2 ms·
> Modern, latest-generation fighter aircraft have a TWR somewhere between 0.75 and 1.15. If you pointed them upwards, they will barely be able to lift off the g
by stcredzero 13y ago
> Modern, latest-generation fighter aircraft have a TWR somewhere between 0.75 and 1.15. If you pointed them upwards, they will barely be able to lift off the ground (if their TWR is above 1.0 at all), much less gain enough speed to generate lift with their wings.
Taking off horizontally allows you to get lift "for free" with the wings.
Well, more specifically, you are using the atmosphere as reaction mass. Wings direct air down. It's not free lift, it's free reaction mass.
I'm not saying that you should eliminate catapult launches. But a ship large enough to have catapults can still be a whole lot smaller than a modern US Navy aircraft carrier. Any aircraft that can land vertically will also be able to take off vertically. (Though with less efficiency when fully loaded, if at all.)
There's a huge amount to be gained by being able to stage aircraft from much smaller ships. How about building submarines a bit larger than the old Soviet Typhoons, and having aircraft on those? Short of that, how about the ability to build squadrons of multiple redundant cruiser-sized carriers?
Perhaps such schemes would be more valuable potential opponents of the US, than they would be to the US.
Yes, on the whole, the system will be less fuel efficient than horizontal take off and landing.
- starpilot 13y ago> There's a huge amount to be gained by being able to stage aircraft from much smaller ships. These are called amphibious assault ships like the America and Tarawa classes. They can serve helicopters and V/STOL fixed-wing aircraft. No catapults. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/America-class_amphibious_assault_ship http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/America-class_amphibious_assaul... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:USS_Saipan_LHA-2_amphibious_assault_ship.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:USS_Saipan_LHA-2_amphibiou...
- Tloewald 13y agoI suspect you may see submarines configured to launch drones vertically with rocket assist and recover them using something smaller than a flight deck. Subs already deploy SEAL teams and there has been at minimum experimental use of remote piloted minisubs — this would be a perfect complement. This heralds the end of the aircraft carrier (a good thing, since they're really quite obsolete conceptually).
- Retric 13y agoIt's actually more useful to have larger carriers than smaller ones. The obvious difference is top speed as drag does not increase linearly with length. But you also gain the ability to do takeoffs and landings in a wider range of weather conditions as well as having redundant nuclear reactors and dentists etc. But, perhapse most importantly the larger the aircraft carrier the larger aircraft it can support and there are many advantages to having larger aircraft.
- lmm 13y agoReally? Larger aircraft have a larger cross-section for enemy radar and missiles, and are likely to have worse thrust/weight ratios and maneuverability (square-cube law). Combat range and ammo capacity scales with size up to a point, but if you can make a smaller drone with the same range and armament as a normal fighter then it would surely be more useful in most respects.
- Retric 13y agoYour don't need to take my word for it both carriers and modern fighter craft have continued to get larger over time. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supercarrier http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supercarrier and the next gen the Navy is constructing is not getting any smaller. But, don't forget the navy uses a lot of non steath aircraft for logistics and other thing to the point where they seriously considered building a floating 2 mile runway (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_offshore_base http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_offshore_base). As to why it's useful for combat aircraft to be larger. First radar cross sections have little to do with the overall size of the craft it's mostly a question of shape an material assuming everything is staying within the same order of magnitude. Second while strait up thrust/weight is useful, top speed, range, and munitions capacity are generally more important because if your fast enough you can bank at over 10g's which will cause you to pass out long before the aircraft is in trouble. So while maned aircraft are still limited by the pilots all of the rest of those tend to improve as you scale up aircraft size. PS: In many ways Cost and the desire for redundancy do limit the size of both aircraft carriers and combat aircraft.