3 ms·
This article is largely focused on epidemiological studies. These are a very well-known type of scientific investigation, particularly among the tech crowd--bec
by snowwrestler 13y ago
This article is largely focused on epidemiological studies. These are a very well-known type of scientific investigation, particularly among the tech crowd--because it is tech-intensive to manage and analyze large volumes of data.
But, epidemiology is not all of science, it's just one way to do science. So this statement is wrong, or, at least, not complete:
> The standard scientific answer to this question is that (with some caveats) we can infer causality from a well designed randomized controlled experiment.
The more general scientific answer is that we need an hypothesis that can be tested and disproven by observation. Such observations can come from a randomized controlled trial, but a surprising amount of important scientific observations do not. For example, a major confirming test of relativity was to measure the apparent displacement of stars due to gravitational lensing during an eclipse. Obviously there is no way to create a random double blind study of this. (Unless one were to stare too long without eye protection! [rimshot])
But wait, I could hypothesize that saying "blutarski" when flipping a coin will make it land heads up, and if I only do the observation once, my stupid hypothesis might get confirmed. Right?
In this case, yes, a lengthy trial would help provide much better observations. But the more general answer is that a reasonable hypothesis must propose a physical system that could plausibly cause the predicted result. There is no known physical system that connects "blutarski" with coins, or Facebook traffic with Greek bonds. But there is a plausible physical mechanism by which smoke inhalation could lead to lung cancer.
This is what scientists are talking about when they say things like "there's more to science than curve-fitting." But most people do not understand the difference, and that's why we see things like global climate circulation models get mixed up with historical climate reconstruction, or paleontology get mixed up with evolutionary biology.
- Goladus 13y agoThis is an excellent explanation. I'm not sure what you mean by paleontology being mixed up with evolutionary biology, though.
- snowwrestler 13y agoA lot of critics of evolutionary theory believe that the fossil record is the most important piece of supporting evidence--hence the focus on "missing links" between species. The scientific reality is that Darwin formulated his theory by looking at living species, and the modern study of evolutionary processes does too--primarily viruses, bacteria, and insects, because their lifespans are so short.