3 ms·
Is Smith v. Maryland really all that relevant? Isn't there a big difference between collecting data from "a" pen register, and putting pen registers on every s
by hga 13y ago
Is Smith v. Maryland really all that relevant?
Isn't there a big difference between collecting data from "a" pen register, and putting pen registers on every single phone in the nation? (And claiming that's not "collection", collection is only invoked if and when they decided to look at stored data?)
- dragontamer 13y agoSmith v. Maryland is relevant because it is being discussed by the Senate Intelligence Committee and debate in Washington. Its part of the discussion, its part of the debate. Period. The author of this piece has failed to communicate part of the discussion from within Washington to the rest of his readership.
- nitrogen 13y agoLet's bring Rihanna and Bieber into the discussion as well. Surely there's some way we can make them relevant to the discussion of NSA spying, then we can complain about law professors not including them in their articles either. If "It[']s part of the discussion, it[']s part of the debate. Period." were a general rule of debates, then it would be ridiculously easy to sideline a debate by introducing random irrelevant facts to the discussion.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dragontamer 13y agoPrecisely why I'm annoyed at the author. Please tell me why Mr. Barnett's rant about 5th Amendment rights in Colonial America is relevant to the conversation... but Smith v Maryland isn't. Yeah, that's not a typo. Barnett begins to rant about the Fifth.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dragontamer 13y agoThe important bit of Smith v Maryland was that the Pen Register was warrantless, which means it has been established as an unchecked power of police. The police are allowed to install as many pen registers as it wants, and never tell anyone about it.