3 ms·
I really, really, really hate to be "that guy", but, but... I think the author of TFA is misunderstanding the idea behind Lean Startup and Customer Development
by mindcrime 13y ago
I really, really, really hate to be "that guy", but, but...
I think the author of TFA is misunderstanding the idea behind Lean Startup and Customer Development if he thinks "get out of the building" means "go out and find an idea for a startup". Steve Blank states very specifically in The Four Steps To The Epiphany that you start from the idea that the founder has in his head. The "get out of the building" bit means to get out and validate that there is actually a market for the thing you are building, and - if you can't find a market for it - then (and only then) modify the idea or change ideas.
It's totally fine to have your own idea about something new that you think the world needs, and to start building it without any external validation. The mistake that the "lean startup" movement is warning against, is to waste years of time, and millions of dollars, building something that nobody wants. This is why "customer development" runs in parallel with "product development".
So yeah, stay in the building long enough to come up with an idea, build a prototype if you feel the need, then "get out of the building" and show people the alternative to "a faster horse" that you've developed.
This really isn't a binary situation anyway... any successful businesses is going to involve a mix of your own "inside the building" ideas and "outside the building" validation. The goal is to find the right balance. I think Steve Blank and his peers would argue that, in the past, there was too much emphasis on the "inside the building" part and that people waited far too late to "get outside the building". But don't over-interpet that to mean that everything happens "outside the building".
- gruseom 13y agoI find the article more subtle, and rooted in much more experience, than you're giving it credit for. When people talk about the lean theory they often leap from "Don't make something no one wants", which is a truism, to "this theory tells you how to validate what you're building and thus how to make something people want", which is an enormous claim, and they never seem to address the abyss between the two. (It's a bit like the "?" step of the underpants gnomes, or that old physics cartoon where "Then a miracle occurs" appears on a blackboard amidst the equations.) Nate's post does address it. That's why it's interesting. It's a mistake to respond by saying that he must not understand the theory.
- mindcrime 13y agoIt's a mistake to respond by saying that he must not understand the theory. And I'm not saying he must misunderstand the theory. I'm saying it's a mistake IF "he thinks 'get out of the building' means 'go out and find an idea for a startup'" which is what TFA seems to be saying on at least some level. But I'll allow that I may have interpreted it differently than what the author intended. Still, when you read this: I cold emailed the guy to get a meeting to chat about his business. I was hoping I’d discover a problem I could create a new product around. If you’ve read any of the dozens of books about running a Lean Startup (I’ve read them all), you’d probably call this “getting out of the building”. ... it sure seems to be saying that "get out of the building" directly corresponds to "go out and look for a problem to solve" as opposed to "go out and validate an existing idea". But there could be some hyperbole in there that I missed on my first read, and it's entirely possible that I took that part too literally. Edit: I should also say - the author of TFA is showing a transition over time, in his approach, and his learning based on experience (as you note). It might be more accurate for me to say that he may have misunderstood the theory previously, rather than to say that he currently misunderstands it. Certainly I largely agree with the position he takes nearer the end of the article, which is somewhat different than where he started. I think the big open question, for which there is no easy answer, is something like "how far do you go based solely on scratching your own itch before you do go out and look for external validation"?
- chipsy 13y agoThe analogy I would have is with one's relationship to body image. If you are saying to others constantly, "am I pretty?" not only is their feedback never going to be satisfying, it's not accurate because you aren't sure what might actually be wrong with your appearance, and they, being caught in a mix of politeness and low interest, are most likely to say something vague and positive like "you're fine, you look great." On the other hand, if "looking better" is an internally driven problem, you already have some conceptions of how to proceed and the feedback is just one of several yardsticks - the actions you take being the primary means of tracking progress. But you have to come up with your own strategy to quell your anxiety and find some internal drive. And that's where balance as a person comes in - it stops you from obsessing over the wrong things. And there's a sort of progression of maturity in understanding how to deal with feedback, too: At first you are too naive to pay attention to feedback. Then you become hyper-aware of it like a teenager. Finally, you've developed your internal systems, so you can use it as a complementary mechanism.
- rmason 13y agoI totally agree, getting out of the building is about validating an idea and not about creating one. If you really want to solve problems in the restaurant industry try shadowing not only the owner, but everyone in the supply chain. The only restaurant owner who is going to know exactly what he wants is another programmer and you won't find many running a restaurant.