34 ms·
Stop giving out corn welfare to corporations and problem solved. It's the ONLY reason why it's so heavily used. Corn syrup and ethanol - two massively damagin
by ck2 13y ago
Stop giving out corn welfare to corporations and problem solved.
It's the ONLY reason why it's so heavily used.
Corn syrup and ethanol - two massively damaging products of a completely corrupt system that everyone refuses to change because of massive profits off taxpayers.
- mistercow 13y agoIt should be specified that what you say is true of ethanol in the US. In places like Brazil where they grow lots of sugar cane, it's a different story. And in theory, if ethanol were widely adopted as a fuel source in the US, we could potentially move to production using GM algae or something similar that would actually be efficient.
- nhebb 13y agoEthanol plays havoc with small engines. A couple of years ago I forgot to make sure the tank was empty and the fuel lines were cleared before winter. In the spring I had to take it to a lawn mower repair shop and plop down $50 just to clean out the gummed-up lines. It's even worse - and more expensive - for boat motors.
- Scaevolus 13y agoHistorically, there have been large sugar tariffs shielding the domestic sugar industry. There have been some recent changes, like raised tariff-free limits or NAFTA allowing free imports from Mexico, but the market is still used to corn syrup being the most economical choice.
- stephengillie 13y agoAnother control on this is the Overall Allotment Quantity of sugar, which is the USDA-regulated quantity of sugar which can be sold in any year. If you have too much sugar to sell, you'll have to store it or dump it. This is to keep sugar's price high. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overall_Allotment_Quantity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overall_Allotment_Quantity
- Groxx 13y agoThat's an... interesting mechanism. I can't figure out what the goal is, aside from, as you said, keeping prices high (specifically for those two kinds of sugar, which seems extra weird) - is there another reasonable explanation?
- speeder 13y agoMoorcock this is the official purpose, they never even feigned it being something'.else.
- yajoe 13y agoIt's extremely complicated. One reason for keeping prices high this season is to prevent loan defaults from the farmers/producers in the fall. So one part of the federal government may spend another $40mil affecting the sugar market (high prices this season) to prevent a loan default of $100mil to different parts of same federal government and all of the fallout to those small businesses. Bankruptcy threatens families keeping their farms... as big of a deal as foreclosures for suburbanites. The loans are based on a variety of factors and have a variety of goals from ensuring that family farms exist (and don't get gobbled by mega-farm corps) to ensuring that we grow certain kinds of crops in this country to ensuring we build better combines. It's very complicated and any 'narrative' that has a single cause or explanation is likely incorrect.
- newbie12 13y agoThe "family farm" defense of agricultural subsidies is dead wrong. In fact, most programs are price subsidies, so the more you produce, the more you benefit, and as a result most of the subsidies go to the largest producers-- we actually subsidize agribusiness over family farmers, relatively speaking. Further, the value of the subsidies gets capitalized into the land and makes it impossible for young farmers to get started in the business.
- rmrfrmrf 13y agoThanks for the laugh. You know you've reached the pinnacle of "first world problems" when a phrase like corrupt system, which has historically been used to describe things like institutional discrimination and genocide, is now used to describe the "horrors" of agricultural subsidies and tariffs. I'm surprised that Amnesty International hasn't updated their corruption index accordingly, which would surely put every sovereign nation's score in the single digits.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoI believe that if one first resolves domestic problems they become more effective in helping people outside the home. > Thanks for the laugh. Speaking of which, please don't abuse the other members. It only undermines your humanitarian intentions.
- pessimizer 13y agoOr third-world problems, such as when we started dumping all of that subsidized corn into the Mexican market.
- deelowe 13y agoWhen high tariffs on the importation of sugar prevents countries from developing their own agriculture industries, it's not just a first world problem. It's BS like this that causes international tension, wars, and famine. This situation isn't as superficial as it may seem on the surface.
- prodigal_erik 13y agoCorruption is misuse of bureaucratic power for personal financial gain. I don't know why Amnesty International would spend a lot of time on that rather than the atrocities you speak of, and if they publish a "corruption index" I can't find it.
- randomdata 13y agoThe problem is not exactly solved, because it is not clear what the farmers should grow in the place of corn. As a grain farmer operating in a country that does not have subsidies, we still end up growing corn, even if it results in a loss. Bankers prefer to see a loss than to leave the land lay fallow, and there are not many famers who can operate against banker's wishes in such a capital intensive business. You cannot just simply transition into other non-grain crops because nobody has the multi-million dollar investment that it would take to build up the necessary infrastructure, the environment is not always suitable for all types of food, and you cannot get away with growing the same crop year after year. Corn solves a lot of those problems, even if it ends up creating others, as you point out. It is a pretty deep problem that cannot be solved with just a stroke of a pen, though innovation is always welcome on the farm, if you have real solutions.
- justin66 13y ago> The problem is not exactly solved, because it is not clear what the farmers should grow in the place of corn. It's quite possible they should stop being farmers and that the nation should farm out (get it?) much of its agriculture to the developing world. This is certainly what "the market" dictates and something which government spends a lot of money working to prevent.
- randomdata 13y agoWhile it might seem logical in the peaceful times we've grown accustomed to, it is going to still be a tough sell for nations like the USA that have a war-centric mindset. A starving population is how you lose wars, and the work the government does to maintain the local food supply exists for that reason. Also, there is growing concern for our ability to replenish food-stocks as-is. If farming ceases in these nations, you lose a lot of food people directly eat too.
- justin66 13y ago> A starving population is how you lose wars, and the work the government does to maintain the local food supply exists for that reason. While it's true that having crops in the fields would help keep people fed during a world war that disrupted world agriculture, that's not the reason "the work the government does to maintain the local food supply exists." It exists because agriculture has a powerful lobby and they make a lot of money this way. Poor, developing world farmers don't get a vote. It's sometimes used as a post-hoc justification for what is done. > Also, there is growing concern for our ability to replenish food-stocks as-is. If farming ceases in these nations, you lose a lot of food people directly eat too. Killing developed world agricultural subsidies and allowing market competition to stimulate agricultural production in the developing world is one of those things that seems to unite almost all economists. This seems to be because they think it will make food less expensive and more accessible. I'm not familiar with anyone making the opposite case?
- cgrubb 13y agoIt's not the corn subsidies; it's the tariff on sugar imports. The US cannot produce much cane sugar domestically. Corn subsidies are only about $2B a year, and 75% of corn is used for animal feed or ethanol. http://farm.ewg.org/progdetail.php?fips=00000&progcode=corn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maize#U.S._usage_breakdown
- buddylw 13y agoI agree completely that corn subsidies are out of control, but it's not clear that getting rid of corn would solve the health problem. It would likely be replaced with 'high fructose' <some other starch>. Fructose has properties (very sweet, doesn't crystallize like sucrose, etc.) that junk food purveyors love and corn doesn't even contain any fructose naturally. Any starch + amylase makes a syrup (my personal favorite is rice syrup). An extra process turns part of the glucose to fructose making it very sweet. Sorry to crap on a point I mostly agree with in the name of technical correctness :)
- kyllo 13y agoRight, if corn were not subsidized, corn syrup would probably not be wholly replaced with cane sugar, as cane sugar is much more expensive, a lot of it is imported, and it can't really be grown productively in most of the US--inside the US it's really only grown in Florida, Texas, and Hawaii. The 89 million acres[1] of corn harvested in the US would be partly replaced by some other starchy crop x, and high fructose corn syrup would be partly replaced by high fructose x syrup. The root problem is really the fact that we as a nation eat too much food, and too much cheap, high-carbohydrate, calorie-dense, processed food. I agree with cutting corn subsidies, but the real solution is on the demand side. 1: http://www.nass.usda.gov/Charts_and_Maps/Field_Crops/cornac.asp http://www.nass.usda.gov/Charts_and_Maps/Field_Crops/cornac....
- zanny 13y ago> we as a nation eat too much food I really don't know how to fix it, because it is more the subconscious drive to overeat when you can than any cultural issue. Food is plentiful and cheap, so Americans devour it incessantly. One thing I think could fix it is decoupling the social aspects of eating - most families only see each other for food, which prompts them to eat more if subconsciously they want more human interaction. It is also known you eat more when you aren't happy, so obviously make people happier, which isn't something as a society we are doing much of.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]