3 ms·
The Linux kernel is used in a lot of different devices, this is true, but it's also a lot leaner than the Windows one. Although efforts have been made to pare d
by astrodust 13y ago
The Linux kernel is used in a lot of different devices, this is true, but it's also a lot leaner than the Windows one. Although efforts have been made to pare down what Windows is, it's still got a footprint gigantically bigger than Linux. Where Windows can squeeze on to an ARM system, Linux runs on embedded systems that are even smaller.
The thing that's the most broken about Microsoft's strategy is it's not just the kernel being thrown everywhere, but the user interface. That's the most incoherent part of their strategy. Does the accounting department need to use the same UI as the Xbox? It's so confused.
OS X and iOS are similar, but not the same thing, although not as different as, say, Ubuntu is to Android. It's possible that the Ubuntu phone project might blur this distinction in time, it seems possible.
What I mean mostly is that just because Windows and it's user interface can run on all these different platforms doesn't mean it's an optimal approach. Then again, Microsoft has never shied away from monoculture. They're the Monsanto of software.
- freehunter 13y agoMy Windows Phone runs faster than my Android Phone on less hardware, for one example. I also know my car runs on Windows on pretty barebones embedded hardware as well. The two OSes also have slightly dissimilar user interfaces. Windows is not Windows is not Windows in exactly the same way Linux is not Linux is not Linux.
- gecko 13y agoThe Linux kernel is used in a lot of different devices, this is true, but it's also a lot leaner than the Windows one. Although efforts have been made to pare down what Windows is, it's still got a footprint gigantically bigger than Linux. I think Windows Phone 8 shows that this is not meaningfully true anymore. There's more work to be done, but the kernel on those devices are quite minimal, happily running on underpowered ARM devices with minimal RAM, and still leaving plenty of room for apps.
- angersock 13y agoSo, the Windows kernel probably is pound-for-pound as lightweight as the Linux kernel. Whenever people talk about Windows they always drag the UI and such along, whereas with Linux they seem to merrily ignore all the chrome. Any Windows kernel folks care to confirm/deny this?
- marshray 13y agoI work at MSFT and while not involved with kernel stuff directly I interact with them from time to time. The sentiment among kernel people is they'd put the NT kernel up against Linux in efficiency any day of the week. The challenge is that it's difficult to get just the NT kernel and minimal support libraries. There was an internal project called http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MinWin#cite_ref-zheng2007_10-0 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MinWin#cite_ref-zheng2007_10-0 Without watching the entire video, Wikipedia mentions something like a 25MB footprint for a usable NT kernel. Windows installed OS features are a lot more a' la carte these days. It annoys me that there's not a ntsd.exe or telnet.exe on every box by default, but I suppose it's worth it for the greater goal. There's a lot of focus on Windows Server Core, Hyper-V, and Azure. Cloud is bringing everybody back to thinking about OS footprint again. I think the Windows-sans-(stuff not everyone needs) approach is only going to become more normal.
- gecko 13y agoI don't work on the kernel, but I'd note that you can very comfortably run Windows Server headless on 512 MB of RAM--just like you can with Linux. (MySQL will experience hellishly Pavlovian pain on either OS with that little RAM, though.)