3 ms·
Speaking as someone who used to buy a bunch of books on Amazon, and now buy them on iBooks, I don't understand the "bad for consumer" angle. I don't tend to buy
by eridius 13y ago
Speaking as someone who used to buy a bunch of books on Amazon, and now buy them on iBooks, I don't understand the "bad for consumer" angle. I don't tend to buy bestsellers, so maybe I'm not hurt as much by the higher prices for that category, but I do still see $12.99 prices on new books. However, and this is something that everybody seems to be ignoring, I'd much rather pay $12.99 for a new book than not be able to buy the book at all because the publisher is holding it back to promote hardcover sales (i.e. "windowing"). Also, what hardcovers are you buying that cost $12.99 or $14.99? I just looked up Amazon's prices for a book that came out 3 months ago that I pre-ordered (Blood of Dragons by Robin Hobb). I paid $12.99 for it in iBooks. Amazon's selling the hardcover for $20.86. I am much happier to pay $12.99 to read it in iBooks than to pay over $20 for a physical copy. And I wouldn't be surprised if the only reason I could do this at all is the anti-windowing agreement. In fact, another recent book by the same author, The Willful Princess and the Piebald Prince, is not even available in eBook format (I don't know who published that book but they must not be subject to the anti-windowing agreement). I'd love to read it, but I'm not paying $28.05 for Hardcover.
It's also worth pointing out that the publishers didn't change their prices. Amazon artificially lowered what the consumer was paying, but the publisher still got their $12.99 (or whatever they charged). It would not surprise me in the least if Amazon's long-term plan was to stop discounting books once they cemented their hold over the market.
- smackfu 13y ago> I don't tend to buy bestsellers, so maybe I'm not hurt as much by the higher prices for that category, but I do still see $12.99 prices on new books. Interesting reason for the $12.99 books: the ones I see are from Random House and are being sold under the agency model still. You can tell because it says "price set by publisher". Random House was not part of the price fixing suit. And yeah, generally speaking, this whole case was about bestsellers. No one cares about downlist stuff, they care about hurting the value of their NY Times bestselling hardcovers.
- AppDevPro 13y agoI'm honestly scared of Apple after learning of the abusive(?) manner by which they got Random House to adopt agency pricing for ebooks: Random House, the largest publisher, resisted Apple's call to adopt the agency model in 2010. But the company capitulated a year later in order to get its books on the iPad. "Apple decided to pressure Random House to join the iBookstore," Cote wrote. "As Cue wrote to Apple CEO Tim Cook, 'When we get Random House, it will be over for everyone.' Apple had its opportunity in the Fall of 2010, when Random House submitted some e-book apps to Apple’s App Store. Cue advised Random House that Apple was only interested in doing 'an overall deal' with Random House. By December, they had begun negotiations, and Random House executed an agency agreement with Apple in mid-January 2011. In an e-mail to [Steve] Jobs, Cue attributed Random House’s capitulation in part to 'the fact that I prevented an app from Random House from going live in the app store this week.'"
- greyfade 13y agoWhy be scared of Apple? Boycott them.
- justizin 13y agoIf you read the Steve Jobs mails, it's clear that Apple was trying to create a sustainable marketplace, while Amazon was, as you oddly imply at the end of your thought, controlling the marketplace by artificially setting prices lower than the cost. Of COURSE they would stop doing this after some time. This practice kept small players out of the game and while Apple could afford to play along, they knew it was a foolish game. It's a dangerous precedent that a new player bringing new customers to a market, refusing to engage in monopolistic tactics, and refusing to sell above a certain price, is price fixing. Price fixing hurts consumers by many sellers agreeing to artificially raise the price of something such as to avoid the pain of competing on price. Apple convinced publishers to accept a lower price - nominally - and to sell at a reasonable market price, or they couldn't be stocked in their store. A brick and mortar retailer could never be faulted for refusing to sell products at a loss!!! I'm not saying Apple is perfect, but in this case they behaved more responsibly and in the interests of content creators and consumers, in the long run, than all other parties involved. The true price fixing was Amazon and the publishers, pre-iBooks, agreeing to sell some items as high as 24.99 for eBooks - something Steve Jobs refused to do. Average price higher, highest price lower. I still buy books on Amazon instead of iBooks because my Kindle is handy as a dedicated reader and hey, I want to pay less out of self interest. I also got my Kindle for free. But it must be clear this is surely fucking the authors. Also, to those who think eBooks should be far cheaper than print, what do you think it costs to print a thousand page novel? You think the hardcover costs $10-15 more, or that it's a premium sell?
- fpgeek 13y agoApple wasn't trying to create any old sustainable marketplace. They were trying to create a marketplace where they didn't have to compete on price so they could win on a more favorable dimension (like platform integration). Therein lies the problem.