3 ms·
Is it a journey of self-discovery? Or were those people simply the right people to make the observations they did? I would be careful with cause and effect. It
by DanielBMarkham 19y ago
Is it a journey of self-discovery? Or were those people simply the right people to make the observations they did?
I would be careful with cause and effect. It may be that brain structures allow one person, say, a greater ability to see in the dark and notice the tiger that is about to pounce while another cannot. But the tiger is not a result of that person. The observation of the tiger is a result of brain structure or whatever. The tiger exists with or without the person noticing it.
This is beginning to set off my BS alarm, but suffice it to say that philosophers seem to have made discoveries quite apart from the structure of their brains or personalities. They've also indulged in a lot of pontificating and wondering about based on their unique brain structures, no doubt. But I would be careful in using neuroscience to explain philosophy. I've read some studies that show that some brains are more conservative than others, and some are more liberal. This might be really cool in 100 years once all the noise comes out of the experiments, but for now, it poses more of a danger than a benefit to the layreader, imo. We're just at the stage of correlation. Nobody that I know of is talking about causation for some of these higher-order effects.
- robg 19y agoNo doubt in 100 years we'll know much more. But we have to start somewhere! And right now we're sketching the outlines. And you're absolutely right - causation is very difficult to explain. Ask the philosophers!