4 ms·
Note that the reasoning under which this happened is exactly the same as the NSA's reasoning - as long as they don't know that the people are Americans, they do
by btilly 13y ago
Note that the reasoning under which this happened is exactly the same as the NSA's reasoning - as long as they don't know that the people are Americans, they don't think the 4th applies.
- jdp23 13y agoExcellent point. And how are the anonymous activists supposed to prove that they're US citizens without revealing their identities? And just as with the NSA's reasoning, there's no protection for non-US citizens. Also worth highlighting: any mechanisms Microsoft (or other companies) build in to allow the NSA access to data also have the side effect of allowing access to that data in this situation. Of course as they keep pointing out they only disclose data in response to a court order. But when the courts are granting subpena's like this, that's not a big comfort.
- unclebucknasty 13y agoI was thinking the same. What a cynical and self-serving argument, given that these people were acting anonymously. This back-handed ruling effectively puts an end to anonymity and the judge knows it. If it is determined that any of these people are U.S. citizens, then they should be able to sue for violation of their first amendment rights. Further, any information obtained via the subpoena should be inadmissible since it would have been obtained illegally. Better still, why do we accept a double standard for U.S. vs. non-U.S. citizens in cases like these, if we are supposed to be the beacon of justice and democracy for the world?