4 ms·
> The US actually tried to impeach a president for lying about a sexual encounter with a White House intern yet does not seem to care much about a president who
by munificent 13y ago
> The US actually tried to impeach a president for lying about a sexual encounter with a White House intern yet does not seem to care much about a president who despite teaching Constitutional Law (G.W. Bush was not even a lawyer) does not appear to know his primary responsibility as president - to protect and defend the Constitution - and proceeds to violate the sworn oath of allegiance he took (twice) after being elected and reelected.
I believe that this is actually literally true: people do care more about the former than the latter. And I think the reasoning is the same psychological flaw that leads to bikeshed[1] arguments.
The executive branch manipulating the interpretation of laws to undermine the checks and balances of the Constitution is too huge, complex, and nebulous of an issue for the average voter to understand or know how to feel on. So many of us just sort of assume that other, smarter people will figure out how to fix the problem for us.
Meanwhile, we can all relate to and easily come to a moral judgement when it comes to infidelity in a marriage and lying about it in court. We can imagine ourselves in that situation and have a clear picture of what the right thing to do is.
With this whole privacy issue, it isn't even clear who the actors are in the story. We all know something bad is going down, but who is doing bad things and why, who is doing good to combat it, and what as citizens should we do to improve the situation? It's huge and overwhelming.
[1]: http://bikeshed.com/ http://bikeshed.com/
- narrator 13y agoTheory: It's important to make things somewhat complicated so they don't fall victim to bike-shedding.
- osth 13y agoAh, the bikeshed. IMO the most relevant bit of pop psychology I've ever seen wielded by a programmer in a mailing list/online forum. It's validity is so seemingly self-evident, I'll bet this concept has been christened under other names as well, maybe before or after the book from which PHK quoted. In any case, I absolutely agree with your assessment. As someone who claimed to have known Snowden from past gaming posted in a brief note (on Svbtle or Tumblr I think), this surveillance issue needs a story, as in one with characters, a plot, a beginning and an ending. The American public (whatever that refers to) is much like a kindergarten class right after milk and cookies. They are ready for storytime after which they will promptly take a nap and wake up with a clear head, ready to play, eat and be entertained by the next story. I believe I read that someone is already preparing for a full length film about Snowden and his daring deed. I'd say that script will need quite a bit of poetic license and embellishment. As it stands, there's no story. There's no narrative. NSA slides? Boring. Who is the hero? Who is the villain? What is the moral of the story? (Hollywood usually fills one in that meets sponsor approval.) Is it really so surprising that the government is engaged in mass surveillance? Hardly. The American people are a generally suspicious and cynical lot. They don't need evidence. Spying is not enough to shock them. To get the American people to actually care about something, they need to be entertained. We tried to entertain them in the beginning: focusing on Snowden's girlfriend, his Ars comments, etc. But there's no Starr report, no stain on a party dress, no candid photos to feed the innuendos. Close, but there's no cigar. Back to sleep we go.... zzz(8)...