8 ms·
The other problem with "targeted social welfare programs" is that it is very easy to dislike programs that someone else (particularly someone that you don't lik
by btilly 13y ago
The other problem with "targeted social welfare programs" is that it is very easy to dislike programs that someone else (particularly someone that you don't like) benefits from. A program that you yourself benefit from tends to be less likely to get eroded by future politicians.
Compare welfare and social security for a classic example of the difference.
- beachstartup 13y agosee welfare vs. disability
- 127001brewer 13y agoAs I have just posted elsewhere in this thread, disability seems to be a type of "basic income". [1] [1] http://apps.npr.org/unfit-for-work/ http://apps.npr.org/unfit-for-work/ Edited for clarity.
- pille 13y agoOne of the biggest problems with disability pay is the barrier it creates to joining the workforce. Losing payments when you get employed is a huge disincentive to looking for employment. That's the opposite of what UBI is trying to do.
- antitrust 13y ago> A program that you yourself benefit from tends to be less likely to get eroded by future politicians. This could be bad. Very popular programs never get reconsidered, even if they have bad effects.
- abstractbill 13y agoJust to help me better understand what you're saying, can you give an example of a program that's very popular, and which has bad effects?
- arebop 13y agohome mortgage interest deduction?
- anonymoushn 13y agoFor instance, Detroit has created pension obligations that it cannot possibly make good on, and is having some difficulty dealing with those as it is bankrupt. Many other local governments have similar programs, but are not yet bankrupt.
- el_zorro 13y agoSurely Social Security wasn't meant to be the biggest item on the Federal Budget. I suppose you can argue about its popularity, but it has become enormous.
- mncolinlee 13y agoWould you mind mentioning any one thing which federal government does which should be more costly than providing a livable income to everyone over the age of 65? Our Federal Government is not responsible for most of the major functions of governance because our states cover most functions. Also, we aren't at war with a major foreign power.
- Zaytes 13y agoProp 13 in California
- dredmorbius 13y agoCalifornia's Proposition 13 property tax law. Much of the special exemptions relating to health care and insurance which effectively tie it to employment, while restricting the ability for other groups to form for pooled risk. Addressed somewhat under Obamacare. Big Ag subsidies. Patent and copyright laws.
- tomjen3 13y agoAh, but that is a feature, not a bug.
- jerf 13y agoThis is my biggest concern with the idea, which I don't see being addressed (checked the entire conversation on this post to date). I don't think having the vote and having the basic income is compatible with each other. Why aren't people going to vote themselves larger basic incomes every year? How can you both have the (modern conception of the) vote, and a basic income at the same time? Attempts to answer this question also need to deal with human beings as they are, not as they could be if we were all just really good and pure and all motivated by selfless interest only in the good of humanity as a whole or something, because presumably this is being proposed as a real policy for real people and not some fantasyland. (Also, I do not consider "well we already have some programs like that today" to be a defense... I'm not entirely convinced that's just going to turn out peachy keen in the end either. I'm personally pretty convinced we've already passed a threshold at which a significant chunk of our government is actively pursuing government dependency as a conscious policy, and that's not going to end well either, as the same mechanics take sway... there is always a reason to grow benefits, it's always evil to cut them, and there's no feasible way to bound the growth of promised benefits to real growth, other than the really, really hard one of simply running out of resources.) While this is a criticism of mine, and I am not trying to hide my general skepticism as seen in my second paragraph, I am posting this also in a genuine spirit of inquiry about what answers to this question may have been developed. I acknowledge the problems the BI idea is trying to solve, and I acknowledge that I have no answers (including, alas, BI, unless someone can convince me here).
- dgreensp 13y agoHaving the vote hasn't given us any unholy powers to control the government's spending so far, so why would it? It's not even clear if any form of basic income would be voted for. We're just talking about changing from structure A to structure B in terms of how the government provides for people.
- agilebyte 13y agoAgree with you. How does one enforce people hopping borders from places that have no universal income policy? How do we deal with sovereign states that are allowed to set their own tax policy and thus legally become an offshore tax haven?