24 ms·
When male CEOs have daughters, relative pay for women at their firms goes up
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- nawitus 13y agoThe 'wage gap' actually mainly exists because women work less hours per year (up to ~20% less), and because they they work in different industries, and on the whole do different jobs. There's no discrimination.
- shadowfox 13y ago> There's no discrimination That is a fairly blanket statement that could use some backing up.
- quandrum 13y ago> There's no discrimination. Or rather that the discrimination is cultural and leads to life choices that make the wage gap structural. For example: We live in a culture that devalues young girls who excel in math, leading to lower achievement in this area[1]. By the time they go to college they choose differently than men and "work in different industries" [1] http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/2096370?uid=3739856&uid=2&uid=4&uid=3739256&sid=21102535661477 http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/2096370?uid=3739856&ui... for one example
- jami 13y agoAt least 40% of the wage gap isn't explained by the factors you cite. http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/labor/news/2013/04/09/59658/what-causes-the-gender-wage-gap/ http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/labor/news/2013/04/09...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoThis, alongside the recent "I put Mr. on my CV and got a job" is fascinating. I have had to rethink my own -isms over the years and its amazing just how prejudiced a right-on liberal has turned out to be - its almost as if I evolved in a totally different environment.
- RodericDay 13y agosame. well, different articles, but same story.
- smsm42 13y agoNote that plural of anecdote is not data. Neither is singular. I.e. how often do you read articles "I put Mr. on my CV and I still have no job" on the front page of HN? Clear setup for survivorship bias here[1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias
- eeky 13y agoThe gender wage gap is a well-documented, persistent, and worldwide phenomenon wherein women earn, on average, an estimated 9 to 18 percent less than men who have the same job descriptions and equivalent education and experience. If women were 18% more effective then men, then this is a surefire way to get rich: Step 1: Start a business and employ only women Step 2: Crush your competitors by being 18% more efficient Heck, even if you could find a way to cut costs by 1% in an industry, that's huge.
- RodericDay 13y agohow would you be more efficient? you would be just as efficient. unless you paid them 18% less. in which case you'd be exploiting their situation.
- Goronmon 13y ago>unless you paid them 18% less. in which case you'd be exploiting their situation. Well, yes, but the point is, ethics aside, if it was as simple as just hiring from an entire subset of potential employees who are cheaper than others, why wouldn't you do it in order to have a more profitable business?
- dylandrop 13y ago> why wouldn't you do it in order to have a more profitable business? > ethics aside You wouldn't do it because it would be unethical. That's like saying "besides the fact that eating a cheese burger is terrible for you, why wouldn't you eat a cheese burger?"
- papsosouid 13y agoBusinesses do things that are unethical to gain a competitive advantage all the time. Constantly. Every day. The fact that none of them are exploiting this "wage gap" is pretty strong support for the fact that the gap isn't actually real.
- rayiner 13y ago> The gender wage gap is a well-documented, persistent, and worldwide phenomenon wherein women earn, on average, an estimated 9 to 18 percent less than men who have the same job descriptions and equivalent education and experience. Interesting fact: in the U.S., single, childless, women under age 30 in urban areas earn more (10-20% in cities like New York) than single, childless, men under age 30. See: http://www.time.com/time/business/article/0,8599,2015274,00.html http://www.time.com/time/business/article/0,8599,2015274,00..... This is not to undervalue the statistic presented in the article, but I'm always a bit wary of comparisons involving "equivalent education and experience." In Denmark, for example, 20-30% of women (depending on the study) work part-time, versus 8-10% of men. How do you compute "equivalent" experience with a part-time worker? Is 5 years of working an 80% work-week "equivalent" to 4 years of working full-time? Does a 30-year old woman who took 2 years off after college for childcare reasons have "equivalent" experience to a 28-year old man who did not? Mathematically that works out, but part-time work and time out of the workforce are death-blows to a resume, far out of proportion with the resulting differential in actual amount of experience. I appreciate the ideas discussed in the article, but as the father of a daughter and the husband of a very ambitious woman, I have as slightly different perspective on the issue. Yes, it is important to avoid bias that results from the perceptions of men higher up in the hierarchy. At the same time, it's crucially important to look at the other irrationalities in the system. I think it's irrational that a women who takes a year off after the birth of a child is viewed by HR managers in a worse light than a man who took a year to backpack across Asia. I think it's irrational that men are never expected to be the ones who downshift their careers for a time to help raise kids. I think it's irrational that a period of downshifting is perceived as such a negative light in the first place.
- lsd5you 13y agoIt could be that the fact that urban single childless women earn more is a sign of things to come - a wave that with time will propogate to all ages and locations. Now it could also be that this is the point in their lives when society values women the most and this is why they get paid well at that age. Attractive young women are desirable as they make other (especially male) employees happier as well as having advantages in certain roles (e.g. sales). This 'premium' they enjoy is despite the risk of child birth being at its highest. I know that this is very cynical point of view, but is it unrealistic? I have definitely witnessed it and it could well be a significant factor. Male attitudes to women are an extremely strong force in shaping society, and we might well expect them to go as far as distorting the job market as well. I know it is a little bit sad to undermine female accomplishment in this manner, but it is quite plausible. This mechanism would also contribute the glass ceiling. It is desireable to have young,attractive women around, but not to promote them to the more senior positions.
- ryguytilidie 13y agoI think this is a phenomenon that extends well beyond pay. As members of congress have shown us, if you have a gay child you will go from a violent hate toward gays to a complete acceptance. If you need an abortion, abortions are somehow moral, even though they are the devils tool when used by others. It's things like this that made me wish that as a society, we were better at putting ourselves in the other persons shoes and having our viewpoint be based on something other than our thoughtless, engrained "morality".
- danielharan 13y ago+1 Putting ourselves in the other persons shoes is the critical skill for creating a better society. Too often we promote assholes at work, and ideologues to public office. Anyone that changes their mind due to facts is guilty of a "flip-flop". We need to start promoting leaders that have a track record of empathy for people that are unlike them.
- dominik 13y agoDo to others as you would have them do to you?
- jbooth 13y agoThat sounds like some sort of godless, unchristian commie talk.
- jamesaguilar 13y ago"Do unto others 20% better than you expect them to do to you, to correct for subjective error." -- Paraphrased from Linus Pauling, apparently. http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/138002-do-unto-others-20-better-than-you-would-expect-them http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/138002-do-unto-others-20-bet...
- JabavuAdams 13y agoDon't do unto others what you would not have them do to you?
- smsm42 13y ago
- khawkins 13y agoI believe the interpretation is wrong here. The hard data: Employee Wages F M Has firstborn sons: +0.8% -0.5% Has firstborn daughters: +1.1% +0.6% The story here is that when men have children, in general, female employees wages go up, by pretty much the same amount. However, when the firstborn is a boy, they are harder on men, and a little more respectful of women. I'd personally interpret this as men becoming more respectful of women when they witness their wives undergoing childbirth. However, the more drastic effect of child gender can be seen on male employee wages. I suppose the CEO might be channeling frustration in child-rearing a boy on his male employees.
- bru 13y agoI think that you have a very good point. The article should have been something like "Child Effect: When male CEO wife has a child, relative pay for women goes up". More of a "My wife gave birth and that helped me gain respect/comprehension towards women" than a "I have a daughter and I'm realizing she'll grow up in biased world, time to fix that beside me". Not that it is a better or worse conclusion, but quite different IMO.
- draugadrotten 13y agoCan you see if the study rules out covariance with other factors such as "CEO becomes older, raises employee wages" or "CEO works fewer hours per week, raises employee wages".
- dnautics 13y agoYeah, this definitely seems like "CEO has child, realizes children are expensive, so gives everyone a raise.... Unless it's a boy, in which case screw you, other guys".
- mathattack 13y agoThis study was just Denmark, no? It would be interesting to see if the data holds elsewhere.
- samstave 13y agoCheney had a gay, female child... why is he still such a cold-hearted bastard?
- jrockway 13y agoIs he actually, or is that the persona of the character he plays on TV?
- protomyth 13y agoor the persona he was given by the coverage... For example, President Ford was probably the most athletic President in the 1900's (he played LB). He is "known" more as clumsy and un-athletic from a set of comedy sketches[1]. 1) the real lesson is shoe choice is important as a politician
- jbooth 13y agoGiven that, at this point, there's no incentive for him to be a bastard besides the pleasure derived from it, it seems like that's actually just who he is.
- MartinCron 13y agoIt's all relative, imagine how much worse he would be if he only had straight male sons?
- smacktoward 13y agoIn Cheney's defense, he is a robot sent back from the future to put humanity on the road to destruction. So it's not really fair to expect a lot of empathy from him.
- rayiner 13y agoCheney is a war-monger, but in his defense, he came out in favor of gay marriage in 2004, before a lot of democrats who are on board with it now that it's not as controversial.
- 13y ago
- imgabe 13y agoIs there really a causal link here? They don't say anything about the size of the firms other than that they excluded very small firms. For medium to large size companies, how involved is the CEO in setting the salary for each employee?
- peter-fogg 13y agoWhat's more, it seems that a small wage increase (say, for the next hire after a CEO's child is born) could have an outsize effect on average pay at the company.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- schoper 13y ago> nature randomly determines the gender of each child Some evidence emerging that this isn't true: http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/07/130710182941.htm http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/07/130710182941.ht... People that tend to have more female babies: nurses. People that tend to have more male babies: CEOs. Could low testosterone (or low "fitness," per article) in a CEO cause him to have more daughters? Could it also cause relative pay for women to go up in their company? Why would that be?
- refurb 13y agoWhen was the last time you saw the CEO of a company decide how much they pay their employees, especially in a huge Fortune 500 company? Usually that's HRs job. Sure budgets are set high-up, but I think it's ridiculous to say that CEOs have a big impact in salaries.
- dspeyer 13y agoFrom the article: > The researchers also found that these effects were strongest at firms with 50 or fewer employees, which they attribute to the fact that CEOs at smaller firms are typically more directly involved in making decisions that affect the pay of individual workers than CEOs at much larger firms.
- tokenadult 13y agoAs with all preliminary research findings, this finding (reported here in a blog post from early 2011) needs replication before we can be sure it is reliable fact about the world. http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html As a father of three boys before I had my daughter, I really, truly desired to have a daughter in part to improve the "consciousness-raising" environment in my home both for myself and for my three boys. Perhaps I really have had a little bit of "male chauvinist pig" thinking on my own part counteracted by observing my daughter grow up at home. (My wife, on her part, grew up with four older brothers and only one (older) sister in her birth family, and she finds it very easy to take the male point of view.) What exactly could be done about this from the public policy point of view? Family sizes are smaller than ever--which means that some CEOs have only daughters, and no sons, but other CEOs who have children have only sons, and will not go out of their way to have daughters just to balance their parenting experience. Other than differences in family structure, which thus far are usually haphazard more than planned, it's not completely clear what life experiences can be provided to the current generation of business leaders or the next generation of young people growing up to make sure that they have a balanced view (and what would that be?) about the roles of men and women in the society of the future.
- bitops 13y ago> it's not completely clear what life experiences can be provided to the current generation of business leaders or the next generation of young people growing up to make sure that they have a balanced view (and what would that be?) about the roles of men and women in the society of the future. One option could be to seek out education on the topic? I'm thinking of in-house seminars where speakers are invited to address the topic and provide coaching, particularly for executives. Of course, that assumes that the executives are interested and recognize the issue in the first place.
- sentenza 13y agoIt is horrifying to read the comments here. In Germany, where I live, on average, a woman will earn less than a man IF EVERYTHING ELSE IS THE SAME. Here is the source (PDF, in German): https://www.destatis.de/DE/Publikationen/Thematisch/VerdiensteArbeitskosten/Verdienstunterschiede/VerdienstunterschiedeMannFrau5621001069004.pdf?__blob=publicationFile https://www.destatis.de/DE/Publikationen/Thematisch/Verdiens... No, this cannot be easily dismissed, yes they corrected for all the obvious stuff, no they don't have an agenda. This is a report by the official statistics bureau for Germany. Maybe the data for other countries is not as good, but why do so many people here immediately snap into backlash mode without considering the possibility that this could actually be an existing pay bias?
- JabavuAdams 13y ago> [...] why do so many people here immediately snap into backlash mode without considering the possibility that this could actually be an existing pay bias? <sarcasm> Because sexism and bigotry are properties of evil, despicable people, who aren't anything like us. We're cool progressive techno-optimists. We're so smart we couldn't possibly be bigoted. We're the new establishment. </sarcasm>
- sentenza 13y agoI find it funny that you would read me like that. Among my colleagues, I'm that one guy who, in his private life, is friends with "regular" people, who chooses to live in a rural area and who speaks with his native hillbilly accent. I'm aware that everybody has biases and preconceptions. I was taught to be aware of mine, which I think I am (and boy, they're something). But nonetheless, the dismissive tone of (some parts of) the conversation disappointed me and I think, given the standards to which HN holds itself, rightfully so.
- sneaky_ruds 13y agoI don't think that this is aimed at you. JabavuAdams suggests that "I couldn't possibly be sexist because I'm not a bad person" is the reason that many commenters are dismissive of the idea that there may be sexism in an establishment to which they contribute.
- jccooper 13y ago"The study focused exclusively on male CEOs rather than female CEOs: men account for over 90 percent of the CEOs in the authors’ study and an even larger proportion of the CEOs of large companies around the world,..." Fair enough; data set might be too small. "while female CEOs would presumably already be attuned to possible gender wage inequity, consciously or not, by virtue of being women." But this is not a reasonable conclusion. One hopes it's the reporter interpolating; otherwise the investigators have a rather rosy view of the world. Gender discrimination, to the extent it exists, seems to be rather strong in women as well. They may be measuring a certain effect, but leaving out some interesting data.
- dspeyer 13y agoI'd be very interested to see the mechanism. I can't imagine any company had a "pay women less" policy that got revoked. So what happened? Are women being brought into management more? It seems possible that a single promotion by the CEO could have major follow-on effects there. Had there been a subconscious tendency to shut down ideas that had women's names on them? Did the company culture move away from 60 hour weeks now that the CEO wants to get home early, allowing women (who are generally less willing to do 60 hours) to thrive? I'm assuming the study conductors were competent statisticians, so there's a real effect and it pretty-much has to be causality as indicated.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sendos 13y ago"Does that reflect an injustice? Many say no, arguing that women earn less because they take time off to care for children or elderly parents (and thus have less seniority) or accept lower pay in return for more flexible working arrangements. Women also tend to go into lower-paying lines of work, shunning higher-paying technical fields. It's easy to caricature this view (dirndls versus Visigoths, etc), but there may be some truth in it. Some research suggests that when women behave as men do--not having babies, mainly--the income gap largely disappears. If so (I won't claim the matter has been definitively settled), the question facing women is a stark one: What do you want, kids or cash?" [1] http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/2411/are-women-paid-less-than-men-for-the-same-work http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/2411/are-women-paid...
- ChikkaChiChi 13y agoCan any CEOs that intentionally pay women less where everything is equal chime in and explain why? --- In my experiences, I believe women are brought in under equal pay but in small teams and companies they are relied on to handle more responsibilities; perhaps even sometimes being considered "senior" when they aren't promoted to that level. I can't think of a single person who would be dumb enough to consider someone's genitalia when determining pay rate.
- peter-fogg 13y agoMany forms of discrimination are much more subtle than "this candidate is a woman, so I'll offer her $10,000 less than a man". That's why the authors chose Denmark as an area of study; since the country is (apparently) a fairly egalitarian place, any explicit biases should have a small effect, and anything left over is unconscious discrimination.
- koshatnik 13y agoInteresting that having a daughter makes CEOs more mindful of equal pay, when they already had a woman close to them that they should be looking out for - their wife/partner (I'm assuming gay CEOs with kids don't form a significant percentage of the sample). Is there any data on how CEOs and their partners share childcare responsibilities? I'd guess that most of the load is shouldered by their other half, given the kind of hours CEOs tend to work (especially in early stage companies).
- Tichy 13y agoMight be worthwhile to point out that even if it should turn out to be true, this doesn't imply that male CEOs were paying their female employees unfairly before they had daughter. It would just show that they paid women more afterwards than before (which could be discriminating against men, for example). Perhaps they even just paid men less, or earned less themselves (perhaps daughters require more time spent with family or whatever), thus dragging down the averages. I have not read the actual PDF yet, though, only the newspaper summary.