5 ms·
This article is trash, the discussions on this issue are trash, and everyone is running around like a headless chicken. A Law Professor, writing an argument ab
by dragontamer 13y ago
This article is trash, the discussions on this issue are trash, and everyone is running around like a headless chicken.
A Law Professor, writing an argument about law, without discussing the relevant cases? No discussion of Smith v Maryland? No discussion of FISA 702 or Patriot Act 215? Did he even bother to look up any relevant information with regards to this controversy?
Call it unconstitutional if you want, but I want to see an _argument_. Call yourself a law professor or a lawyer, but if you write under the guide of a legal expert, I demand to see a high level discussion on the issue.
Instead, I get a rant about libertarian ideals, applying the 5th Amendment to property you clearly do not own. I see vague descriptions of the 4th Amendment, with no regard to context that is going on in the debate in Washington.
Any "Law Professor" that writes about this subject... but FAILS to mention Smith v. Maryland is horribly horribly ignorant on the subject. And does not deserve to be writing under the guise of a legal expert. And he has failed to do his due diligence as both a legal expert and reporter.
- Tarrosion 13y agoPerhaps the author feels that a short op-ed in a popular newspaper is not the place for highly technical discussions. Whether choosing to write at a surface level is optimal or not, it's a bit of a stretch to accuse a professor from a highly respected university of being "horribly horribly ignorant" on the basis of what's not in a single page article.
- dragontamer 13y agoIf he knows the information, but has failed to talk about it, then he has failed as a reporter. As a legal expert and reporter, it is his job to elevate the discussion. If he is not ignorant, then he was lazy, and now he has spread ignorance to his reader base.
- cshenoy 13y agoI feel like the op-ed is aiming to "spread the knowledge" more than it is trying to dig deep into the legal issues surrounding NSA's activities. I recall reading polls after the Snowden leak showing how a fair amount of the US public did not fully understand what was happening. It seems like this is Barnett's initial attempt at speaking out in some official form and creating some dialogue around this issue.
- twoodfin 13y agoSo what makes it a decent article for hn? Are there really a bunch of folks around here who haven't noticed this controversy yet?
- hga 13y agoEmphasis on "short", the word limits on Wall Street Journal are infamous, "unless you're the Pope" as one author put it. As they put it (http://online.wsj.com/article/SB126841622758561059.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB126841622758561059.html): "We prefer that the submission be between 600 to 1,200 jargon-free words...."
- e3pi 13y ago> "We prefer that the submission be between 600 to 1,200 jargon-free words...." "...True, judges have long been approving search warrants by relying on ex parte affidavits from law enforcement. With the NSA's surveillance program, the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court has apparently secretly approved the blanket seizure of data on every American so this "metadata" can later provide the probable cause for a particular search. Such indiscriminate data seizures are the epitome of "unreasonable," akin to the "general warrants" issued by the Crown to authorize searches of Colonial Americans. Still worse, the way these programs have been approved violates the Fifth Amendment, which stipulates that no one may be deprived of property "without due process of law." Secret judicial proceedings adjudicating the rights of private parties, without any ability to participate or even read the legal opinions of the judges, is the antithesis of the due process of law." An ex parte judicial proceeding is conducted for the benefit of only one party. Ex parte may also describe contact with a person represented by an attorney, outside the presence of the attorney. The term ex parte is used in a case name to signify that the suit was brought by the person whose name follows the term. Under the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, "No person shall … be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law." A bedrock feature of due process is fair notice to parties who may be affected by legal proceedings. An ex parte judicial proceeding, conducted without notice to, and outside the presence of, affected parties, would appear to violate the Constitution. However, adequate notice of judicial proceedings to concerned parties may at times work irreparable harm to one or more of those parties. In such a case, the threatened party or parties may receive an ex parte court hearing to request temporary judicial relief without notice to, and outside the presence of, other persons affected by the hearing. Ex parte judicial proceedings are usually reserved for urgent matters where requiring notice would subject one party to irreparable harm. For example, a person suffering abuse at the hands of a spouse or significant other may seek ex parte a Temporary Restraining Order from a court, directing the alleged abuser to stay away from him or her. Ex parte judicial proceedings are also used to stop irreparable injury to property. For example, if two neighbors, Reggie and Veronica, disagree over whose property a tree stands on, and Reggie wants to cut down the tree whereas Veronica wants to save it, Veronica can seek an ex parte hearing before a judge. At the hearing, she will ask the judge for a temporary Restraining Order preventing Reggie from felling the tree. She will have to show the judge that she had no reasonable opportunity to provide Reggie with formal notice of the hearing, and that she might win the case. The court will then balance the potential hardships to Reggie and Veronica, in considering whether to grant Veronica's request. A court order from an ex parte hearing is swiftly followed by a full hearing between the interested parties to the dispute. State and federal legislatures maintain laws allowing ex parte proceedings because such hearings balance the right to notice against the right to use the legal system to avert imminent and irreparable harm. Far from violating the Constitution, the ex parte proceeding is a lasting illustration of the elasticity of due process. http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/ex+parte http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/ex+parte
- _delirium 13y agoRandy Barnett is a libertarian activist, and generally writes in that style, fwiw. He also has a legal background, and can make use of it in court briefs where necessary, but most of his writing is more from the perspective of, "what I think the law ought to be, based on libertarian principles".
- hga 13y agoIs Smith v. Maryland really all that relevant? Isn't there a big difference between collecting data from "a" pen register, and putting pen registers on every single phone in the nation? (And claiming that's not "collection", collection is only invoked if and when they decided to look at stored data?)
- dragontamer 13y agoSmith v. Maryland is relevant because it is being discussed by the Senate Intelligence Committee and debate in Washington. Its part of the discussion, its part of the debate. Period. The author of this piece has failed to communicate part of the discussion from within Washington to the rest of his readership.
- nitrogen 13y agoLet's bring Rihanna and Bieber into the discussion as well. Surely there's some way we can make them relevant to the discussion of NSA spying, then we can complain about law professors not including them in their articles either. If "It[']s part of the discussion, it[']s part of the debate. Period." were a general rule of debates, then it would be ridiculously easy to sideline a debate by introducing random irrelevant facts to the discussion.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dragontamer 13y agoPrecisely why I'm annoyed at the author. Please tell me why Mr. Barnett's rant about 5th Amendment rights in Colonial America is relevant to the conversation... but Smith v Maryland isn't. Yeah, that's not a typo. Barnett begins to rant about the Fifth.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dragontamer 13y ago
- rhizome 13y agoAs for Smith, there might be a way around it: http://www.volokh.com/2013/06/07/why-does-a-terry-standard-apply-to-querying-the-nsa-call-records-database/#comment-926079717 http://www.volokh.com/2013/06/07/why-does-a-terry-standard-a...
- cpleppert 13y ago>>This article is trash, the discussions on this issue are trash, and everyone is running around like a headless chicken. This article is more than trash, it is totally misleading in almost every way. Any discussion of the fourth amendment in the context of Patriot Act 215 will invariably bring up a discussion of the third party doctrine which states that: "information loses Fourth Amendment protection when it is knowingly revealed to a third party[1]." The author seems to go out of his way to avoid discussion of any of the extensive legal precedents that have interpreted the fourth amendment. Just hyperbolic rhetoric and comparisons to the colonial government. It isn't helpful at all. 1:http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1138128 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1138128
- nitrogen 13y agoWe don't consider handing a letter to the post office as "knowingly reveal[ing] to a third party." Should using a phone company to carry your private conversation not have the same protection?
- dragontamer 13y agoYes we do. You reveal to the Post Office: 1. The date that you sent the letter 2. The address you're sending the letter to 3. The return address (ie: where you've sent the letter from). Its a known fact that the Post Office records this information, and that the Police is free to analyze this information without a warrant. How do you think the Police go about those Anthrax attacks through the mail system? Neither the Police nor the Post Office are allowed to OPEN an envelope, because that hasn't been revealed to a 3rd party. But that goes back to this whole _metadata_ collection question. There is no expectation of privacy on the three elements above... you've written it on the _outside_ of an envelope. So you expect other people to know about it. If this is a "Police State", then we've been living in it for damn near a hundred years. Analysis of mail records is police standard procedure. Similarly, the Smith v Maryland case argues that Telephone records have no expectation of privacy. After all, its all information that goes onto a caller-id, its all public information. On the other hand... the actual conversation, the Feds aren't allowed to look at. That requires a warrant.