3 ms·
a VERY strong NO. Most college/university level courses teach the wrong languages in the worst kind of ways. CS Majors who did not self-tutoring outside of cla
by ErrantX 18y ago
a VERY strong NO.
Most college/university level courses teach the wrong languages in the worst kind of ways. CS Majors who did not self-tutoring outside of classes are really only suitable for management roles.
I think doing a subject (maths, engineering, physics) that shows a ranging ability in a tough area is much more important. It's easy to prove you can program (with examples and simple tests) but proving ability via a CS course is next to useless.
- andylei 18y agoyou take this too far. i agree that it's possible to learn CS without taking courses, but i don't think that CS courses are useless. if you can learn CS without a course, i don't see how taking a course would hurt. your argument is based on CS courses teaching you the wrong thing, but if that's true, then you're equally, if not more likely, to learn the wrong thing if you just learn on your own. if you were hiring a programmer and you had two candidates were exactly the same, except that one had a degree in CS from, say, Stanford, would you really be indifferent between the two?
- ErrantX 18y agoDepends on what the other candidate had done. If they were identical in every way potentially I would take the CS candidate. But that is a straw man argument ;) With a group of newly graduated candidates (and we have been hiring programmers recently so this is from experience), assuming "newly graduated" means they have a degree of some sort, the CS majors tend to be, in my experience, the weakest real world programmers. Engineers and physicists are the best.
- scott_s 18y agoMost college courses don't teach a language. They use a language to teach computer science.