7 ms·
The Case for Abolishing the DHS
- Dirlewanger 13y agoYeah, while I'm sure a good deal of the public feels repugnance toward DHS, anyone short of a much-needed cowboy like Rand Paul ain't shutting down this abomination. More government is all the rage nowadays, haven't you noticed?
- betterunix 13y agoI doubt that the majority of Americans feel repugnance toward the DHS. Most people I have met seem to believe that the DHS is important to keep us and our children safe from terrorists. Most people fall victim to the classic "something must be done, this is something, and therefore it must be done" fallacy.
- Dirlewanger 13y agoSorry, when I wrote that I was thinking the TSA. Forgot that the DHS is more of a shell organization.
- tsotha 13y agoRand Paul couldn't do it either, any more than Reagan could shut down the Dept. of Education. It has to be done in Congress, and there's no appetite for shutting down anything, ever, in Congress. The reason we have fourteen separate agencies with intelligence operations is as they lose the trust of elected leaders new ones are created, leaving the old ones intact.
- JonSkeptic 13y agoTalk about sensationalist news. "The Case for Abolishing the DHS". It may be one of the scariest departments in the government right now, but it serves a fundamental purpose: to secure the nation from the many threats we face. *http://www.dhs.gov/about-dhs http://www.dhs.gov/about-dhs). It should be steered back towards protection (and probably toward creating a better mission statement as well), not dismantled. When dealing with code and servers, sometimes you have to delete something and start over and it usually sucks to have to do it; imagine how bad it would be with an entire DEPARTMENT of the government. The article states that there are 15 vacancies at the top: this is an opportunity. Update it, fill it with new, ethical, honest leadership and it could be everything it was originally meant to be. Shame on Businessweek for adding nothing to the discourse but for an emotional headline.
- dllthomas 13y agoShutting down DHS wouldn't necessarily mean shutting down everything that falls under the DHS umbrella. As recently as 2000 there was no DHS. It was created to improve coordination between agencies; if it's not doing a good job of that, then split them apart again.
- RyanZAG 13y agoAs a non-American, the DHS has always come across to me as some form of large scale elaborate joke. I'm genuinely curious if the department you are spending billions of dollars on has actually accomplished anything at all of any practical use?
- mpyne 13y agoAlmost everything DHS is doing now was being done before DHS. Even TSA was being handled by private security under FAA regulations, IIRC. So while it may seem like an elaborate joke, it's not. Coast Guard does search and rescue work nearly every day, FEMA responds to natural disasters, etc.
- ims 13y ago> Coast Guard does search and rescue work nearly every day Over 100 cases every day.
- forgotAgain 13y agoShame on Businessweek for adding nothing to the discourse but for an emotional headline. Thank you Business Week for participating in a rational discussion about our nation's deep dive into fear. It's time to raise our heads from the sand, take a look around, and start making a positive contribution to the world again.
- bgilroy26 13y agoThe number of downvotes the user has received despite representing the minority in the discussion here indicates they were right about the level of emotion.
- oofabz 13y agoThe DHS includes the Coast Guard, Customs, Immigration, and FEMA. Abolishing these critical functions would be like throwing the baby out with the bath water.
- cgi_man 13y agoAll of those functions existed before DHS. DHS can be abolished and those will be moved to other services.
- saryant 13y agoAnd those functions can be moved out of DHS, just as they were pre-9/11.
- wmeredith 13y agoAs stated in the article (RTFA), these could be moved out of the DHS bureaucracy as they were before 9/11.
- danso 13y agoI think the debate is not over whether to abolish the concept of Homeland Security period, but whether Homeland Security as an umbrella-department (that encompasses such agencies as TSA, FEMA, Secret Service) makes more sense than having these agencies as a part of other departments...the Secret Service used to be part of the Treasury, TSA could become part of the Dept. of Transportation, etc. It's not just about changing-names...in a large bureaucracy, the organization of agencies and officers is a real factor in how that bureaucracy effectively functions. In any case, I think DHS could be seen as an example as poorly conceived bureaucracy...it's a department that will forever be waging turf battles with the FBI, the NSA, and the DoD, among other groups in charge of our security.
- Shivetya 13y agoThis is the case for many of the "Department of" organization the United States has; it probably applies just as well to other countries similar organizations. The issue with removing the DHS is, most people see it only as Airport security and they WANT THAT GONE. How do you deal with the tens of thousands of unionized government workers who do that job? Do we just hide them elsewhere? I doubt it will ever be gone, even the Department of Education; only active since 1980; has produced no credible results and yet eats 69 billion a year. Many of the services people attribute to it are actually handled by other Departments. For the most part it just doles out grants - why can't that be elsewhere? We need to broaden our approach to reducing government agencies. First item on the agenda is consolidating or eliminating similar programs. Then from that eliminating programs that are obsolete or no longer needed. The list goes on and on. So just picking one isn't enough, its government that needs a rethink.
- cafard 13y agoPeople don't want to be perv-scanned, and they don't want to have to take their shoes off. I don't think they object to a 20th-Century level of inspection.
- rayiner 13y ago> has produced no credible results and yet eats 69 billion a year. Many of the services people attribute to it are actually handled by other Departments. For the most part it just doles out grants - why can't that be elsewhere? The purpose of the Department of Education isn't to "produce credible results." It's a welfare program for minorities, the poor, and the disabled (I don't meant that pejoratively). ~72% of that $65 billion goes to just three things: Pell Grants, Title I grants (direct aid to municipalities for the disadvantaged), and IDEA grants (direct aid to municipalities for the disabled). Sure, you're funneling money to the people statistically least likely to benefit from it, but that's not the point. The point is that everyone can get at least a minimum level of education, even if they are poor or have a learning disability. It's the minimum basic guarantee we give to people in a society where we pretend to be a meritocracy but tolerate dramatically unequal starting positions for different people. Municipalities could not provide this guarantee on their own. White flight in the 1960's and 1970's left inner city school districts decimated. E.g. Chicago Public Schools (CPS) is 86% black or hispanic and 87% low-income. 24% of the system's budget comes from federal sources (about $1.65 billion). 31% comes from the state, and 36% from local property taxes. Inner city schools in the U.S. are mostly similar in terms of demographics, and the result of a fragile political compromise. Middle class people fund the systems, but don't want to send their kids to schools that are 85-90% low-income minorities. As a result, you can tax them only so much before they just move out to the suburbs. State and federal funding keeps these school districts in existence, and with state budgets strapped as they are, the DoE is the lynchpin that keeps the whole thing from collapsing.
- at-fates-hands 13y agoThe ironic thing about the DHS was it was supposed to make the communication lines between the FBI, the CIA and other federal law enforcement agencies better. This is one of the major failings of what happened on 9/11 - a total lack of sharing of intelligence between the CIA and FBI. And here we are, almost 15 years later and nothing has changed or improved. Several commentators even argued if the DHS actually worked, several of the recent terror attacks would have been prevented. Either fix it, or get rid of it.
- mathattack 13y agoAdding a bureaucracy to improve communications is like adding a junior programmer to a late project. It totally misses the nature of the problem.
- mpyne 13y agoWell, it can make sense when the added bureaucracy aligns well with an unexpected functional requirement that otherwise cuts across organizational boundaries. Even if you don't move every agency under the new structure, simply having a single point of responsibility for that new function can help with communication flow. I think that's the real issue, is that functional requirements cropped up with no point of focus, but when they instituted a new agency to handle that they wrapped it up with a whole Department and a grab-bag of other tangentially-related agencies.
- mathattack 13y agoMaybe we're arguing the same thing. I kind of view it like... If there's a group of people who aren't talking, adding someone to facilitate communications doesn't add much. Improving the structure is better than adding on top of it. (This is sometimes why PMOs fail. Adding someone to make sense of a bunch of projects doesn't address why they weren't making sense previously)
- mpyne 13y agoRight, mere facilitation is no good, you need to give that new person directive authority and make that function their job. That's actually one of the things I'm struggling with in my current job. I oversee a collection of units that can easily track a certain pool of wastefully-utilized resources, but have no actual power to fix it. Those with actual directive authority over the individual elements of that pool have no incentive to correct things other than some guy 8 levels higher in the chain of command being irritated. And a third party that actually does the work that would get elements of this pool out of the pool drag their feet on it completely as for them it's "just admin". So I get to make reports on this waste everyday but with little effective power to fix it. Standing up an audit team that would have the power to fix requires resources, resources which no one seems to have now...
- ianstallings 13y agoThey're gonna have an uphill battle. The DHS is digging in, literally: http://www.gsa.gov/portal/content/133423 http://www.gsa.gov/portal/content/133423 DC institutions don't just go away. They fight tooth and nail to survive. So if you want to make it go away, prepare for a tough fight.
- ferdo 13y agoDHS is just another excuse for government contractors and unions to screw taxpayers.
- SwellJoe 13y agoAs far as I know, unions had no involvement in the creation of DHS. There are unions for DHS employees, just as there are for police, firefighters, etc...but, it's difficult for me to see a connection between the creation of the entity and those unions (which didn't exist as DHS employee unions until after DHS employees existed).
- ferdo 13y agoThey certainly were involved with smoothing out the rough patches in the beginning so they could get their piece of the pie: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/08/15/AR2005081501184.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/08... If one group is plundering another group, it makes little difference if they planned the plunder or are participating in the pillage after the raid.
- shill 13y ago"The U.S. Department of Homeland Security was a panicked reaction to the Sept. 11 attacks." The Hart-Rudman Commission recommended the creation of a National Homeland Security Agency in January of 2001. 9/11 panic was just the grease to ram a massive new bureaucracy through a congress controlled by the party of 'limited government'. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Commission_on_National_Security/21st_Century#Recommendations http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Commission_on_National_Sec...
- homosaur 13y agoYes, thank you. Everything post-9/11 was already on the table including DHS and the invasion of Iraq. 9/11 was for the Bush administration the simply a huge amount of grease on that wheel.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jivatmanx 13y agoYes, In fact, warantless wiretapping actually began 7 months before 9/11 http://digitaljournal.com/article/352455 http://digitaljournal.com/article/352455
- tsotha 13y agoBush didn't want to create the DHS. He was forced to by the "something must be done" crowd.
- homosaur 13y agoBush didn't want to wipe his butt without permission. That's what happens when you elect a weak leader with no experience and it's at the root of what's happening now with Obama. These guys were and are over their heads. It took Bush 6 years to grow a pair and actually stand up to Cheney. In a vacuum of leadership, stronger personalities dominate. Say what you will about that horrible troll monster, Cheney does not want for personality.
- sigzero 13y agoThe only thing needed is "information sharing" between the branches. We do not need the DHS for that.
- mtgx 13y agoThe DHS is about to become much worse soon, if the NYPD chief becomes its next boss: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130714/22284823796/up-against-wall-america-sen-chuck-schumer-touts-nypd-chief-ray-kelly-as-potential-next-head-dhs.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130714/22284823796/up-ag...
- vermontdevil 13y agoLast time a government agency was shut down was the Civil Aeronautics Board a long time ago. Can't recall any big agencies ever shutting down since the New Deal days.
- cpr 13y agoEven the name "Homeland Security" is an abomination. A "homeland" implies some kind of empire where there's a homeland, vs. outlands. The US should not be an empire (as it is today). It needs to return to being a simple nation among equals. Naming things has power; propaganda power if nothing else.
- newnewnew 13y agoWhat's the last federal bureaucracy that was abolished? This is never gonna happen. The size of government only goes one way.
- rayiner 13y agoThe size of the executive branch, including the postal service, peaked under Bush I: http://voices.washingtonpost.com/federal-eye/2010/09/how_many_federal_workers_are_t.html http://voices.washingtonpost.com/federal-eye/2010/09/how_man.... The current number of civilian executive branch employees is somewhere between where it was in 1964 and 1970. Adjusted for population, the executive branch is 40% smaller than it was during its peak under Nixon. Now, the picture gets murkier if you include contractors, but they're not part of the bureaucracy per se and it's not like contractors were doing poorly, employment wise, during the Cold War. Federal discretionary spending as a percentage of GDP is not exactly monotonically increasing: http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/RL34424.pdf http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/RL34424.pdf (17). Aside from the recent bailouts and stimulus in response to the recession, it's smaller in percentage terms than it was at the peak of big government in the 1970's. Both defense and non-defense components of discretionary spending are smaller as a percentage of GDP. As a practical matter, agencies don't get abolished. But they do get marginalized. Congress underfunds them relative to their original mandate, which forces them to shrink relative to the rest of the government and the rest of the economy. Is there hope of their doing this with DHS? Possibly. The long-term trend for all defense-related spending is sharply downward.
- djKianoosh 13y agoThe DHS budget is about 1/10 of the DOD budget. Just saying. If people want to make more of an impact... "Abolish" is a bit of a sensational word to use, especially because even if the department is shut down, all the agencies under it would shift to other departments or form new one(s).
- linuxhansl 13y agoNever going to happen. Power, once gained, will not be given up without a fight.