2 ms·
This is mostly false. I'll try to explain. I don't believe it is false. Instead of explaining again, can you provide specific verifiable assertions and citati
by btilly 13y ago
This is mostly false. I'll try to explain.
I don't believe it is false. Instead of explaining again, can you provide specific verifiable assertions and citations? I'll make it easy, I'll give you specifics to refute.
If subsidization of farmers to produce more than the market is predicted to demand in order to smooth out volatility and prevent famine is necessary (and it seems to me like a laudable goal), government can simply fund overseas farmers to overproduce, rather than its own. It would be less expensive than the current process in those cases where overseas farmers produce more cheaply. In many cases they'd still be subsidizing their own farmers.
Is your argument truly based on the assumption that government generally solve problems in efficient ways??
The truth is that it is easier for most governments to justify giving subsidies to their own citizens rather than foreign countries. Also self-sufficiency on food is seen by many as a security issue, and therefore there is a resistance to relying on others.
That said, different countries use different solutions. See http://www.guardian.co.uk/global-development/2012/may/10/chinese-food-security-investments-africa http://www.guardian.co.uk/global-development/2012/may/10/chi... for a news article indicating that China is taking exactly the efficient approach that you suggest.
Pretty much the only thing that would be untenable would be the current practice of paying "farmers" who own land to not produce. As far as I can tell everyone who doesn't receive that money hates the practice, so maybe we should just stop doing it. Which brings me to...
The USA pays people to keep land ready but unused so that production can rapidly improve. The European Union instead accumulates surpluses - aka the famous "butter mountains" and "milk lakes". Those are just different means to the same end - ensuring that there won't be a major famine.
> After repeated bad experiences, every country with the capability has decided that they want farmers to grow extra in normal years.
They haven't really. It's not like we ever had a vote on it. The current process is just a powerful lobby exercising their considerable power.
No, YOU never got to vote on it. It was before your time. That doesn't mean that I am wrong.
The European Union's policies were explicitly adopted as a reaction to famines after WW II. (Which in turn were significantly lessened thanks to major US intervention.) See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_Agricultural_Policy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_Agricultural_Policy for confirmation.
The US policies started earlier, and were motivated by the Dust Bowl in the 1930s. http://stateimpact.npr.org/oklahoma/2012/11/16/ken-burns-dust-bowl-how-the-dirty-thirties-changed-policy-in-oklahoma/ http://stateimpact.npr.org/oklahoma/2012/11/16/ken-burns-dus... is one of the first links that I came to which can verify that.
- justin66 13y ago> The truth is that it is easier for most governments to justify giving subsidies to their own citizens rather than foreign countries. I don't disagree with that statement at all. It is a statement that only speaks to public sentiment and it strikes me as probably correct. > Also self-sufficiency on food is seen by many as a security issue, and therefore there is a resistance to relying on others. I don't disagree but I suspect there's little actual analysis going on among most people as to the actual tradeoff: the current system means we have an agricultural system that can carry us if we have to fight a world war capable of completely disrupting world food markets, as we are a net exporter of food. On the other hand strife, terrorism, and small wars are more likely until the developing world actually leaves extreme poverty behind. Having to compete with subsidized agriculture in the developed world slows this process. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agricultural_subsidy#Poverty_in_developing_countries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agricultural_subsidy#Poverty_i... > The USA pays people to keep land ready but unused so that production can rapidly improve. The only guy I know who gets one of those subsidy checks because he owns land will never, ever be a farmer. His yard was farmland once. Interesting system. > The European Union instead accumulates surpluses - aka the famous "butter mountains" and "milk lakes". Those are just different means to the same end - ensuring that there won't be a major famine. The policy contributes to poverty and famine in Africa. Ideally we would find a way to mitigate famine risk here without sticking it to them. > The US policies started earlier, and were motivated by the Dust Bowl in the 1930s. I can't speak to European policy but the incentives and politics today in the US (in the area of agriculture, and everything else) are radically different than they were eighty years ago. Still, I take your point and thanks for sharing that.
- btilly 13y agoI am making a statement about the reasoning that results in current policies. I'm not saying that the policies are well-executed (indeed I think they are not), merely that they have something more than just "reward a well-connected lobby" justifying them. As for African poverty and famine, you're right that measures that protect farmers in rich countries will hurt farmers in poor ones. However the #1 cause of African famine remains corruption and war inside of Africa. And on current economic trends, we'll see economic powerhouses emerging in Africa in near decades. So as sad as our neglect of the interests of over a billion Africans is, it does not seem to be a permanent boot in the face. For perspective, take 5 minutes to watch http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jbkSRLYSojo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jbkSRLYSojo. There are - today - African countries that are better off than any country in the world was 70 years ago. If others continue on trends that have happened elsewhere, things are going to improve fairly dramatically. I agree with you that our agricultural policies create problems. But I'm optimistic about what the future holds for people who are impacted.