play music? Do you think they learn it by purely taking theory and turning it into songs out of the blue or could it be that they learn a lot of songs other have played, transcribe and through that build their own sense of music. Copying existing music is the way most people learn. By copying others. You don't need samplers for that. The middlemen in the 90's decided who should get access to their distribution. It is a far cry from the ability for anyone today to put out their own records on their own terms. The ability for musicians to record a song once and sell it infinitely has nothing to do with being a musician. The copy of your original is NOT the you it's a copy and that is a commoditized business.
- tptacek 13y agoThe question isn't whether Daft Punk will or won't exist. It's whether people will pay for authorized copies of Daft Punk, or unlawfully download unauthorized copies. You keep using this term "commodity" as if it meant "any market where offerings have a low cost". But that's neither a good description of the music market nor a valid characterization of commodities markets, which include pork bellies which are used to make bacon like you might find in a bacon, lettuce and tomato sandwich as well as gold, silver, and crude oil, which aren't cheap. A commodity market is one in which good are standardized to the point where one provider's offering is as good as any other's, and so the only determinant of price is cost; commodities markets often feature low prices as a result of competition. But Daft Punk isn't competing with Blaft Smunk and Zaft Tunk for who can offer the cheapest dance album. Music consumers demand Daft Punk and will not accept substitutes. You comments pretend that what's happening is that music consumers are driving prices down by avoiding artists who don't pay for licensing on consumer-friendly terms. But of course that's not what's happening. Instead, consumers acquire content that isn't licensed at or near "free" by unlawful mechanisms ranging from ad-supported P2P networks to Google's ad-supported Youtube site. P2P networks and Youtube don't reliably remit any payments to artists, and their significant impact on pricing is a market inefficiency; they're free-riders. What makes music appear to be a commodity market is the coercive impact of technology coupled with the market power of a cartel of specific buyers which makes it untenable for almost any artist to sell music directly to consumers. Music is made cheap by piracy, and cheaper still by the fact that a monopsony effectively controls authorized sales. I might feel like these were pedantic points, except that you're the one who keeps invoking economics in defense of the status quo, as if there were real economic principles supporting it.
- ThomPete 13y agoYes it is the question whether or not they exist. People will buy something else. It's not like people walked around saying. "I wish there was a band like Daft Punk." People like music naturally and depending on what time in history you lived in will like different types of music, but music is the fundamental product that people are buying. They would buy more or less whatever was available to them, cause that is how music works. Repetition and the more you hear a song the more you will end up liking it. You can choose to play a game of semantics and not accept the term commodity but the reality is that 50 years ago people paid for music because there was real cost involved, just like they today still pay for a concert. Today to be in a position to have a band the price has come down many many times. That's the primary commodity part. There is no "hard labour" involved for most of the music you hear today. They understand that they should pay for it and there is a classic supply/demand principle in play. With digital distribution and copying there isn't the same supply/demand principles in play. The artist don't pay for the medium that holds their music, they barely pay for the recording anymore, the consumers do themselves. This is the difference in value. I like the music of bands and I am ready to support them, but I liked a lot of bands a lot before the internet and I didn't buy a fraction of what they were selling. This has all changed and it is at no cost to music in genreal only to the individual musician. But I would much rather live in a world where record labels weren't the gatekeepers anymore. Both the musicians and their audience is much better off.
- oz 13y agoYes, we all know that "great artists steal." And of course, every musician has been inspired by some one before. There are only so many chords. But that's a red herring. When musicians directly copy another's work, i.e., sampling, don't they need to get permission? And if the owner of sampled work says "no, you can't have it", then that's that. Again, easy to do =! ethical. Mass surveillance has become widespread. Deal with it.
- ThomPete 13y agoSampling isn't the only way to directly copying other peoples music.
- tptacek 13y agoMusicians who play covers are required to arrange licensing fees.
- ThomPete 13y agoWe aren't just talking about covers. We are talking about passages, melodies, riffs, fills, rythms etc. It is much more complex than you seem to be aware of.
- tptacek 13y agoThat's a weird thing to say. These are all questions that copyright jurisprudence has had to deal with. The copyrightability of riffs should be well known to anyone who watched MTV in the Vanilla Ice years.
- ThomPete 13y agoWhy? Playing a melody over a different chord progression or a re-arragned progression, different instrument, add a few lifts etc. the possibilities are litterally endless. You can't apply copyright to these things unless they are blatantly obvious, which they in most cases aren't and not something that really matters to the bigger picture. But the actual act of copying them. Most music is composed that way. Thats also called inspiration. Which is just a nicer way of saying a less obvious way of copying.