3 ms·
> dismissing anyone who interprets the 4th amendment differently as "morally bankrupt. If you get to the top rank of any government agency, you have a moral re
by dmix 13y ago
> dismissing anyone who interprets the 4th amendment differently as "morally bankrupt.
If you get to the top rank of any government agency, you have a moral responsibility to understand and respect constitutional law.
The 4th amendment was not instantiated so it could be interpreted at will by whomever is currently in power. Doing so is the exact opposite of acting morally in the context of ruling over a democratic society.
That is the very definition of a republic:
A republic is a form of government in which affairs of state are a
"public matter", not the private concern of the rulers.
- mpyne 13y ago> The 4th amendment was not instantiated so it could be interpreted at will by whomever is currently in power. It has to be interpreted to be applied in any event. That's why rayiner mentioned 'narrow scope' in his hypothetical. In this actual case it's not that Gen. Alexander decided the 4th Amendment doesn't apply, it's that Gen. Alexander managed to get a lot more people than himself, in all 3 branches of government, to agree that legal precedent would make systems such as being used at the NSA legal. Now we can argue that something simply being legal isn't actually carte blanche to go do it (e.g. rayiner has said as much in a different topic, that the law isn't meant to withstand everyone to try to push its boundaries all at once). But we can also argue that someone with a task T should take advantage of every available tool at their disposal to finish that task. This is the tack taken by those who say that Google/Facebook/etc. have no culpability for not paying more taxes, as long as they avoid doing so by legal means. Personally, I'm of the opinion that this WaPo piece is actually more concerning than news of PRISM, data collection, etc. I assume the NSA is collecting data, but I assume also that senior NSA leaders would be aware of why we do not concentrate power in the hands of individuals, and why we do not try to 'merge swimlanes' of functions.
- rayiner 13y ago> If you get to the top rank of any government agency, you have a moral responsibility to understand and respect constitutional law. Sure. But you don't have a moral responsibility to take the broadest possible view on Constitutional protections. It's one thing to ignore the 4th amendment. That's bad. It's another thing to reasonably conclude that the 4th amendment was intended to keep police from breaking into peoples' houses, not to keep the government from collecting information that people voluntarily handed over to third parties.