2 ms·
You're right, but there's still a valid point I think. I'm a reasonably competent home mechanic. I happily rebuild engines and gearboxes for cars and motorcycl
by bigiain 13y ago
You're right, but there's still a valid point I think.
I'm a reasonably competent home mechanic. I happily rebuild engines and gearboxes for cars and motorcycles at home. I can modify and tune engines. I easily do all my households vehicle maintenance. And I happily help friends out with their repairs and maintenance. One thing I won't do though, is fix a friends brakes. I'm happy working on my own brakes, and happy to accept the responsibility for my actions. I won't take hat responsibility on for friends though. If you're not happy/capable of fixing your own brakes, take it to someone qualified and insured.
I think crypto is the same. There's nothing wrong with learning about and writing your own crypto as a curious amateur. But deploying that crypto where it can get other people killed is a bigger deal. Don't be "the cryptocat guy", "Oh yeah, I just found out you can't use water for brake fluid, turns out it boils when it gets hot! Who knew? Anyway, I just put brake fluid in my brakes, you should probably upgrade yours too sometime…"
I think if you want to _deploy_ crypto to other people, you owe it to yourself to have at least as much "professional training" as an auto mechanic gets before they're allowed to repair your brakes. And to further stretch the analogy - I'll point out tha most mechanics these days don't "repair" much in brake systems, they'll just replace large components - its becoming more common to not be able to buy seals and pistons any more - you're expected to just replace entire calipers or master cylinders. In my head that's the same approach as saying "I'll choose to use GPG or OpenSSL, but I won't 'do my own crypto'" - for someone who's _not_ prepared to put in a few hundred hours of proper crypto training, I think "rolling your own crypto software" is something best left to personal/educational projects, and never deployed I a way that other people might rely upon it.