3 ms·
On what legal grounds was Microsoft "forced" to provide access to unencrypted data before encryption (effectively nullifying the security that they promised to
by mtgx 13y ago
On what legal grounds was Microsoft "forced" to provide access to unencrypted data before encryption (effectively nullifying the security that they promised to their customers)? So how were they forced? Legally? Illegally/blackmail?
CALEA seems to say that companies don't have to decrypt data for authorities. I guess it's very convenient that they give it to them before they encrypt it then:
http://paranoia.dubfire.net/2010/09/calea-and-encryption.html http://paranoia.dubfire.net/2010/09/calea-and-encryption.htm...
And this seems to be a "team sport", and that implies willing collaboration, not being forced to do it. More like something "fun" they're doing together.
- tzs 13y agoA company doesn't have to decrypt to meet their CALEA obligations. If CALEA is the sole legal authority for a particular communications interception, that would be the end of it. However, I've seen nothing that indicates that CALEA is the legal authority behind the NSA interceptions.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y ago>So how were they forced? Well, we can't really know (they won't answer FOIA requests!). We can only make guesses. Could be they were just asked. Western Union gave telegrams to the NSA just for the asking. Some people would argue that Microsoft has enjoyed favorable treatment by the courts. Maybe there was a quid pro quo somewhere along the way. NSA has strategically placed employees/agents in other companies. Why not Microsoft?