6 ms·
Data Brokers Are Now Selling Your Car's Location For $10 Online
- jrockway 13y agoIs this the same company that owns all the speeding and red light cameras? If so, what a brilliant way to further monetize their monopoly. "Public safety", indeed. (One thing I like about riding a bicycle is that you are mostly anonymous, and nobody is going to show up with a picture of you running a red light a couple months later. Of course, once these companies start doing facial recognition based on pictures of you tagged by your friends on social networks...)
- cinquemb 13y agoTwo years ago in my E & M lab, one of my profs was showing off on of his research projects into materials with negative permeability and negative permittivity… it started to make me think about if people could have clothes(or objects) and spray a lining of these type of materials on them, it could render them "invisible" to traditional optics… Isn't the military doing research like this too? I know they work close with academia as well…
- D9u 13y agoThere has been license plate blocking technology for sale for quite some time now, which is definitely more low-tech than James Bond style license plate changers. http://www.phantomplate.com/photoblocker.html http://www.phantomplate.com/photoblocker.html
- maxerickson 13y agoMythbusters had worse luck than the local media at your link: http://dsc.discovery.com/tv-shows/mythbusters/mythbusters-database/way-to-beat-police-speed-cameras.htm http://dsc.discovery.com/tv-shows/mythbusters/mythbusters-da...
- dsl 13y agoThe data is collected from cameras attached to tow trucks. The people who source the data will come out and install it for free, and a laptop inside the cabin makes a noise and automatically prints out a repossession order if it finds a car on the repo list. They get a cut of the finders fee from the finance company who underwrote the delinquent car loan. (and from this article it sounds like they sell the data to law enforcement and lawyers now too) I suspect thats why the hits he was able to find were from parking lots. Previous to the automated system repo guys would troll parking lots with a hot sheet of plate numbers looking for hits.
- codezero 13y agoIt's too bad current vehicle codes forbid you from obscuring your plate at all at any time, this makes it illegal to hide your identity from would be data collectors, which makes protecting yourself very difficult. I suppose you could just go without plates like Steve Jobs did and pay the fix-it tickets you end up getting. Personally, I tend to forget to pay my registration for a solid 6 months before I finally get pulled over for it every year, and it costs me about $35 extra, so if this becomes pervasive, it might be worth considering losing the plates. I'm willing to bet that some officers would even be slightly sympathetic if you explained your reasoning, not that they wouldn't still give you a ticket, but maybe.
- redthrowaway 13y ago>I suppose you could just go without plates like Steve Jobs did and pay the fix-it tickets you end up getting. A minor note, but he never paid any fix-it tickets. IIRC, there's a clause in California's vehicle laws that gives you up to 6 months from the date of purchase to affix plates to a vehicle (although it must still be registered). Jobs just traded in his MB S500 every 6 months for a new one to avoid ever having to put plates on. It's not exactly feasible for the non-billionaires among us.
- codezero 13y agoAh yeah, I think you are correct, very clever. I still think that going with the fix-it ticket route would be feasible for the normal folks. Though I am not sure if they end up raising the price if you repeatedly get the same fix-it ticket, that might be a problem.
- sliverstorm 13y ago"Strategies" that involve throwing around lots of money, like buying a new car every 6 months, never seem that clever to me.
- codezero 13y agoIt depends on what you are optimizing for. In his case, I presume it was privacy.
- coldcode 13y agoLife begins to suck more every day, soon everyone will know everything about all of us. I wonder what an open source life will be like.
- logn 13y agoWell, I have a seemingly infinite world of information at my disposal already. And I spend most of my free time reading HN. I don't think it will be that big of a deal. Most people will just willingly choose not to invade your privacy even if no one would find out if they did (besides, who's to say I don't start a database of people who look at databases of this private info?). Anyhow, I should cruise wikipedia more.
- wladimir 13y agoAgree about the sucking part. But IMO the problem is not that everyone will know everything about everyone. That would be weird (utopian?) but kind of fair. The fear is about the rich and privileged knowing everything about the poor and underprivileged (using databases that are expensive, protected by IP laws, and/or require clearance), and opaqueness the other way around. Information as a means of control.
- tokenadult 13y ago"Of five cars that I looked up, three cars turned up nothing, but I found data on the other two. "One car had a single sighting: it was parked on Manhattan’s Upper West Side at 12:40 in the morning last December." This squares with my use of databases sold to lawyers, doing look-ups on myself and close family members. The databases are much less impressive in their power than salesmen suggest. I'm not worried about this. I won't be worried about this, and eventually when most cars are self-driving and many cars are paid for by the use and ridden by many different passengers, license plate recognition will be less informative than ever. To be sure, aggregating a whole lot of data can add up in its impact. MIT has developed a tool with which you can analyze all of your own Gmail metadata https://immersion.media.mit.edu/ https://immersion.media.mit.edu/ (I learned about this from a submission to HN from ColinWright, which alas received little discussion here), and I found out from that tool that my use of email is more business-related than I realized: all of the top seven "collaborators" (that program's term) that I have are actual work colleagues, as well as personal friends. A megabyte here, a megabyte there, and pretty soon all the data turn into information. But really the victims here often enough will be the chump clients who pay for license plate record searches and don't find out anything worthwhile.
- wtvanhest 13y agoTo your last point, my gmail reflected the same thing, but I think the cause is that immersion seems to analyze the number of emails for each person. To get something small done for work purposes requires 10 emails. For personal stuff, it seems to require just a few.
- edoloughlin 13y agoeventually when most cars are self-driving and many cars are paid for by the use and ridden by many different passengers, license plate recognition will be less informative than ever Except that then they'll have credit cards matched to continuous GPS data.
- dredmorbius 13y agoTime to find a bitcoin car-share.
- baltcode 13y agoSo who is actually going around photographing the cars? Do they have regular employees, fixed cameras, or do people just turn in photographs for small change?
- Amadou 13y agoRepo men. There is at least one company that works with repo men - they put ANPR cameras on the repo men's dashboards, it records every plate that comes into view and uploads it in near real-time to a central databases along with gps info. Any repo man who subscribes to the service can put out an alert for a plate, once that plate of interest shows up in the central database they get a text message telling then when and where it was scanned. When I first heard about these guys a few years ago they already had a very large number of repomen participating in the service. I am not surprised to hear that the companies have expanded their market beyond repomen, that is the nature of databases - once you've got the data centralized all kinds of ideas come up for how to exploit it.
- vijayr 13y agoAnd all of this is legal? Does this mean anyone can put up a camera on his dashboard, roof and capture these info?
- Amadou 13y agoYes, in the US, the current state of the law is that anything done in public is fair game for anyone - there is no expectation of privacy when in public. However, this point of law was determined back in the late 60's or early 70's, back when the concept of an indexed database of millions of permanent records of essentially everybody in public was barely even the stuff of science fiction, much less everyday fact. I think we are long overdue for a revaluation of the legal situation given the drastic change in circumstances of the last 40 years.
- guelo 13y agoThis is nothing compared to what cops are putting together, gathering data from all their tag reader cameras including ones monitoring popular roads and ones attached to police cars. And aggregating it at regional "fusion centers". http://cironline.org/reports/license-plate-readers-let-police-collect-millions-records-drivers-4883 http://cironline.org/reports/license-plate-readers-let-polic...
- bigiain 13y agoThat's a great/terrifying link. I'd love to know the justification the city of San Leandro use to explain why they're keeping photographic records of cars, owners, and their families - and just how uptight the police/city-officials would be if I took photos of them and their families in their driveways at the rate of "1000s every eight hours"…
- diminoten 13y agoDevil's advocate: Why would they need justification to at least keep records of where your licence plate has been in public? What expectation of privacy do you have?
- jordan0day 13y agoI'm not entirely sure what the US constitution says about a reasonable expectation of privacy, but I certainly have to wonder what the authors of it would have changed, had they envisioned a society in which the government could constantly, reliably, and ubiquitously surveil its' citizens. That is, perhaps we shouldn't have an expectation of privacy in public, but for a long time, we had a reasonable expectation of relative anonymity, at least, the average person did.
- bigiain 13y agoAs elsewhere, the expectation of "just another face in the crowd" pseudo-privacy. When we (as a society, by which I mean my grandparents parents) agreed to have "unique identifiers" prominently displayed on vehicles we own, the reasoning behind that decision was based on a different reality. This is _very much_ scope-creep - without anyone affected being asked whether it's OK. If there was a proposal to have police all stop 1000 people per shift to check and record their ID, people and civil liberty groups would be up in arms (perhaps literally). Is this _very_ much different? Shouldn't we at least have had a discussion about it before rolling it out without letting anybody know what was going on?
- homeomorphic 13y agoForget the cars. How long before people accept discounts on Google glass (or similar) in exchange for continuously running face recognition software and streaming the information back to some company providing a similar service where you can look up people instead of cars? "User #129334, we have detected a person of interest in your field of view. A client would like Enhanced Position Information (TM) on this individual. Nod if you agree to keep him in sight for the next hour and receive a month of free cable!" For a long time we've enjoyed the goods arising from the fact that technology can rarely be stopped. I have a feeling we'll see some awful things in the coming decade... It unsettles me greatly that I have this newfound fear or technology, but I really do.
- veidr 13y agoIt's a done deal: everywhere your car with a license plate goes is and will be tracked, and stored forever. It's already happening, it is already cheap, and there's no way to stop it short of a massive swell of public support for enacting laws to limit it -- in the USA, that seems very unlikely. What I think is important to extrapolate from this stuff is that everything we can do with license plate recognition now will soon be doable with facial recognition. Tracking everywhere your car has been and storing the record forever is one thing. It's very hard to imagine that tracking everywhere your face has been isn't the next step.