10 ms·
My Product Has Failed
- danso 13y agoGreat post...one of the more detailed post-mortems I've read...this one point stuck out to me: > Most importantly, I can't relate to my target demographic at all > I'm not a small business owner. I don't have any employees, I don't have any physical inventory. > I think this was my biggest downfall. I had to pay for content because I didn't know what business owners with a physical inventory wanted to read about inventory management. How is this not painfully obvious to any independent entrepreneur? If you don't have the resources to do customer surveys and advertisements, why don't you stick to something you actually know? Because, assuming you are a reasonable person, a problem you have is likely a problem that others have. The main advantage, in this case though, is that feature brainstorming and iteration is much quicker...sometimes the time intervals are as short as it takes for a thought to reach the other side of your brain. And even if you don't have a market right away...or ever...you may have built something that is useful enough to you to markedly improve your life. So, almost a win win. I can't count the number of times when, while working at an incubator, I overheard developers building the next awesome photo-world-traveling-sharing app, and trying to come up with features they think photographers might need...it was always painful to listen to.
- dack 13y agoThe flipside is that a lot of developers don't have enough hobbies to draw from with which to start a business. One thing we can all build is a developer-focused tool, but we are also some of the hardest customers to please, since we would only pay for something that is sufficiently difficult and useful that we wouldn't want to just build it ourselves or look for an open source solution. This is something I have had to tell myself - go out and have a life as if you've already "made it", then when you find something you can fix that you yourself would prefer over the alternatives, that's your startup. Unfortunately, I think that means we have to be patient about ideas - you're not going to notice the real problems in a given area after having tried it once (unless your solution is a newbies guide or something).
- Rakathos 13y ago> The flipside is that a lot of developers don't have enough hobbies to draw from with which to start a business. This was (is?) definitely me. I have a grand total of three hobbies: Building software (also my job), playing WoW and reading. I couldn't think of any business idea that I could build off of WoW (and I'm pretty sure Blizzard doesn't allow that), so I took a different route for finding a problem to solve: I surfed through small business forums and picked the problem that most people were complaining about. That happened to be inventory management. (I'm happy to say I've since quit WoW, on account of the nonexistent IRL returns).
- josh2600 13y agoI feel like I read things like this on HackerNews about once a month. All of these posts can be summed up like this: 1) I built stuff without talking to people 2) I built custom work for a client and it wrecked me 3) I didn't listen to customer feedback Yes, your business will fail if you don't talk to customers. We're all terrified of showing off our children. What if the world thinks they're ugly? What if the child actually is ugly? Well then, that child is still going to have to make its way in the world, isn't it, or not? Some of the best solutions to problems I've seen start out as ugly children, but, in truth, over time they find their place in the world. The difference between what makes an ugly child grow up strong, versus one dying, is the development. If your friend tells you that your kid would look better if he had a tail, and he's willing to pay you to put it on, you'd be doing a disservice to your child to attach that tail. You have to do what's best for your business; no silver bullets, no easy answers. I think that writing these kinds of things can be cathartic, but, to be honest, if you read enough of these they all start to look the same. The one thing I know is that your time wasn't wasted. Learning lessons is what life is all about; doing something with them is what success is all about. TL;DR: Your product failed because you didn't talk to customers and no one is surprised. I look forward to a follow-up post about your new product, driven by customer feedback :).
- dack 13y agoLike many of us, I've been reading hacker news and related sites for years, but it was only after I attempted to actually apply all that knowledge I thought I had that I realized how unprepared I really was. It's natural to read an article about a failure and feel like the points made are obvious - but that's because we aren't imagining all the pitfalls that we may have fallen into along the way that others would have avoided. Not only that, but the rules have so many exceptions that it could have just as easily gone the opposite way (I wish I hadn't listened to my customers) and we would still say it was an obvious conclusion. I agree, the conclusions raised are all pieces of advice I have heard before, but I still enjoyed reading about his particular mental model of what he thought was the right course of action, and then seeing how it got shattered by the (lack of) results.
- josh2600 13y ago
- teilo 13y agoIndeed. Big or small, ERP is where it's at. You can't have five or six systems that can't talk to each other. Accounting here, Invoicing there, Inventory, Point of Sale, Warehousing, etc. At that point you're almost no better than managing your business on paper, because you are re-entering everything over and over again.
- kaa2102 13y agoI would not quit what you're doing just yet. You built a product and have a paying customer. Congrats! You mentioned that you don't understand your the needs of your customer. I think you can build on what you've already done. Get out of the building, join your local Chamber of Commerce, and find out the challenges that small businesses are facing. There may be adjacent markets that you can enter by tweaking your product.
- nthitz 13y agoBit of discussion on HN from when this article was originally written: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5782761 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5782761
- erroca 13y agoThis is old, its been on HN already...
- Rakathos 13y ago(Blog post author here) I wondered where the random burst of traffic came from. For those who haven't read the more recent posts, I received a ton of great feedback from HN and other entrepreneur friendly places. I've also been gobbling up great advice from places like Rob Walling's "Startups for the rest of us" podcast. About a month ago I started a "challenge", inspired by Brennan Dunn, to rebuild my "failed" product, and it's been going pretty well so far. Most importantly, a few days ago I announced that I'm "pivoting" from just inventory management to a full-blown ERP for printing companies. I chose printing companies because I'm a full-time developer at a printing company, and I know exactly what kinds of problems we face with our terrible ERP system. Though I need to be super careful not to build a system that is so focused only my own company can use it. If there's one piece of advice I could give somebody else, it would be to narrow your niche like I did with printing companies. This has helped me so much it's downright ridiculous. Edit: Also, when I originally posted the article some people were concerned that I was just trying to build a "meta" product with Iron Conversions. I admit I had planned to build a product with it, but I've put that on hold indefinitely in favor of rebuilding Rakasheets. I don't know if I'll ever return to it, so for now Iron Conversions is just the place I'm blogging about my progress.
- hamburglar 13y agoI'm glad to hear you're going back and refocusing the original project. I have to admit that when I got to the "Iron Conversions" part of the blog post, I was flabbergasted that you'd pivot towards an aspect of the business that you were apparently not good at. What you said about Iron Conversions was vague enough to leave some doubt, but it sure read like "My product failed, partly because I can't convert customers to save my life. I know, I'll start a new business helping people with conversions!" Put this way, it sounds like a pretty delusional plan, unless you learned something magical about conversions that for unknown reasons you just don't feel like applying to your existing business. Hope that doesn't sound too harsh. Good luck on phase 2.
- Rakathos 13y agoNot harsh at all! You're right, but in my defense "Iron Conversions" was just going to be a massive dunning email generator. It would have hooked into a user's Stripe account and responded to webhooks with A/B tested dunning emails. The onus would have been on the user to convert their trials.
- Chanel_Bunnell 13y agoCouple of things spring to mind. First, regarding the articles: Article or blog traffic is a long term strategy. You shouldn't expect to see a real return for 6 months to a year, and when the return comes, it stays for years. You should be writing a blog yourself, not farming it out to jokers on fiverr -- that's if you want to go down that route. As I said, it's a long term thing, and not everyone or every business is suited to it, as it takes a regular and continuous work. Second: >I wasted too much money on AdWords >As of now I've put about 300 dollars into AdWords and it has all been completely wasted. That's peanut and pizza money. You should have spent that running an ad campaign before you wrote a line of code. Seriously though, if you can't afford to spend $300 on advertising, you haven't got a pryer of generating traffic in the early days. And without traffic, you have no sales. And without sales, you have no business.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- btipling 13y agoA cool write up and good discussion but looking at the home page can maybe be insightful too. The home page can probably be improved to see a minor tick in conversions. The "Online Inventory Management without the suck" is not a great intro. It stresses an absence of something negative instead of stressing something positive and uses the rather crude and unprofessional word "suck" You also have no sign-up form visible on first page load and no call to action (one has to scroll a little, at least on my mac). The "not interested" inversion of "contact us" is also pretty weird and announces that you expect people to not be interested. The pricing link does not look like a link at all. Then as you scroll it's just a wall of text all the way to the end.
- petervandijck 13y agoAgreed, your sales pages are very, very(, very) bad. Perhaps your product didn't fail, but your marketing?
- antjanus 13y agoYep, those were all points I noticed too. For example: * the CTA is below the page fold which means LOWER conversions. It's also grey. I didn't see it during my first scroll. Perhaps changing the button to the yellow used in the picture would work. * the sign in button should readily have a "sign up" button next to it * the pricing link isn't really a link, like you said. I didn't even realize it was until I read your comment. I think that pricing should be available right below the page fold after the CTA, much better placement. * the main image on the page is pretty low-res, I think it'd make more sense to blow it up so you can see the detail and overlay text over it (but so that the legibility of the text doesn't decrease) * the wall of text is something I never really read. I always take note of successful products and how they convert. Both mailchimp and basecamp and many others keep their home page a single page site, unscrolling for the most part.
- Rakathos 13y agoMy entire site design and copy have been a source of downright embarrassment. In fact, this week's "challenge goal" is a brand new home page, landing page and sales page design. The copy itself is going to need to change to reflect the pivot from inventory to ERP, so happily "Inventory management without the suck" is going away. > The "not interested" inversion of "contact us" is also pretty weird and announces that you expect people to not be interested. Curiously, I thought this myself when I put it up. To this day, I can't fathom why I thought that was a good choice of words (or why I never changed it). > Then as you scroll it's just a wall of text all the way to the end. I had been experimenting with the "hybrid copy"[1] sales page that Joanna Wiebe of Copyhackers has been a proponent of. It's worked incredibly well for my actual landing pages, where a user knows what the product is about when they click whatever link or ad brought them there. However, I took it way too far by doing "hybrid copy" on the home page. The new design I'm working on is going to be the classic home page with a brief overview of the product and a CTA linking to the "hybrid copy" features/tour page. Edit: I neglected to mention that the "hybrid page" experiment resulted in a noticeable increase in new trials. [1] http://copyhackers.com/2013/04/long-copy/ http://copyhackers.com/2013/04/long-copy/
- ryanackley 13y agoIt's strange because I have a very different takeaway than the author (or most people here). It took him 1 month to build his entire product! And people say he should have talked to customers first. It takes some people 1 month to mock up their product and build a slide deck and business plan, etc. His biggest failure was he couldn't market his product effectively. If you aren't funded by a big name VC and you're tackling a ho-hum problem. Chances are, you won't be featured on TechCrunch or the HN front page. Some ideas are so innovative and awesome that they market themselves but my guess is that inventory management doesn't land in that category.
- dclowd9901 13y agoIf VCs were validation, Medium would be a good idea, instead of a shameless rehash of a content farm.
- cmbaus 13y agoI wouldn't call continuing where the inventor of mainstream content publishing (ev williams) left off with blogger, a rehash. After Blogger, Odeo, Twitter, and now Medium, I think he knows what he is doing.
- paul_f 13y agoHow can you possibly know this: "His biggest failure was he couldn't market his product effectively" The number one failure of startups is building stuff nobody wants. Go read some Steve Blank pronto.
- dinkumthinkum 13y agoExactly. 1 month to build is nothing. Some people just "talk" about building a product for six months. Perhaps he even gave up too easily and could have tried to market it different, go after customers a different way. The problem here on HN is that there is such a focus to build advertising based products that are like photo-sharing apps and sometimes the techniques to get TC to care are different. Of course the author could have tried to market via TechCrunch by writing vacuous blog posts about how they are "Disrupting Inventory Management" or some such ... and honestly that might have even work, at least to get TechCrunch to publish it. But, I think possibly there could have been some direct sales approaches here ... He built the product, I hate to see it wasted if it can be salvaged.
- MagicWishMonkey 13y agoYour site looks nice. Have you considered letting people register and use it for free (with up to 10 users, and 1000 inventory items or something reasonable for small businesses)? If enough people sign up it might be worthwhile to add additional features for premium users in the future.
- jborden13 13y ago"They also need customer management, order tracking, accounting, lead tracking, etc. All of the people that I could get to seriously look at Rakasheets all said the same thing." Before I got to this point in the post I kept thinking that inventory management on an island doesn't sound like a robust enough of a solution to be of much use (I admit this is an assumption and I'm biased). What would be interesting, and something that we will be looking for shortly for our platform, is an inventory management API. We've got most of the other stuff the poster mentioned, but will most likely try to find a solution to buy for inventory management instead of rolling our own, if we can. Good post - love the poster's frankness and willingness to admit his/her mistakes. Successful entrepreneurship is often an iterative, effectual undertaking. Don't expect to hit a home run, or even get a base hit your first time up to bat. It takes a couple of times through the ringer before you really get on track.
- shekyboy 13y agoMakes me think about the post I read from Nathan Kontny http://ninjasandrobots.com/what-people-really-want http://ninjasandrobots.com/what-people-really-want Its really hard to do this if you are not completely immersed in the problem yourself. The legacy players who have this strong position have the years of understanding the problem and that is why they command the market and at times dont even have to innovate to protect their position. If you yourself are not your customer, it is very hard to execute, prioritize etc. For enterprise businesses this is extremely critical. Also when I say Problem I just dont mean the actual product. It also includes decision makers, sales cycles, budget cycles etc etc. The whole decision matrix around a enterprise product needs to be understood. Actually I dont think Rakasheets has failed. You just have an expensive Prototype. If you want to continue, spend the next month in customer offices selling this. Forget adwords or any other such mechanism. Your best customer acquisition channel will be Word of Mouth. Small Business owners know many other SMBs and they share such stuff. If you can crack a few they will share that positive experience with their friends and colleagues. Good luck!
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- kybernetyk 13y agoHmm, has it really failed? Isn't it too early to decide on that after just 3 or 4 months of running it? Even more so that your adwords campaign seems pretty sub-optimal if you can spend only $2 a day. Have you tried optimizing the campaign, your landing pages and your sales funnel? That's where I usually spend most of the time for a product. Building is a walk in the park compared to the work I have to put into sales optimization. Development is just a small part of running a software business. I'm not saying you should ride a dead horse - I guess you have more reasons to believe your product failed than you stated in the blog post - but keep for your next project in mind that you shouldn't give up too quickly.
- Nate75Sanders 13y agoWould you care to detail your process some and/or link to some books/articles about this process for someone who has no experience with any of this? I'm interested in both the theory and the practice of marketing and sales, for many things, but especially for SaaS.
- mathattack 13y agoI'm with you - 3 or 4 months seems premature to give up on something that's already been built. It does sound like the marketing plan is weak.
- hpcorona 13y agoYeah, 3-4 months seems too little to expect some income... This guy just wanted to make it big, and wasn't in the mood of creating new features... All he was doing is what he wanted with the product, not what the potential customers need... I agree that you cannot do everything that the customer ask for, but from my point of view, this guy doesn't even knew the needs of his target market.
- wrath 13y agoI agree with the others, 3 to 4 months is nothing. As a comparison, it took my current company 2+ years to make enough money that I could live on and 5+ year in order for me to call it a success. Many times during this 5 year period we thought about closing our doors but we knew we had something, the problem was that what we were selling wasn't exactly what our customers wanted. We pivoted a few times and finally something hit. We haven't looked back ever since. You are probably right that inventory systems are awful for small to medium businesses, so you have a business somewhere. There are others in your space so that always good validation (http://tradegecko.com http://tradegecko.com). This is what I would do: 1. Learn everything you need to know about the inventory pipeline within small businesses. How they order stock, warehouse it, receive orders, ship it, etc.. 2. Blog the living hell out of what these small companies do and how you can make their lives better. This will help your SEO which in my experience is much better than AdWords. 3. If you don't already have one, produce a roadmap for your product. You won't always be able to stick to your roadmap but making one will do the following: - Help you understand how different you are compared to your competitors. What makes you (or will make you) so special? Why should I buy from you? - Help with conversations with potential customers that you are committed to them in the long term by showing them a roadmap. 4. Stop blogging about how you failed. I don't want to buy a product from a company that may close tomorrow because they're going to fail!!! I want to buy a product from a company that screams success. Your customers don't give a shit about how bad you are at business, they care about solving their problems. 5. Keep your product simple, be great at solving one need. This doesn't mean that you shouldn't add a contact manager if you're customers are asking for one, but that the contact manager you add isn't at the same level as salesforce has it! 6. Get known in the inventory management community. You'd be surprised how small and thigh nit these communities are. Sure IBM is huge, but they only have a handful of individuals performing outreach. 7. PR, PR, and more PR. Bug the living crap out of every tech blog, inventory management blog (big enterprise types and small types) and every other blog that fits. Don't pitch them "Have you heard about us!?",. Pitch them stories that their users want to read, and by the way, you got your data from Rakasheets. 8. Slowly integrate with e-stores and shopping cart platforms such as shopify. 9. Last thing, be patient! A company isn't built in 3 to 4 months, it's built with years of sweat and most importantly love for what you do. You built a product, which is far more than the majority of the people hanging around here have done. Be proud and "grind" on. Good luck!
- coldtea 13y ago>Four months ago (sometime in January, 2013) I started building my first real SaaS business. Rakasheets was a realtime, cloud based inventory management app that had a ton of great benefits. Or so I thought. At the time I was starry eyed, dreaming of a future of fat bank accounts. Rakasheets was my ticket to success! The tool that would make my dreams come true. Or you kidding me? He wrote that "fourth months" after starting building his first business? And it was a failure because it hadn't made him rich in 4 months? Talk about perserverance...
- Rakathos 13y agoA few people were upset that I called it a failure after 4 months. You're right, 4 months is nothing compared to most other startups or software businesses. Let me clarify that I'm calling it a failure not because I wasn't rich in 4 months. Instead, it's a failure to me because I lost interest in what it did and who it was for, and I had no intention of ever working on it again.
- freework 13y agoFor every person who says their company failed because they didn't listen to customer feedback, there are the same amount of people who say their company failed because they did nothing but follow the demands of every single customer. Success lies somewhere in the middle. How do you know where that middle is? That is the $100,000,000 question that you can only learn by a process of trying and failing. This is why these unsolicited "advice" articles are worthless.
- Osmigo 13y ago"For every person who says their company failed because they didn't listen to customer feedback, there are the same amount of people who say their company failed because they did nothing but follow the demands of every single customer." Very, VERY important point. Some years back I had the experience of designing, from scratch, several dozen web sites for some state government agencies. I used to tell people, "designing a web site is like decorating a room for 50 people and trying to make them all happy." And for sure, if you jerk and twitch from every customer comment, you'll crash and burn, like the proverbial hound dog in a whistle factory. The real question is not just whether or not you listen to customer feedback, but how you process it.
- rokhayakebe 13y ago100% Wrong. Your marketing failed.
- epa 13y agoA nice advertisement hidden as an article.
- starrhorne 13y agoYou are giving up too early. You can make money on this product, but you just have to be willing to spend time learning to market it. And by market I don't mean advertise. I mean, finding a group of people who really need inventory management and then tailoring your app to their specific needs. For example, how many $1000s of dollars a year do restaurants lose from inventory spoilage? How does that compare with the cost of paying someone to enter all that data into your system? Because, as a business owner, I only care about how your app is going to make or save me money. One more thing. Not every type of business does well with a no-touch sales process. I suspect that with something like inventory management, you'll want to focus on an industry, go to trade shows, and really insert yourself into that world. Bizdev is really underrated in this self-serve world.
- lucidrains 13y agoGive it more time... 3-4 months is nothing
- Renaud 13y agoBeside the fact that it is certainly a bit early to call it quit, I'm having problems with the product and the site itself. I have dealt with stock inventory for years and it is one of these areas that looks deceptively easy to implement but ends up being a lot more complex in real life. The website makes many grand promises but there is very little information on what it actually does. The target customer should be someone knowledgeable in Stock Inventory, but there are not many specifics for them to even assess if the product is for them or not. * Who does this target? small businesses? retail? factories? * What is a "sheet" really ? It is a Form? a data entry grid? * Inventory data doesn't exist in a vacuum, it needs to be fed to accounting software, so at least a good import/export/reporting story is important here. * similarly, can I connect to the database to produce my own reports and plug custom software (even Excel for instance through a datasource) to it? * I can't find any information about cost management. Does the software only manage quantities or can it track cost as well? * How does the software manage counting units? Can I manage cable lengths in metre or in whole roll? Can I sell some oil SKU by the litre and other by the bottle? * What's the story for annual/continuous inventories (stock counts)? does it help me with that? * Cant I easily make transfers from one warehouse to another? * I can't find whether the software is able to manage FIFO, LIFO, batches, etc. * What's the picking list story if there is one? * Does the software manage part revisions? For instance factories may have different revisions of the same item (electronic or mechanical). * Does the software manage stock locations so I can easily find where product with SKU F7786 is located? * what's the story for receiving deliveries? Can I have a quarantine area where I receive my goods for inspection? It reads everywhere that this is a one-man labour of love. Why should I risk an important business activity to a one-man shop? What happens if the founder is sick and there's a problem? I don't want to be too negative, I'm only being harsh because I really like the concept; the design and the amount of work put into this is a short time is amazing. The tablet story is great too. On the other hand, it feels like this was made by a programmer who doesn't really know the business he's in and ends up with a products that seems to be targeting libraries and bookstores (2 very different businesses) and groceries, retailers, even factories maybe. It tries to be too much for too many. To save this, I would target specific markets and make appropriate versions of the software for those markets, using their business terminology, highlighting on the first page the pain points they are facing and how the software solves them, etc. Making a one product fits all is exactly the sort of problem small business face when they buy a cheap general purpose ERP: it's often too complex and it ends up not being what they need. The pricing is also fairly high: a 4-seat version of Sage Line 100 (a complete ERP for SMB) costs less than US$900 per year in license renewal. Yours cost about $700 for 3 users only for inventory management. That's quite a lot.
- downandout 13y agoAt the end of the day, the software business is exactly that - a business. Great business people can turn mediocre ideas into successes, while bad business people can turn great ideas into disaster. Very few independent developers are good business people. Either enlist the help of a great business person to roll out your projects, or drop the independent projects and spend that time doing consulting or other things that will get you paid. Creating independent projects without strong business talent behind them will almost always be an incredibly disappointing experience.
- areeved 13y agoDid you do any lead gen or direct sales? Pick up a phone! It sounds like you have a reasonable product, but you've simply failed to sell/market it.
- brador 13y agoWhat is a web engineer?
- nadaviv 13y ago> (Sidenote: Judging by my AdWords clicks, Inventory Management is very popular in India) The cost per click in different countries can be very different. India traffic is usually considered lower-quality, and is usually much cheaper. My guess is that he saw a lot of India users not because its popular, but because that's what his budget allowed him to buy.
- dev360 13y ago"I spent most of my time on the SmallBusiness forum on Reddit." ... I'm not saying this is the cause for the failure, but imho, this is a terrible place to look for validation because its a breeding ground for people that have tons of opinions but don't really represent your end customer and at the ending of the day, have zero desire to buy your product, they just want to login in and have opinions. Its in a sense, similar to techcrunch.. a club for internal admiration. I see so many people fall for this sort of thing.. I personally just think its unfortunate.
- lukehorvat 13y agoRaka{sheets} <-- that's how you failed.
- akrymski 13y agoTo me this lesson is simply a reminder of the fact that business is all about sales. Just look at SalesForce. Best products don't always win. Business is about finding an arbitrage opportunity - build something for $X and sell it for $Y. Some businesses can get away with buying stuff for $X and selling it for $Y. Building is the easy part.
- ackfoo 13y agoGet a better name, dood. Also, try writing something other than dogfood, meaning some elaboration of software for an established, crowded market of which you have no specialized knowledge or expertise. 'Course, that would require you to have some life experience of something other than just software.
- ape4 13y agoHow about another name? Raka means ""Moon in the Sky" ('Aakasher Chand') in Bengali language." according to wiki. Ok, nice word but not easily accessible to Americans. Maybe "Sheets" is an inventory thing. But it means nothing to me. How about EasyInventory.