3 ms·
Then so are radios. Artists are only forced to do what they did in the beginning, namely performing. They can do that on top of selling for scale. They have b
by ThomPete 13y ago
Then so are radios.
Artists are only forced to do what they did in the beginning, namely performing. They can do that on top of selling for scale.
They have been fortunate enough being one of the first industries that got to take advantage of the scaleability technology has allowed for.
There is no natural born right to make a lot of money from recording once and then reselling the same piece without any additional cost. Thousands of brilliant musicians never got a record deal when the record labels where the gatekeeper, now everyone has a shot.
But everything comes with a price and so does this opportunity.
- tptacek 13y agoNo, radios are not analogous; artists can refuse to have their songs played on the radio, but cannot effectively refuse to have their work pirated. There are no natural born rights to anything. In the state of nature, humans contend not with audio licensing but with not being eaten by bears or having their heads split open by other humans. Past that, everything is a question of the social contract, and in our social contract, you are usually not entitled to consume the fruits of someone else's labor on your own unilaterally defined terms. The same logic you use to entitle yourself to download music without the artist or owner's permission is the logic I could use to entitle myself to download your application's database.
- ThomPete 13y agoArtists can refuse to have their songs played on Spotify. And people can copy the music played on the radio. There is no one hindering the musician in keeping their recorded song to themselves. Just as I can keep my application database to myself. The artist can even choose not to record it an only perform with it. Just like they did when they started out playing music. The developer cant. I can just as the artist put up my DB and ask for people to pay for it. And people can just as with music copy it if I choose to do so. But the artist can also choose to simply charge for performing the song, an option a developer do not have unless they make a service at which there are ongoing costss I think you need to rethink your position on this one mate. It's not Spotify you need to blame it's technology in general.
- tptacek 13y agoNo, they can't; artists are between a rock and a hard place w/r/t Spotify, because if they aren't made available on one or more of the major paid services, they (a) are pirated merciless and (b) have to compete (and inevitably fail) for the promotion and monetization of their own work with services like Youtube. I'm not saying Spotify is uniquely to blame for this situation, only that they're a part of the situation.
- ThomPete 13y agoThis is absolutely no different than being on the app store and selling your app on the website. You are trying to create a difference where none really exist. Take it from someone who have both been a musician and made apps. Furthermore the new generations don't even have to change, this is the reality they grow up in and are free to make their choices. Spotify is a far better ally for all musicians than record labels where for a select few.
- oz 13y agoThomas, I honestly don't know how you do it. Every time the copyright debate comes up, you tirelessly try to inject reason into it. But they're not having it. I simply cannot, for the life of me, understand why people think that it's their RIGHT to copy the works of others. I'm no saint - I love me some isohunt - but I don't have the self-entitled mindset that says "I'm supposed to be able to pirate your stuff, your hard work be damned." "Oh, well technology has outdated their business model, artists need to get with the times!" Well technology has updated the NSA's surveillance model, but everybody's mad? If ease of copying is a justification for piracy, then ease of data collection is a justification for mass surveillance. But the HN crowd is unaffected, because they're relying on SaaS to make money. I keep waiting for the day when someone invents a way to reverse engineer webapps, and all and sundry will be able to download $SociaLocalMobileStartuply.com's code, and freely use it to create their own competitor to it. Then we'll see the hypocrisy of these entitled pirates. You don't have a right to people's stuff. If you did, it'd be your stuff. Keep up the fight, Thomas. You're a better man than I am.
- ThomPete 13y agoDo you know how much musicians copy from each other? If you really want to take this logic to it's full extend then be prepared to a much much more diluted payback. Music has become a commodity business. Deal with it.
- tptacek 13y agoThat argument is also stale. Your favorite artists might be Girl Talk and Public Enemy, but Parquet Courts and Neko Case don't do a whole lot of sampling, do they? Again: the problem is not that music is "becoming a commodity business". IT CLEARLY IS NOT, because consumers don't want "commodity music"; they demand Yeezus, Magna Carta, Hail To The King and Random Access Memories. A commodity business is one in which prices are driven down by substitutes. But unlawfully downloaded copies of Daft Punk albums aren't a real market substitute for authorized copies of Daft Punk albums. Instead, music is a market in which middlemen of varying stripes have achieved control over the market sufficient to dominate the returns for recording music in the first place. The middlemen of 2013 are actually worse in some ways than the middlemen of 1990; record labels worked on the VC model and signed artists were often ensured a middle-class standard of living, but today's middlemen are companies like Google that aren't in any way incentivized to compensate artists at all. Music has been made to seem like a commodity by what is in effect a monopsonistic cartel. But that commodity status is an illusion, not a valid market outcome.
- rmc 13y agoThey have been fortunate enough being one of the first industries that got to take advantage of the scaleability technology has allowed for. Huh? Read some history. The Industrial Revoltuion (starting around 1750) was the first example of technology and scale. It was quite effective.