4 ms·
I'm not exactly disagreeing, but don't forget the other side too -- that you might not know what you're doing, that you might not understand the good reasons th
by crazygringo 13y ago
I'm not exactly disagreeing, but don't forget the other side too -- that you might not know what you're doing, that you might not understand the good reasons that certain rules are in place, that you might not understand the big picture and that your actions might backfire and/or be counterproductive.
Don't forget to be humble too, and realize that what you think is the right thing, isn't always the right thing. There's no inherent valor in "breaking the rules" -- if you can, it's much better to gently persuade, bring people to your side, and talk things out.
Again, not disagreeing with the article, just pointing out that life isn't that simple always.
- dclowd9901 13y agoExactly. I see it this way: Freeform jazz performers and poets can break all sorts of rules, because they know what the rules are so well that they know which rules make sense, which ones they can bend and which they can outright break. I would never advocate handing the keys of this philosophy to a young scrappy kid at his first job out of college. More like the seasoned veteran who's seen all sides and knows what it takes to make something (Disclaimer: I am neither of these).
- afterburner 13y agoI'm not so sure age is any indicator of principled action. Older employees have been worn down and want to get somewhere, young people can have more conviction in their principles because they have less to lose and more enthusiasm. And the opposite can happen too of course; young people can be easily misdirected, and older employees can have the learned cynicism and experience to see history repeating itself.
- zecho 13y agoAs a veteran at my company, I've let scrappy kids take the keys. It's always about them understanding the general direction we're going. I trust their judgement and their fearlessness to ask questions of those of us who've been around much longer. Which actually fits into the jazz analogy. Jazz players work together in the same direction, there are rules within the rule breaking, even if they're unspoken.
- ryanac 13y agoThere's actually a TED talk with a group of freeform jazz performers explaining something similar to this called "There are no mistakes on the bandstand": http://www.ted.com/talks/stefon_harris_there_are_no_mistakes_on_the_bandstand.html http://www.ted.com/talks/stefon_harris_there_are_no_mistakes... Shows how even when you do something against the rules / on your own, you still need to remember you're part of a bigger unit. I agree that people should know when to and how much they can break the rules and it takes experience to know that. But, I feel like you have to make mistakes to get that experience, and that there should be some room for experimentation and failure for those willing to take these risks.
- ozataman 13y agoIn further support of these points... Thinking outside the box, breaking the rules as a last resort to do the right thing and other similar actions can indeed produce the extraordinary results, in certain situations, the organization is hoping for after all. Yet this strategy will work only for the very top performers: Those who can sense and actually produce the truly largest "contribution" to their company (as opposed to what seems right, interesting or cool to them), even when it more or less eludes their higher ups; those who can do this while also being politically savvy enough to contain the consequences and sell their actions as actually in line with everyone's goals; those who are almost magical in being able to produce the kind of results others are very unlikely to do etc. It can work, I've seen it work, but I think it is important to realize that not everyone can or should do it. When it works, it is certainly a great boon to the career of the said top performer. Know that by doing this, you may be counterproductive both to your organization and your career. If you take it to the extreme, you may become a friction rather than a "problem solver". The most common pitfall I've seen is a highly technical person considering things like "refactoring", "getting it right" more important than getting to the finish line fast. Remember that you may be missing what's really the most important thing for your company at the time. I've also seen commonplace "complaining" about inconveniences that are actually quite legitimate. It's just that you don't know all the facts or haven't been put in a position to produce the bottom-line results. Things look different when you're the one navigating the ship. OTOH, I've seen this strategy work best when the very formal scope/objectives/deliverables of an effort are clearly wrong and would indeed lead to a subpar outcome for all involved. Implemented successfully, this strategy could produce outstanding results by forcefully course-correcting and then actually delivering great results. Remember though that you'll be blamed for everything if your course-correction isn't great, even if the original direction would also have been equally bad.
- daemin 13y agoI always think that whenever a new rule or procedure gets created there should be sufficient reasoning as to why it had been created, what conditions prompted it, and what it's designed to solve. With that information people can see why something needs to be done a certain way, and additionally they will know when rules and procedures should be eliminated. In my mind this would allow people to deduce when exceptions to the rules are applicable, and hence be more effective. Unfortunately I have not actually seen this happen in real life.
- nazgulnarsil 13y agoNever take down a fence unless you understand why it was built. OTOH Things often improve when youngsters come in and break things older folks didn't realize weren't working.
- jakobe 13y agoThe problem is that there are no signs on the fence explaining why it is there, and the people who raised it are nowhere to be found, and the most likely reason for its existence is unreasonable paranoia.
- jarek 13y ago> the most likely reason for its existence is unreasonable paranoia Spoken like someone who's never walked across a minefield ;)
- marrs 13y agoAnd farmers still plough up mines in the Somme, because they still have to plant next years crops.
- arethuza 13y agoOn that subject, unexploded ordnance (UXO) is a real danger for the Crossrail tunnels deep under London: http://www.londonreconnections.com/2012/a-legacy-of-iron-crossrail-connaught-and-ww2/ http://www.londonreconnections.com/2012/a-legacy-of-iron-cro...
- chiph 13y agoI can't link it (YouTube is blocked at work), but there was a BBC program from the 80's called "Danger: UXB" which is quite excellent, and nearly every episode is online.
- jarek 13y agoIt's mostly artillery, which is less likely to kill on a touch. Plus I'm sure one could spin an argument about this being an example of knowing how to break rules relatively safely, too.
- asafira 13y agoAwesome post. It's great to see a top comment on HN that isn't hugely disagreeing with the article in a (perhaps borderline) disrespectful way. Furthermore, I agree that often times the best way to go about doing things is being reasonable with people, but it's also just _hard_ to do. You're human, and sometimes you might lose it for a dumb reason --- just fall back, understand what you could have done better, and learn from the experience.
- sas 13y agoChesterton's Fence! "In the matter of reforming things, as distinct from deforming them, there is one plain and simple principle; a principle which will probably be called a paradox. There exists in such a case a certain institution or law; let us say, for the sake of simplicity, a fence or gate erected across a road. The more modern type of reformer goes gaily up to it and says, “I don’t see the use of this; let us clear it away.” To which the more intelligent type of reformer will do well to answer: “If you don’t see the use of it, I certainly won’t let you clear it away. Go away and think. Then, when you can come back and tell me that you do see the use of it, I may allow you to destroy it."
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoYes, but sometimes the road is nothing but gates. By crossing the fence and running across the field, we harm no-one on the road, and we get places.
- igouy 13y agoBy crossing the fence you put your car on the train tracks and derailed the on-coming train. Happens over and over again.