4 ms·
I don't agree with the statement that Secure Ideas makes; they are opting out because DEFCON is supposed to be an open collaboration place, but if the very nets
by samstave 13y ago
I don't agree with the statement that Secure Ideas makes; they are opting out because DEFCON is supposed to be an open collaboration place, but if the very netsec community doesn't have the balls to stand up to the extreme over-reach of the NSA, then we are farked.
Yes, most of us have known for years the extent of the spying the NSA/USG does -- and I believe it's time to take back some individual sovereignty -- the NSA has all but dissolved this.
For me, this is not a political issue, its a human rights issue. I have no respect for the NSA and its apologists, period.
- mpyne 13y ago> I have no respect for the NSA and its apologists, period. Do you lack respect for those people, or their arguments?
- samstave 13y agoI have no respect for the NSA and those who work there who perpetrate this surveillance state. So those people who have built this.
- stfu 13y agoExactly the right point! This needs to be personal - especially because we are not talking about some exploited minimal wage earners who have no other options. But instead about professionals who have made the intentional choice to dedicate 8h+ a day to organizations that set out to destroy privacy and private communication across the world.
- samstave 13y agoYour comment made me think of something.. Let me ask you: THe NSA in specific and the intelligence community in general clearly believes that the information about, opinions of and actions by equate to "a person" -- if they did not, they would not be surveilling what they are. Your question of whether I respect the "people" or their "arguments", appears to me, to be loaded. It's as if you're attempting to determine if I make a distinction between the people in the positions of NSA staff vs. the actions they take as a willing person under employ. I respect people: human beings. As a human being I see myself as a part of a singular species on a, thus far, singular planet in our universe. I am not an enemy of humanity - I am an advocate of it. The opinions arguments and actions of planetary governments though appear to actually be at odds with humanity and its longevity. So, on the one hand we have an agencies actions which distill a person to their digital DNA; analyses, evaluates and judges it coming to a conclusion in whole as to what that person "is" and a schism in our culture that you appear to be attempting to exploit: your question is attempting to play to my "humanity" with these being people who are just making decisions and arguments in line with the "orders and directives" of an institutional body such as the NSA/USG. Let me be very clear; I don't care who anyone works for, if you are attempting to control, oppress, exploit or succeed at the expense of people as a whole - you are an enemy to humanity. You could be an individual, a group, a corporation or a government. I stand for both my individual sovereignty and the collective well being of my species and civilization. This is what sets us apart from the insects; we are capable of thriving as collective individuals as opposed to hive-minded slaves.
- mpyne 13y agoSo the mathematician at NSA who developed the SHA-1 algorithm that underlies a lot of higher-level crypto primitives... is he an oppressor or an individual making a positive contribution to the collective good? How about the janitor who sweeps the bathroom floor at the NSA? Is he or she an enemy of humanity? Hopefully you would conclude otherwise for both, but now you run into the situation where you have to judge individual actions and not just collective membership when assessing who is, or is not, an enemy of humanity. Note that I haven't even had to try to stick up for those 'just following orders'. By all means, judge people on what they do; judge ideas on their own merits; that's all I've ever asked for myself. Just remember that sometimes good work may come from organizations that you consider evil. Imagine how we would have thought of the infamous Nazi Oskar Schindler, before we knew the real story of his factory. Likewise, good people may have bad ideas, and those with good ideas are not necessarily good people trying to lead you to a good goal.
- samstave 13y agoIf you retread my comment, I specifically said I have no respect for the people at the NSA (and USG in general) who have worked to create a global surveillance state. Your question about the "janitor" is ridiculous. While he's the lowest on the pawn totem, I am specifically talking a out those who know that they have created the systems designed to spy on every man woman and child on the planet. If you cannot separate these people from those in a janitorial position, then you're clearly attempting to sideline the discussion.
- mpyne 13y ago> If you retread my comment, I specifically said I have no respect for the people at the NSA (and USG in general) who have worked to create a global surveillance state Well all I ask is that you keep that in mind next time you decry someone for working at NSA, or FBI, or any of a number of other agencies, unless you actually know what they've done. People are all too willing to offload rational thought to the simple act of labeling. The Bush-style logic of "You're either with us or against us" was wrong when talking about terrorism, and it's still wrong when you're talking about the NSA, or even government in general. Let people be evaluated for what they actually do, not merely for where they showed up for work. In case you're wondering, this does mean that I don't support excluding Feds from a conference just because they're Feds, arrest powers or otherwise... though you could ask the agency not to send their employees on official duty since we oppose the agency's actions itself.
- throwawayDC21 13y ago> but if the very netsec community doesn't have the balls to stand up to the extreme over-reach of the NSA, then we are farked. I would agree with this much more if they had previously had a statement suggesting that feds from oppressive foreign regimes were not invited. As a non-US citizen, there is a sentiment of "it was OK when we thought they were just doing it to foreigners" about much of this debate. However, this isn't about standing up to anyone, it's a PR move by DEF CON.
- sanderjd 13y agoI'm sure this will just further your impression of the general sentiment, but I want to try to explain it as a US citizen. The biggest problem many people have with what the NSA has been revealed to be doing is that it breaks laws regarding the US government's ability to invade the privacy of its citizens, and it does so in secret, precluding real democratic oversight. While spying on foreigners may be unsavory, it does not fundamentally break our government the way (secretly) spying on citizens does.
- Nrsolis 13y agoI agree with your sentiment. It's worthwhile to note that people have often stated that the Constitution is not a "suicide pact". We are free (as a people) do what needs to be done to preserve our union. Whatever your political persuasion, it cannot be denied that bad actors are trying to coordinate and plan attacks against "soft" targets inside the United States and abroad. This is not a theoretical problem. It's real. What is extremely unsavory about this entire affair is that the entire citizenry has somehow become a suspect. Every snippet of our communiques, interests, and associations is now considered "fair game". This has been done without ANY meaningful discussion in the public sphere. We, as a people, have been misled and our desire to understand what our government has been doing has been ignored. This is wrong. I don't agree with Snowden's actions. I think he handled it the wrong way if what he wanted was to bring attention to this state of affairs. There are many who feel like he might have done this for personal glory or with traitorous intent. I'm not convinced one way or another, but I'm not happy with how this has unfolded. I'm glad that there are enough people paying attention to this devils bargain we've made in the pursuit of security and I hope we get some resolution before things go back to the status quo. We need to have a national conversation about this. The sooner the better. If there is a silver lining in Snowden's actions, I hope this is it.
- ropman76 13y agothis is rank hypocrisy. The NSA is simply using what "security researchers" have been talking about at Defcon for years. One lone hacker gets into a telecom's system and he makes a name for himself (or herself). A government agency does it and everyone gets on their sanctimonious high horse when all the NSA is doing is taking hacking to its next logical step, government weaponization of hacking. .
- D9u 13y agoWe the People don't take kindly to our elected and appointed Public Servants openly lying to us with impunity about programs which are most definitely against the spirit and intent of the Bill of Rights. There's no comparison between some "lone hacker" and our own government entities. The idea that we should accept what the NSA et al have been doing in our name simply because it might be the next logical step is preposterous! The next logical step is extermination camps, and the parallels between our current IC & that of Nazi Germany are too numerous to ignore. That our government wastes so much on these spy programs while simultaneously neglecting our own people is unforgivable. Hypocrisy has no place in our government, but that's exactly what we have now.