4 ms·
Was expecting to find comment by tptacek explaining how WP's Craig Timberg has no journalistic integrity because "direct access" clearly doesn't mean the NSA ge
by specialist 13y ago
Was expecting to find comment by tptacek explaining how WP's Craig Timberg has no journalistic integrity because "direct access" clearly doesn't mean the NSA gets whatever data it wants by whatever means necessary. Rather, "direct access" can only imply the NSA administers the credentials of each and every server and database existent, which clearly couldn't be true.
Maybe he's busy.
I'll check back.
- virtuabhi 13y agoMy thoughts exactly. I had assumed that tpateck would have magnified a figure of speech (e.g. full control -> judge can only appoint not remove), ranted about some obtuse point (e.g. which foreign government does not spy), and enjoyed the thread on violation of first/fourth amendment right derail from the issue. And all of his posts are moved to the top by HNers who recognize the name.
- furyofantares 13y agoHow is this related to the comment you're replying to? I don't understand the connection.
- b6 13y agoIt wasn't. I agree there's a little bit of wrongness to that, but I hope his parent post won't mind too much, because there's a lot of truth to his point. Often we get more information like this, a fuller understanding of how Americans have been paying billions of dollars to fund this surveillance weapon that threatens the human race, and find an extremely well-written post by an obviously highly intelligent tptacek at the top, explaining why, strictly speaking, this is all legal -- or something. I'm glad I'm not the only one who finds it annoying.
- PavlovsCat 13y agoThose posts usually have a lot of responses that rise to the challenge though, and without any opposition or advocacy for the devil, much less (or even nothing) is learned. I don't think it's fair to call him out like that, HN is better than this and posts can be dealt with on a one by one basis. Take off all the nicks, for maximum message resolution.
- nwombosi 13y agoYou guys are amazingly mature and civilized for a social website. You make reddit look like Aleppo!
- furyofantares 13y agoOh, I figured I was missing some context. I still hope that's the case. I'm not sure what value there is to replying to imagined posts by people who aren't posting, and hijacking the top rated comment to boot.
- ScottBurson 13y agoI frequently disagree with Thomas (tptacek), but this is unfair.
- VexXtreme 13y agoI was just expecting to see him defending the NSA and telling us we're all wrong again.
- Jd 13y agoI think this is a bit of a cheap shot at tptacek so will defend him in his absence. First, when it comes to programs by US intelligence agencies (both previously known, currently revealed, and yet to be revealed) there are multiple categories of evaluation: namely, ethical, legal, constitutional. Generally speaking, everything the Feds are doing is legal in the sense that it follows a specific legal process that was setup in the scare over terrorism, which both expanded the powers of the executive branch and created "shadow courts" which presumably provide some checks and balances in the system. Of course, we can't really know how reliably these work since the process for National Security Letters and other aspects itself is secret. Nonetheless, there are specific process in places that seem generally speaking to be followed. How often there are "exceptions" to this process is difficult to ascertain, and has not really been a focus in the present debate. When it comes to constitutionality, it is a hotly debated topic among Americans partially because it was the bedrock of the American state, but an increasing number of Americans (including justices) either aren't knowledgable or don't care about the specifics of the constitution. This is a huge topic, but it is sufficient to say that something can be unconstitutional (even blatantly so) and nonetheless be legal. In this specific case, it is difficult to know how or whether the protection against "unreasonable" searches includes storage of metadata associated with phonecalls that can be searched by an analyst. Then, more broadly, there are a wide representation of ethical issues. For example, it is completely legal and constitutional to spy on non US citizens, but are there any boundaries that should be set on what is and is not acceptable behavior? My strongly held view is that, at least when it comes to US hq'ed companies with a large foreign user base that they provisions in places for non US citizens should at the very least be the same as those for US citizens. However, saying that something should exist and implementing it are two different things, and one is considerably more difficult than the other. So this is all basically to defend tptacek and say that it is important to differentiate when accusing the US government of "crimes." In other words, there are lots of unethical things that you can do that are perfectly legal.
- specialist 13y agoI'm mocking the "direct action" fabricated controversy. I apologize that wasn't more clear. I fully expected Craig Timberg to be attacked, just like Glenn Greenwald was. It is unfair that I'm using a nym, whereas tptacek's a real identity. It may be unfair to single out tptacek out of the mob of people banging the "direct action" drum. He stands out here on HN. Since I'm using a nym, I won't belabor the point.