3 ms·
Newspapers are a product sold for personal consumption and priced accordingly, but they have enormous positive externalities. The traditional solution to deali
by cma 18y ago
Newspapers are a product sold for personal consumption and priced accordingly, but they have enormous positive externalities. The traditional solution to dealing with something with positive externalities is via government subsidy; doing so for news in a direct manner is obviously a bad idea, since the primary positive externality provided by reporting is the check it provides on the government and other centers of power. Doing so through a government funded voucher system could be one possible solution.
Everyone would receive $X of money with a mandate to give it to any news organization they wish. A condition of the money is that the organization receives it blindly, e.g. they don't reward you with anything in exchange (this isn't a subsidy for you to buy a daily newspaper).
The primary difficulty with this solution is that under such a system, how do you ensure the money is spent on news? As one example, how do you prevent Bob from spending his voucher on his neighbor's sham "news organization", and his neighbor doing likewise on Bob's sham "news organization"? You can easily craft legal language to remove a one-level tit-for-tat situation like that, but how do you do so robustly for the many other manifestations?
If you allow the government to choose who constitutes a real news organization and who doesn't, the voucher system loses many of its advantages (the primary one being proportional representation through the "individual choice" a voucher system provides, rather than monolithic "majority choice"; of course in both cases there is still a monolithic decision made on how much funding will go towards news).
- pie 18y agoAlthough it seems like a political and economic improbability in the US, I'm somewhat fond of the BBC's (potentially as an extension of PBS's) system of large-scale, government-supported news. Clearly we would prefer a more distributed, personalized, and capitalist solution for funding quality news, but it seems as though we're losing a lot of steam while groping around for some unknown salvation of our current paradigm. If our society really does need exhaustive, deep journalism from large-ish organizations (which seems to be an underlying consensus among articles on the topic), then it's probably the government's duty to keep these institutions and practices alive. Perhaps all this hubbub arises from a lack of vision though, and investigative reporting and in-depth analysis of current events are not in jeopardy at all - they'll simply come from different sources that most of us would expect.
- Retric 18y agoSadly I find publicly funded news organizations (BBC,PBS) far more informative than private organizations (NBC,FOX). However, I suspect directly paying for news that is not primarily funded though advertising might be the best solution. Removing the costs of TV / printing paper and filling a 24 hour news cycle means far smaller organizations can still fill the need for real reporting. The other option is something like "the daily show" where in depth news is just one type of content and you don't need to yammer on about every new case of H1N1 to fill an hour of news every single day. PS: The reality is paying 10,000 or so journalists is just not that expensive a proposition and assuming the current system is the only way to fund them is probably missing the point.
- Xichekolas 18y agoI think you make a good point about the hour long format. News seems like a case where the time constraint was beneficial, and the product has become less valuable (more noise) ever since that constraint was dropped by the 24 hour news networks. When I was a kid, we watched the 10 o'clock news every night before bed. The first half hour was world news, the second half hour was local news, and it always wrapped up with some local human interest piece. Yeah, it was a staid format, but it also meant the signal to noise ratio was high, because you really only had time to say what was actually important/informative. With 24 hour news, we basically have the same information, but it's diluted by 23 hours of commentary on "what might happen" and "what's your view on what is happening". Why do we want to listen to people speculate all day? If the speculation was at least honest and intelligent, you might be able to learn from it, but I'm fairly sure you could find a higher level of discourse in your local high school debate class.