3 ms·
Why don't they just make a binary client ? How does that help the situation at all? Either data is DRM-encumbered or it's not. The basic issues of rights of c
by Silhouette 13y ago
Why don't they just make a binary client ?
How does that help the situation at all?
Either data is DRM-encumbered or it's not. The basic issues of rights of creators vs. rights of distributors vs. rights of consumers are exactly the same.
All you're doing by arguing against a standardised way of using DRM on web sites is leaving lots of little walled gardens. Having all the data you want, in an unencumbered format, in a nice open field where anyone can play, isn't an option that's on the table right now. It won't magically become an option just because you force all the distributors to develop custom schemes for their DRM instead.
- jlgreco 13y agoIt helps because the barrier to entry to creating your own binary client is high. I don't have to worry about my local news station going coo-coo and DRMing their entire site because "Hey, it's easy so why not? Gotta stop those dastardly copy-pasters."
- cheald 13y agoWhy exactly do you care if your local news station DRMs their content?
- jlgreco 13y agoIs this a serious question? Are you trolling? Because I like to read it..
- cheald 13y agoIt's a serious question. DRM doesn't prevent you from consuming the content they provide under their terms, does it? The classic argument against DRM is that you don't really own something that you've purchased. But...you aren't purchasing your local news channel's broadcasts. You don't own them, you don't have any claim on them. What's wrong with the owner deciding what can be done with them?
- jlgreco 13y agoThe terms are not my primary concern. The capability to read it is. I want to be able to read it. Right now I cannot use Netflix on my primary operating system. I can read the news because without strong incentive to DRM it (as Netflix has, their licensing terms require it) it is not worth implementing DRM.
- Silhouette 13y agoRight now I cannot use Netflix on my primary operating system. I can read the news because without strong incentive to DRM it (as Netflix has, their licensing terms require it) it is not worth implementing DRM. You appear to have made a poor choice of operating system. Perhaps you should try a better one for your needs? There are lots of choices, and many of them would let you use Netflix if that's what you want to do.
- jlgreco 13y agoIs this an argument you actually think that people concerned about this proposal will find satisfying? Or is it just something that you find satisfying to say. You cannot possibly think the first... (Furthermore, I am able to watch Netflix videos on other devices. The inability to watch Netflix on my primary computer does not bother me. I don't have that support now, I won't in the future, I never had it and I never expected it.)
- Silhouette 13y agoIs this an argument you actually think that people concerned about this proposal will find satisfying? No, I'm just explaining why a problem of your own making, which will affect a tiny minority of people interested in viewing content on-line, is not reasonable grounds for undermining standards that would probably be in the interests of the overwhelming majority. Or is it just something that you find satisfying to say. Satisfying, no, but it is tiresome to watch people campaign for openness with one breath and then complain with the next that they can't access things that are paid for and only available in the closed world they chose not to participate in.
- Silhouette 13y agoIt helps because the barrier to entry to creating your own binary client is high. It really isn't. It's significant, but for the kinds of royalties the big media guys are trying to protect for a major sports event or a Hollywood blockbuster or smash hit TV show, they'd pay it a dozen times over. The reality is that just means only a few of the most popular platforms will be able to view the DRM-encumbered content, and people on niche platforms will lose out.
- jlgreco 13y agoIf the barrier to entry is sufficiently high that small fish currently do not try to cross it. I really don't give a shit if Netflix uses DRM. I honestly don't have a problem with them or other "big fish" using it. I am concerned about every fish using it.