5 ms·
> Dual gigabit, wi-fi and the ability to run Ubuntu makes this very interesting for a "home router / hub" type device. For that type of appliance, I'd rather h
by josteink 13y ago
> Dual gigabit, wi-fi and the ability to run Ubuntu makes this very interesting for a "home router / hub" type device.
For that type of appliance, I'd rather have OpenWRT than Ubuntu. Comes pre-fit to the job at hand. And with a reasonable secure configuration by default, as opposed to whatever the thing you've hacked together yourself accidentally leaves open.
That said: Having medium-powered, cheap, compact and appliance-like general purpose computing available is certainly a nice change.
Big computers with lots of cores and gigahertz gets boring pretty quickly. These kinds of things sort of takes computing a bit more back to its roots.
- patrickod 13y agoI was thinking the same thing. I'm guessing though that it wouldn't be too hard to put OpenWRT on the box?
- TobbenTM 13y agoOr any other Linux firewall (IPCop, Smoothwall, Untangle...) for that matter.
- s_baby 13y agoNo thanks, OpenWRT package management is awful. None of the advantages of OpenWRT apply to a machine that has enough resources to run a typical distribution.
- yuvadam 13y agoWhat exactly makes `opkg` awful? Sure, it's no aptitude or pacman, but you have to remember that OpenWRT is a full fledged distribution (package manager and all) that fits on an image of less than 4MB!
- s_baby 13y agoopkg upgrade can brick your device. >Sure, it's no aptitude or pacman, but you have to remember that OpenWRT is a full fledged distribution (package manager and all) that fits on an image of less than 4MB! It's nice when resources are a limitation. But that's not the case here.
- brigade 13y agoI ran 'opkg upgrade' once and it deleted itself. I've run into lots of other annoyances with it (e.g. its database is rather slow), but that's the one that sticks in my memory.
- jevinskie 13y agoI asked myself why I was toying around with OpenWRT and DD-WRT when my N66U router can easily run Debian with a 600 MHz MIPS CPU and 256 MB of RAM! Why suffer the pain of a half-Debian when I can have FULL Debian? I have a Bus Pirate wired up to the router's UART and a JTAG adapter attached to the JTAG port. Now if only I could get the CFE bootloader to talk to my PC so I can boot the kernel over TFTP and run debian installer or a debootstrapped rootfs. =( I can't even get ping! EDIT: This is the basic path that I am taking: http://people.zoy.org/~walken/wgt634u/HOWTO.html http://people.zoy.org/~walken/wgt634u/HOWTO.html
- s_baby 13y agoSays you should plug tftp into wan but doesn't mention you should use cross-over cable in that case.
- makomk 13y agoIt's very unusual that you need to use cross-over cables these days, almost everything is autodetecting.
- evol262 13y agoOnly GigE autodetects, and the NIC in his system is unknown.
- makomk 13y agoYou've got that slightly backwards. GigE always has auto-MDIX support, slower Ethernet ports might not support it but generally do in all semi-modern hardware.
- s_baby 13y agoReally? Didn't know that. Still might be worth a shot in my eyes since it's unclear to me if autodetect happens before or after an OS bootup.
- jevinskie 13y ago
- Everlag 13y agopfsense is basically designed to take a computer and turn it into a high quality router. Very impressive, I recommend you check it out if you get the chance. Sadly it doesn't have any arm support whatsoever which is extremely disappointing.
- aclevernickname 13y ago> I'd rather have OpenWRT than Ubuntu. That pretty much guarantees you've never looked into pfSense [1] [1] http://pfsense.com http://pfsense.com
- josteink 13y agoWhile that looks a bit more sophisticated than my current setup, it wont fit nor run on my actual router. And to me, that's a deal-breaker. I like having my setup sub-divided into separate things, in small, dedicated boxes. I don't want to have to run a PC as router in my otherwise neat and tidy home. I used to do that, mind you, but I don't feel like going back to that anytime soon.
- aclevernickname 13y ago> I don't want to have to run a PC as router in my otherwise neat and tidy home. Oh, you mean like one of these things? http://itzr.en.alibaba.com/product/520930686-50069247/Firewall_moterboard_ISD525_support_6_Intel_1000M_lan.html http://itzr.en.alibaba.com/product/520930686-50069247/Firewa... yeah, I bet it's really rough to find space in your house for that. it's a shame, too; I got a quote for $45 each in lots of 20 on that unit. I can easily sell them for triple that price, with pfsense installed, and a cheap plastic housing.
- zobzu 13y agoopenwrt is nice but if you're able to run a full stack then why not? besides, you could potentially run openwrt on this too anyways...