2 ms·
The flaw in cultural "explanations" is that they are not in any way explanations, but simply associations. Explanations involve cause and effect. Illustration:
by pessimizer 13y ago
The flaw in cultural "explanations" is that they are not in any way explanations, but simply associations. Explanations involve cause and effect.
Illustration: The causes of ascribed cultural trait X which has a 75% prevalence in Fooistan may be identical to the causes of that same trait X in Baristan, where it has a 5% prevalence, and the difference may be entirely due to random circumstance and network effects. Explaining why a person in a particular incident acted in accordance with trait X with "He's Fooistani and they are often X" is not an explanation, just an observation, and offers no insight into the 25% of Fooistanis who are not X. The equivalent statement in the latter case is "He's Fooistani, and sometimes Fooistanis are not X" and has equal explanatory power: none.
As a Baristani, though, it is a very comforting "explanation" if trait X is a worrying trait, because being Fooistani is not something that they have to fear.