5 ms·
What I want to know, is why this asshole still has a job? Or James Clapper for that matter. And Barack Obama. I don't know about you guys, but more and more
by mindcrime 13y ago
What I want to know, is why this asshole still has a job? Or James Clapper for that matter. And Barack Obama.
I don't know about you guys, but more and more I'm reminded of that old Queensryche lyric:
Let's tip the power balance and tear down their crown. Educate the masses, We'll burn the White House down. Speak to me the pain you feel.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c6L5Jo09l7U http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c6L5Jo09l7U
- tzs 13y ago> What I want to know, is why this asshole still has a job? Have you considered the possibility that the people in a position to decide whether or not he has a job have more relevant information than you do, and are better qualified to evaluate it, and so that when they come to a different conclusion than you it could be that you are the one who is wrong? A lot of smart people inexplicably overlook this possibility.
- mindcrime 13y agoHow much more f%!#ng "relevant information" do we need?!??? We KNOW these fucknuts are shitting on the Constitution, lying to the American people and/or Congress, and running a rogue agency whose regard for the law is limited to it's own byzantine (and secret, I might add) interpretations of said law. I fail to see what other "information" is going to change that in the slightest. Sure, in some hypothetical alternate universe ,these guys might be "in the right", but we don't live in a hypothetical, alternate universe as far as I can tell. I'll also offer this up: If you or I were called to testify before a Congressional committee and we perjured ourselves with blatant lies, then later admitted it, don't you think there would be some repercussions?
- danenania 13y agoYour logic can be used to justify literally any action by those in power who have access to secret information. Rolling over and saying "our leaders have all the info so they know best!" as your rights are violated hasn't exactly been a winning strategy throughout history.
- tzs 13y agoYou seem to have misread my comment as saying something like "they know more than we do, so we should trust them", which is nowhere near what I actually said. What I actually said was that someone with more information might be better able to evaluate a situation and come to the right conclusion, and we should take this into account when evaluating the actions of those who have more information. This should be uncontroversial, unless one wishes to argue that less information puts one in a better position to make correct decisions.
- coldtea 13y ago>Have you considered the possibility that the people in a position to decide whether or not he has a job have more relevant information than you do, and are better qualified to evaluate it I did and came out with the conclusion that even entertaining this possibility is extremely naive. Not to mention terribly undemocratic.
- tzs 13y agoIt's undemocratic to even entertain the possibility that someone might know more or be better qualified than you? Am I misunderstanding you?
- coldtea 13y agoA little. It's undemocratic to explain the behavior of officials behind closed doors with "they could know better". It's not their job to do anything by themselves because they "know better". Their job is to inform the public for what they do, so it can make an informed decision (based on it's interests).
- grey-area 13y agoA democracy depends on an informed voting population. This means that decisions have to be clearly explained to the voting public by the leading experts in a field or the public's representatives, and then the decision of that public accepted, even if it is distasteful to the experts/representatives. Of course sometimes on unimportant topics the representatives will shortcut this process and just take decisions themselves. On important topics though they have to go to the nation and demonstrate their views by explaining what they plan to do and have done. The society created by your proposal is an oligarchy, not a representative democracy.
- tzs 13y agoI have not proposed anything. How would you suggest that decisions be made on questions where the necessary data to make an informed decision must be kept secret? An example would be a country deciding between different weapons systems proposals for its military. An informed decision required detailed knowledge of the capabilities of the different systems, but there is no way to get that information to the voters without also getting it to every other military around the world, which would greatly aid them in producing countermeasures to the new weapons.
- flyinRyan 13y agoRight back at you: a lot of smart people have realized what you propose is not very likely. What are the changes that they are all wrong? What are the chances it is just you who is wrong?