3 ms·
IMO, it might have been self defense if she'd been in a genuine self defense situation, as reflected by "shooting to stop her attacker", even if she missed. Wa
by rdl 13y ago
IMO, it might have been self defense if she'd been in a genuine self defense situation, as reflected by "shooting to stop her attacker", even if she missed. Warning shots is a sign her life wasn't in danger, so she fired, which put him at risk, which is attempted murder. Which is weird, but sort of consistent.
IANAL. (I also don't fire warning shots except to center of mass, and generally don't miss less than 10m with a pistol, and don't shoot unless it's a clearly justified situation.)
- hga 13y agoAn interesting line of analysis, but I think it fails because "warning shots" that weren't don't have to have the intent to kill, they could e.g. have had the intent to terrify, to coerce, etc. Although elsewhere in this discussion rdouble said "The mandatory minimum is for 'unlawful use of deadly force'" so it sounds like the outcome would have been the same, depending on the legal meaning of "use of deadly force".
- rdl 13y agoIn the ~10 self defense classes I've attended, warning shots have been nothing but soundly discouraged. Any discharge of a weapon is inherently dangerous and could be considered deadly force, even independent of intent. The exception was in ROE/ROF training in war zones, where warning shots were explicitly part of the escalation continuum (although, in practice, if it was dangerous enough, the warning shots were generally fired into the driver, or at least into the engine block -- lasers and frozen bottles of water and such were used before that rather than warning shots, if possible.)