3 ms·
I don't see why these need to take off and land horizontally. Give them the capability to take off and land on their tails, and the size of the carrier can shri
by stcredzero 13y ago
I don't see why these need to take off and land horizontally. Give them the capability to take off and land on their tails, and the size of the carrier can shrink dramatically. The reason why we don't use tail sitting craft is because they are too awkward for human pilots to land. Drones wouldn't be so limited.
- Game_Ender 13y agoThe reason you don't use tail sitters is because they have much less payload capacity. In that configuration the engine has to be able to output thrust greater than the entire weight of the aircraft. Something like the 737 has a thrust to weight ratio of only 0.25 (you need greater than 1 to take off vertically). A more direct comparison: A fully loaded standard F-35 has a thrust to weight ratio of 0.87 (that is with the afterburners on). In comparison the short take of and landing version of the F-35 loses 43% payload of its and 25% of it's fuel capacity (and thus range) [1]. 1 - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning_II#Variants http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning_...
- stcredzero 13y ago> The reason you don't use tail sitters is because they have much less payload capacity. I wasn't thinking of abandoning horizontal flight entirely. Being able to land a drone aircraft after it has spent its munitions and fuel should be handy.
- potatolicious 13y ago> "The reason why we don't use tail sitting craft is because they are too awkward for human pilots to land." This isn't true. Taking off anything vertically requires their thrust-to-weight ratios be higher than 1.0 (otherwise try as it might, it's going to sit on the ground). Modern, latest-generation fighter aircraft have a TWR somewhere between 0.75 and 1.15. If you pointed them upwards, they will barely be able to lift off the ground (if their TWR is above 1.0 at all), much less gain enough speed to generate lift with their wings. Taking off horizontally allows you to get lift "for free" with the wings. Accelerating horizontally means you're not fighting gravity the whole time. Lifting off vertically, assuming the aircraft has enough TWR to make it realistic, is a terrible waste of fuel. Modern fighters only have a combat radius of ~300-350mi before they have to turn around and go home. The more fuel that is expended taking off or landing, the less actual flight (and fight) time they have. Catapult launches also allows you to save fuel on the aircraft by "borrowing" the necessary energy from the launcher. Ditto arrested-hook landings that allow you to borrow stopping force from the aircraft carrier - otherwise you'd have to carry enough fuel to exert this force yourself. It's certainly possible to design craft that can take off and land vertically - the physics are relatively simple. The problem is making them practical - the more fuel/weight an aircraft spends just taking off and landing, the less weight can be dedicated to useful tasks, like missiles, bombs, and flying far.
- starpilot 13y agoThe real reason generating lift with large wings is better is that it's much more efficient to generate a force by accelerating a large volume of fluid a small amount, than vice versa as with a turbine engine. This is why helicopters exist at all, because of the efficiency of large rotors (wings). Ref http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:VTOL_DiscLoad-LiftEfficiency.PNG http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:VTOL_DiscLoad-LiftEfficien... (note log scale).
- stcredzero 13y ago> Modern, latest-generation fighter aircraft have a TWR somewhere between 0.75 and 1.15. If you pointed them upwards, they will barely be able to lift off the ground (if their TWR is above 1.0 at all), much less gain enough speed to generate lift with their wings. Taking off horizontally allows you to get lift "for free" with the wings. Well, more specifically, you are using the atmosphere as reaction mass. Wings direct air down. It's not free lift, it's free reaction mass. I'm not saying that you should eliminate catapult launches. But a ship large enough to have catapults can still be a whole lot smaller than a modern US Navy aircraft carrier. Any aircraft that can land vertically will also be able to take off vertically. (Though with less efficiency when fully loaded, if at all.) There's a huge amount to be gained by being able to stage aircraft from much smaller ships. How about building submarines a bit larger than the old Soviet Typhoons, and having aircraft on those? Short of that, how about the ability to build squadrons of multiple redundant cruiser-sized carriers? Perhaps such schemes would be more valuable potential opponents of the US, than they would be to the US. Yes, on the whole, the system will be less fuel efficient than horizontal take off and landing.
- starpilot 13y ago> There's a huge amount to be gained by being able to stage aircraft from much smaller ships. These are called amphibious assault ships like the America and Tarawa classes. They can serve helicopters and V/STOL fixed-wing aircraft. No catapults. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/America-class_amphibious_assault_ship http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/America-class_amphibious_assaul... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:USS_Saipan_LHA-2_amphibious_assault_ship.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:USS_Saipan_LHA-2_amphibiou...