5 ms·
Any five page article featuring phrases like Alexander’s sensibilities is fluff. His proposed solution: Private companies should give the government access to t
by contingencies 13y ago
Any five page article featuring phrases like Alexander’s sensibilities is fluff. His proposed solution: Private companies should give the government access to their networks. Really? Let's not get too far in to the obvious totalitarian risk and sheer bureaucratic idiocy of such a perspective.
Pathetic puff piece on a morally bankrupt individual.
- rayiner 13y agoIs it possible to disagree with someone about the appropriate scope of surveillance without their being a "morally bankrupt individual?" Imagine a world where most people don't think information privacy is a big deal. Imagine a world where most people do think terrorism is a big deal. This is a hypothetical, so don't argue the hypothetical (i.e. whether information privacy is important or whether terrorists are a threat). Is it possible, just maybe, that a non-morally bankrupt individual could put those two things together and come to the good-faith conclusion that collecting large amounts of data to protect against a terrorist threat is in the public interest? Especially if that individual conservative but reasonable legal opinions stating that data held by private companies about their users are not within the scope of the 4th amendment? That hypothetical is probably closer to reality than you'd like to admit. My in-laws are not afraid of the NSA. They are afraid of Al Qaeda. Many legal experts reasonably read precedent like (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smith_v._Maryland http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smith_v._Maryland) to give a narrow scope to the 4th amendment when it comes to information in the possession of third parties. These people are not all "morally bankrupt." They just don't share your values and priorities. Probably most relevant is that you'll never convince my in-laws otherwise by dismissing them as "sheeple" or be able to effect any change by dismissing anyone who interprets the 4th amendment differently as "morally bankrupt."
- D9u 13y agoI'd rather imagine a world where the public servants believe in adherance to the standards of ethics befitting of a nation who justifies its actions by claiming moral high ground. I'm not afraid of al Qaeda because, as our illustrious president said, Americans refuse to be terrorized. When our public servants can perjure themselves before Congress, then they are fitting of the description morally bankrupt. Some may say that Clapper was merely lying to preserve state secrets, but he didn't have to lie about anything he felt uncomfortable speaking on, he could have simply said, "I can't talk about that," which would have been the truth. Perhaps your in-laws are comfortable being lied to by our public servants, however I am not.
- dmix 13y ago> dismissing anyone who interprets the 4th amendment differently as "morally bankrupt. If you get to the top rank of any government agency, you have a moral responsibility to understand and respect constitutional law. The 4th amendment was not instantiated so it could be interpreted at will by whomever is currently in power. Doing so is the exact opposite of acting morally in the context of ruling over a democratic society. That is the very definition of a republic: A republic is a form of government in which affairs of state are a "public matter", not the private concern of the rulers.
- mpyne 13y ago> The 4th amendment was not instantiated so it could be interpreted at will by whomever is currently in power. It has to be interpreted to be applied in any event. That's why rayiner mentioned 'narrow scope' in his hypothetical. In this actual case it's not that Gen. Alexander decided the 4th Amendment doesn't apply, it's that Gen. Alexander managed to get a lot more people than himself, in all 3 branches of government, to agree that legal precedent would make systems such as being used at the NSA legal. Now we can argue that something simply being legal isn't actually carte blanche to go do it (e.g. rayiner has said as much in a different topic, that the law isn't meant to withstand everyone to try to push its boundaries all at once). But we can also argue that someone with a task T should take advantage of every available tool at their disposal to finish that task. This is the tack taken by those who say that Google/Facebook/etc. have no culpability for not paying more taxes, as long as they avoid doing so by legal means. Personally, I'm of the opinion that this WaPo piece is actually more concerning than news of PRISM, data collection, etc. I assume the NSA is collecting data, but I assume also that senior NSA leaders would be aware of why we do not concentrate power in the hands of individuals, and why we do not try to 'merge swimlanes' of functions.
- rayiner 13y ago> If you get to the top rank of any government agency, you have a moral responsibility to understand and respect constitutional law. Sure. But you don't have a moral responsibility to take the broadest possible view on Constitutional protections. It's one thing to ignore the 4th amendment. That's bad. It's another thing to reasonably conclude that the 4th amendment was intended to keep police from breaking into peoples' houses, not to keep the government from collecting information that people voluntarily handed over to third parties.
- jivatmanx 13y ago"Imagine a world where most want to... x" What a majority want or do not want is entirely orthogonal to whether it's moral or not.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoDifferent people can have conflicting morals. If the majority thinks something is moral, it's moral for the majority.
- clicks 13y agoI think relativistic morality has it very wrong. I mean, surely you don't accept that killing Jews can ever be considered moral, or owning slaves, or cutting genitalia of little girls is moral just because a local majority happens to think that it is moral. In this day and age, with having gone through the Enlightenment with having such an abundant supply of literature on psychological sciences we can more or less reasonably agree on what is moral and not: physical and emotional pain is bad -- we know these things intuitively, we learned it over thousands of years -- fire bad, skin being cut bad, seeing my brother get killed bad, hugging good, we don't need human customs, politics, or some piece of paper dictate what is moral or not. See here Sam Harris better argue for an absolutist morality informed by science: http://www.ted.com/talks/sam_harris_science_can_show_what_s_right.html http://www.ted.com/talks/sam_harris_science_can_show_what_s_... I think all intelligent people should aggressively campaign the idea of absolutist morality to all ends of the earth.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoLet's see. In my system of morals, different people are allowed to have different morals. In your system of morals they are not. You are not okay with my morals. I am okay with your morals, as long as they don't infringe too badly on my own. I certainly understand that you have them. I suspect that absolute anything is going to be a problem eventually. I know that I'm very unlikely to be able to change your morality, so why pressure you? By the way, I don't think it's moral to call another person's morality horseshit. Your system of morals says this is okay. We have a small conflict there. No amount of science will convince me otherwise. Basically I believe it's legitimate for morals to be defined by individuals on the basis of their experiences in life. Yes, we know most of them intuitively.
- PavlovsCat 13y agoBeing misled by morally bankrupt people does not constitute moral bankruptcy, no. > "These people are not all "morally bankrupt." They just don't share your values and priorities." Morals is basically "values + priorites". This is like saying "these people don't do X, instead we see physical laws acting on matter and energy". In summary: It might be possible to disagree without employing sophistry, but so far I didn't see anyone do it.
- rayiner 13y ago> Morals is basically "values + priorites". This is like saying "these people don't do X, instead we see physical laws acting on matter and energy". Just because morality involves values and priorities doesn't mean that every disagreement about values and priorities is a moral issue.
- PavlovsCat 13y agoJust because morality involves values and priorities I didn't say involves, I said "is". As in, consists of. Having values without acting on them is pointless, so you need priorities for the whole morality package. You do know that "values" without qualifier is short for "moral values", right? Right... Also, just because you bring up your in-laws doesn't mean it suddenly has anything to do with them, other than you trying to make it about them. I just followed you into this dead-end because I'm fucking tired of people using themselves or their loved ones as hostages for abuse of power on a massive scale. Just because you or they fall for something doesn't make it right, and if yourself and your in-laws are all you have, then you have nothing. Since you asked: I don't think they're being that bright, but to make really sure I'd need you to ask them what they know about WTC7, Al Quaeda in the 80s, and just exactly how much Saddam Hussein and Al Quaeda were in love with each other. Just for starters, you know? Never attribute to malice what can be attributed to stupidity, after all. Anyone who is "afraid of Al Quaeda", in 2013, needs at least to turn off the TV. Were people who genuinely believed Hitler was great and wouldn't harm a fly "morally bankrupt"? No, but the result of their simple-mindedness sure as fuck had evil consequences for others, and to just dismiss it as having different values and priorities, well, as I said that's just sophistry, anything can be talked into being really nothing if you just keep at it. Explain it to your in-laws maybe, how Al Quaeda just has different values and priorities than them.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- zwtaylor 13y agoWhat were the values and priorities of someone like J. Edgar Hoover? His secret dossiers fit neatly inside a standard office cabinet, just think what he could have done with PRISM data.
- SimHacker 13y agoJ Edgar Hoover looked so hot prancing around in his "Throw Me Down And Fuck Me" Big Red Pumps.
- mistermann 13y agoHonest question: do your in laws genuinely believe there have been dozens of planned terrorist attacks in recent history, and all but one (the marathon bombers) of them have been thwarted by the NSA/CIA/etc?
- DanBC 13y agoThe fact that these people actually believe that they need this access to catch terrorists is scarier than if they were just doing it to grab portions of a budget. I tend to agree that it would be easier to persuade people if we used words like "cognitive bias" (with examples of how this affects everyone, even us) instead of inflammatory combative words like "morally bankrupt".
- coldtea 13y ago>Is it possible to disagree with someone about the appropriate scope of surveillance without their being a "morally bankrupt individual?" Nope. Especially if they are head of some secret service. Being "morally bankrupt" is on the job description.
- visarga 13y agoImagine a world where every person is controllable by the government based on surveillance data. They can and they will find issue with anyone they want, and if they are not vulnerable, then their family and friends. My problem is not with fighting terrorism, but with using this data for all sorts of police and state actions, in the benefit of whoever happens to be controlling access. It's another power amplifier. We already have politics and money to empower a select few, add massive data to the list. How is this going to work? How is this data going to be used and by whom?