3 ms·
BTW, Wikipedians considered Microsoft's stack ranking notorious enough to provide the date they started doing it (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitality_curve#Mi
by hga 13y ago
BTW, Wikipedians considered Microsoft's stack ranking notorious enough to provide the date they started doing it (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitality_curve#Microsoft http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitality_curve#Microsoft): "Starting in 2006 Microsoft has used a Vitality Curve despite intense internal criticism." Which I've noted elsewhere is the year in which Bill Gates stopped his day to day roles at Microsoft.
I could talk about how Ballmer himself is a significant problem, but then again these "simple fixes" would surely require removing him from an position of direct power in the company.
- mikestew 13y agoMicrosoft has been doing stack ranking long before 2006. I left in 2005'and attended stack rank meetings, where managers indirectly decide your review score before you even get the form from HR. it goes back to at least the late 90s, IIRC.
- hga 13y agoWere those in the bottom rank shown the door in due course?
- mikestew 13y agoThere was certainly mention of "up or out", and a bad review or two would bring about the PIP stick (which seems to be only legal CYA before the firing, not for any hopes of real improvement). And, frankly, it was a long time ago and I haven't gone to any effort to remember details. I will say that in general it was as screwy and demotivating then as it is described to be now. It was based on a model proposed by Ballmer's hero Jack Welch. What Ballmer forgot is that Welch himself said the "trim the bottom 10%" model didn't work once a company got larger than a certain size.
- hga 13y agoThanks! The only detail I was interested in was the timing; the Wikipedia citation of 2006, which I will stop using, did strike me a bit recent.
- michaelochurch 13y agoWhat Ballmer forgot is that Welch himself said the "trim the bottom 10%" model didn't work once a company got larger than a certain size. I'm not sure that size is the issue. I think that the percentage of deadwood a company has being static is the problem. A typical 10,000-person company probably has enough deadwood to make a 10% cut safe: a mature company that's accrued enough slackers and incompetents can endure a cut of the obvious nonperformers and few will be upset about it. Even many of the nonperformers will agree, to some extent, that it's time. Besides, the company will have a cut anyway if it underperforms. But if you cut 10% every year, after two or three iterations you are cutting good people, and the cultural effects of that make the process not worth it.