4 ms·
Odd blog post. Talks about "NSA-proofing email" and doesn't mention PGP, GPG or S/MIME. Should be titled "How to set up a mail server with SMTP and IMAP". See
by jgrahamc 13y ago
Odd blog post.
Talks about "NSA-proofing email" and doesn't mention PGP, GPG or S/MIME.
Should be titled "How to set up a mail server with SMTP and IMAP". Seems only peripherally connected with protecting email from snooping in any way.
- steveklabnik 13y agoThere was an excellent tutorial posted on that the other day: http://futureboy.us/pgp.html http://futureboy.us/pgp.html
- cmpxchg8 13y agoYeah, it didn't make any sense to me either. I'm all for running your own mail server but that alone will not make it any more secure unless you only communicate with people using said server. If I care that much about the content of an e-mail it will be encrypted or I will tell the person via other means. I assume everything I send via e-mail to be available to 3 letter agencies all over the world, regardless of what server I use.
- zeckalpha 13y agoAnd, even encryption doesn't keep the metadata from the NSA.
- namank 13y agoIt's defence against legal compliance with the NSA. Emphasis is privacy and compliance, not security.
- richardwhiuk 13y agoNo it isn't. The email passes through the server unencrypted (between Postfix and Dovecot), so it's still a potential tap point. In fact, running encryption to the server simply says to the NSA: Ask Linode for access to this disk.
- varikin 13y agoHe used an encrypted FS I believe, but the NSA could just ask to monitor all mail to and from his instance at Linode (or any ISP) since he didn't encrypt the mail.
- cenhyperion 13y agoAnd they probably have most of the mail anyways because odds are he's mostly communicating with people using google, yahoo, microsoft, etc.
- handsomeransoms 13y agoI wonder how effective this advice would even be at achieving that goal. Consider, for instance, that what meager protections are afforded electronic communications (by the Stored Communications Act, etc.) only apply to providers that "serve the public". [1] Others, such as Jake Appelbaum, have argued that hosting with Gmail or other large providers offloads the legal burden onto their well-equipped legal teams to defend against subpoenas, FISA requests, NSL's and the like. [2] The problem here is that it is very difficult to protect yourself when you don't understand your adversary's capabilities. We need transparent legislation and accountability in both government agencies and tech industry corporations. A lot of this advice boils down to an assumption that the NSA/DOJ/FBI will "play fair", and there is really no reason to expect them to do that. [1]: https://ssd.eff.org/3rdparties/govt/stronger-protection https://ssd.eff.org/3rdparties/govt/stronger-protection [2]: http://youtu.be/HHoJ9pQ0cn8 http://youtu.be/HHoJ9pQ0cn8
- namank 13y agoWell, with that consideration, the advice is moot since it isn't outside government regulation. Hmm...good point. We really need an open-source ISP for privacy to start to work. A fool-less system where the executing code is available to the public with read-only access with write permissions to appointed admins.
- teyc 13y agoI wonder if it is feasible to hide messages in spam. e.g. pretend that your machine is spewing out ads when it is sending messages. It probably one of the first things that will get filtered out by the NSA.