13 ms·
This is a financial disaster waiting to happen. Microsoft is oblivious if it is not doing something to divorce itself from the NSA. Apple, on the other hand, c
by acqq 13y ago
This is a financial disaster waiting to happen. Microsoft is oblivious if it is not doing something to divorce itself from the NSA.
Apple, on the other hand, could have come out smelling like a rose, but following the death of Steve Jobs, who apparently refused to play ball with the NSA, it stupidly jumped on board to join the PRISM club.
According to the Prism slides, it really looks so:
"Dates when Prism collection began for each provider
Microsoft 9/11/07
Yahoo 3/12/08
Google 1/14/09
Facebook 6/3/09
PalTalk 12/07/09
YouTube 9/24/10
Skype 2/6/11
AOL 3/31/11
Apple (added Oct 2012)"
Steve Jobs: February 24, 1955 – October 5, 2011.
If it's true, it's one reason more to deeply admire him.
And can you just imagine how much more sales Apple would get now for not being on that list?
- tl 13y agoWell if we're going to randomly speculate on such things, Scott Forstall resigned on October 29, 2012.
- josephcooney 13y agoIs this just a function of the relative popularity of the services?
- mtgx 13y agoThat reminds me of Putin a little bit. Even if you think some leader is an asshole, sometimes you need an asshole to stand up to an even bigger bully. I just imagine someone like former president Medvedev (and with no Putin in sight) would've offered Snowden to US government on a silver platter, just like France, Spain, Portugal and Italy tried to do (fortunately unsuccessfully). I remember I was very much against Putin when he fought the US' anti-rocket shield, but over the past few years I've started to understand why he would do that. No country should own the whole world.
- fauigerzigerk 13y agoDon't mistake a former KGB guy's taunting for a principled stance. Here's how Putin deals with whistleblowers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Litvinenko_poisoning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Litvinenko_poisoning
- lukifer 13y agoI don't think mtgox was implying principle, just a willingness to resist, even for the wrong reasons. ("You can't imprison dissidents. That's my job.")
- rfctr 13y agoYou certainly have a court decision or at least an official accusation to support your claim? Just asking.
- fauigerzigerk 13y agoYou might find some of what you're looking for on the wikipedia page I linked to. But courts are only very rarely the place where accusations against heads of states are examined, especially when it comes to superpowers.
- rfctr 13y agoI read it carefully. Name "Putin" is not mentioned anywhere in the Investigation section. Please stick to the facts.
- fauigerzigerk 13y agoIf the accused can prevent a proper investigation I will make my mind up based on the clues that exist.
- TausAmmer 13y agoThe more you look, the more you will find. Plato's Cave is amazing eye opener to everything we do daily.
- notimetorelax 13y agoMedvedev was and is Putin's pawn, he acts the way Putin tells him.
- mtgx 13y agoI know that, I just meant "someone like him" (weak personality that does what others tell him to do, even if he's head of a state).
- notimetorelax 13y agoYou're right, sorry I should have read your comment more carefully.
- rasur 13y agoNot germane to this topic, but I'm sure there are quite a few GLBT people that might have an opinion on just how much of an asshole Putin is.
- blots 13y agoIt's not exactly him. In my experience most Russians are homophobic to the core, unless they know some LBGT personally.
- amirmc 13y agoYour second sentence reminded me of the Dicks, Pussies and Assholes speech from Team America... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=32iCWzpDpKs http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=32iCWzpDpKs
- alan_cx 13y agoFor those who know Formula 1, I think Bernie Ecclestone and Max Mosley are the sort of examples that might work. Of course, some would say they are and were the bullies that needed standing up to. Heh, I suppose that gets us to the terrorist / freedom fighter type debate!!!
- Spooky23 13y agoAnyone who serves in a role as top leader of a country or large corporation is an asshole -- it's a job requirement. What you're seeing in Putin is the ability to be independent. He gets to enjoy watching the Americans squirm at low cost. What's the US going to do to Russia? Our diplomats will be rude to each other, maybe we won't attend the Russian summer ball and snub the Russian ambassador, each country will declare some spies persona non grata. At the end of the day, the areas in which the Russians and Americans cooperate are areas that they have a mutual interest to do so. Others, like the Germans or Spain are different. They piss off the US, we cut off the faucet of intelligence, money, privileges, etc.
- fatjokes 13y agoI must admit, I'm no Apple fanboy but in this case, I can easily picture a NSA rep threatening Steve Jobs and Steve Jobs telling him to f* off.
- mtgx 13y agoI wonder what would a Tim Cook-made iMessage look like from a security standpoint (probably a lot more like Skype/Hangouts than how it works right now).
- fpgeek 13y agoI don't know, but I wouldn't be too impressed with the security of the existing iMessage: http://arstechnica.com/security/2013/06/can-apple-read-your-imessages-ars-deciphers-end-to-end-crypto-claims/ http://arstechnica.com/security/2013/06/can-apple-read-your-...
- chmars 13y agoiMessage is in no way NSA-proof: http://blog.cryptographyengineering.com/2013/06/can-apple-read-your-imessages.html http://blog.cryptographyengineering.com/2013/06/can-apple-re... tl;dr: * Apple distributes the encryption keys * Multiple keys can be associated with an account (iPhone, Mac – and the NSA?) * Apple can retain metadata * Apple doesn't use certificate pinning
- simonster 13y agoMy understanding is that this isn't that bad. If you use iCloud, then the NSA can read your old messages. If you don't sync your iMessages with iCloud, under the assumption that not every iMessage gets encrypted to an NSA key in addition to the recipient's keys, your messages are safe until the NSA/other law enforcement explicitly targets you, and even then, they can only read new messages and not previous ones.
- scrrr 13y agoHow do you know it was Steve Jobs that prevented Apple from joining earlier? Perhaps Apple just wasn't a priority for the NSA until 2012.
- lukifer 13y agoIt's conjecture, but it's likely. Apple as a company has put a high value on user privacy, which was heavily influenced by Steve. He was also known for maintaining a high degree of personal privacy for such a public figure (for instance, refusing to put plates on his car).
- jgreen10 13y agoApple is a company producing consumer devices, while the others are companies offering Internet services, which is what PRISM targets. Apple has only recently had some success in the Internet services space with iCloud.
- johnchristopher 13y agoOne of those most successful devices is a phone. One that has been selling pretty well for 6 years. That's incitement enough to try to get them on board.
- UVB-76 13y agoUntil iCloud/iMessage, all the actual information was transmitted through third party services (i.e. network providers, email services, etc.) Why go after the myriad of handset manufacturers when you could just get the network providers on board?
- lukifer 13y agoThere are things network providers can't do: activate mic remotely, capture local-only data, keylog apps that use encryption, etc.
- rogerchucker 13y agoOr it means even NSA knew that Apple has mostly sucked in data and web services.
- flexie 13y agoWhat amazes me is that among those corporations with revenues in the tens of billions of dollars, not one of them challenged the constitutionality of the decision in court. Not one, not once. Not that it would be necessary in an obvious case like this, but each one of Microsoft/Skype, Google/Youtube, Apple and Facebook could easily have hired the nation's best and brightest one thousand lawyers at $1,000 an hour, full time for 10 years to defend privacy. It would have been well within their means. Yet, each of them chose to back down. Each of them chose to fail their users' trust. I don't think its due to cowardice. If these organisations cared the slightest bit they would have acted to protect their users. Not in the wildest scenario would the US government have jailed the leaders of Apple, Google or Microsoft. My best guess is they got something in return.
- laumars 13y agoFor all we know, some of them may have challenged it but they cannot make those details public because they're not even allowed to admit the NSA requested such information to begin with.
- sillysaurus 13y agoNot in the wildest scenario would the US government have jailed the leaders of Apple, Google or Microsoft. That may be naive. Most people have skeletons in their closets. The government would use these to pressure those leaders to acquiesce. I suspect the most dangerous skeletons are ones which seem harmless to you, but cast in the proper light they can be used as a justification for punishment. E.g. Something which seems harmless now can retroactively be used to claim you were doing insider trading. Few people would step up to defend you, even if the charges are baseless, because recently it's been fashionable to hate capitalists, and trading stocks is the epitome of capitalism. So it'd be very much "obey us or we will litigate you into bending your knee anyway." Jobs was immune because he was the CEO equivalent of a rockstar. To try to pull baseless charges against him would outrage the public. Yet I'd imagine the public would get grim satisfaction out of seeing Ballmer punished, even if the charges were baseless, because most people don't like him. It's shallow, but it seems true.
- 13y ago
- wslh 13y agoSeems like "Think Different" was more real than "Don't be Evil". Even with all the Apple's closed ecosystem. This reminds everyone to look at different angles when we criticize people/companies and understand that, even now, an individual makes a lot of difference.
- JonFish85 13y ago"And can you just imagine how much more sales Apple would get now for not being on that list?" Barely any change at all, I'd bet. And not worth the legal hassle they could have been up against if it came to a knock-down, drag-out battle with the US Government over <spins the dial>.
- acqq 13y agoI can imagine that U.S. companies wouldn't do anything, but European companies would be much more motivated for transition. As we speak, the top managers in Europe do try to find an alternative and everybody likes the easy way out. At the moment, baring some other potential compromising evidence, Apple would be such a way was it not on the Prism slide. Transitioning to big the powerful non-compromised Apple would be probably valued as less pain than transitioning to your in-company-made Linux distribution.
- el_fuser 13y agonot worth the legal hassle That's not the Steve Jobs I read about. Like him or not, he was a man of principle.
- seunosewa 13y agoHe was also pragmatic enough to pick the right battles. That,s a prerequisite for success in any business.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]