4 ms·
Reading this article it suddenly became clear: FISA is an Executive Branch agency that defends executive actions, much like the DoJ. In other words, it is the D
by javajosh 13y ago
Reading this article it suddenly became clear: FISA is an Executive Branch agency that defends executive actions, much like the DoJ. In other words, it is the DoJ. When it (at least) comes to the 4th Amendment, the executive branch has manipulated Section 215 of the Patriot managed to totally unchain itself from the Constitution and do whatever it wants, in secret, from both the public and the other branches of government.
The magnitude of this is stunning. Historically, the executive has unchained itself for brief periods for specific issues. I do not know of any attempt to unchain itself in perpetuity, and in secret.
The fact that anyone finds it the least defensible is even more stunning. I mean, even if you are for mass surveillance (and there are many who legitimately feel that way) surely you must be concerned that it was done without your knowledge or consent.
There are two paths to solving this problem, both of which result in striking down Section 215 of the Patriot Act: a court challenge (which the EFF is spear-heading) and an act of Congress (which is very unlikely given the lack of public awareness and uproar).
Personally, I would like to see an additional censure on Obama and all other executive, legislative, and judicia officials who abrogated their duty to protect the Constitution of the United States of America. It needs to be our harshest censure, to send a message to future administrations that secret coups will not be tolerated.
- DanielBMarkham 13y agoYou are correct. This is quite stunning. My reaction when thinking about what we've created is "awestruck" -- and I mean that in the initial meaning of the word. It's an amazingly giant cluster fuck. I don't see a way out, and I believe it's only a matter of time, perhaps only a few years, before the executive starts using this power for political gain. And then we are well and truly screwed. ADD: One counter-argument might be that the president can't use this for direct political gain because of all the other laws and structures we've put in place to prevent direct meddling. Believing that is true, which I don't, we're left with an even worse calamity: mid-level managers who will effectively have the power of kings while making 100K per year. As we've seen in many other mid-level management scandals, including the IRS, for the guy getting screwed it doesn't make much difference whether it's the president or some nameless bureaucrat being paid off by the mob who's doing it. Hurts just the same. Still just as bad. In fact, the president directly abusing this power is probably the best of all possible bad outcomes. Gives us one person to blame.
- BrandonMarc 13y agoA matter of time? It's already happened. See how documents submitted to the IRS magically appear in the hands of political opponents. See how political opposition was thoroughly disrupted (tea party groups' tax-exempt purgatory + all of the raids and interrogation which followed) while political friends sailed through immediately.
- amitparikh 13y agoI disagree with your interpretation that the Executive Branch has "totally unchain [sic] itself from the Constitution." Congress has voted a couple times in the most recent decade to approve extensions for the FISA Amendments Act of 2008 (see footnotes). So under Congressional authority, the Executive Branch has been able to continue their activities under the FISC. I do agree, however, that there is a blindfold around the Judicial branch that prevents any introspection into the actual interpretations of law under the FISC, specifically w/r/t the 4th Amendment. [1] http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/112/hr5949 http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/112/hr5949 [2] http://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_lists/roll_call_vote_cfm.cfm?congress=112&session=2&vote=00236 http://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_lists/roll_c...
- mtgx 13y agoThe FISA Amendments Act that passed in 2008 and was renewed late last year, needs to go, too. The Patriot Act part is more for phone calls. FISA allows them to scoop all the Internet data.
- fixxer 13y ago> Personally, I would like to see an additional censure on Obama and all other executive, legislative, and judicial officials who abrogated their duty to protect the Constitution of the United States of America. It needs to be our harshest censure, to send a message to future administrations that secret coups will not be tolerated. But, who will keep us safe! If you want to see reform, you've got to start winning the hearts and minds of the American public and convince them the surveillance state is a bad thing. I think that is going to be a challenge. I know a lot of people who still say "I've got nothing to hide", etc. Truth is it takes very little to scare them into thinking the government needs to do everything in its power to protect them. Case in point, the Boston bombing, which was horrible (I'm not discounting it). But, have we seen any increase in regulatory pressure on fertilizer plants? I'm far more "worried" (=rationally aware of the risk) about the anhydrous ammonia plant on the other side of town. There are approximately 10,000 federal statutes, many of which never get enforced because they are either too difficult or so completely asinine that nobody cares (http://tjshome.com/dumblaws.php http://tjshome.com/dumblaws.php). Just wait until the infrastructure gets to the point where it allows total information awareness on the general population and everything gets enforced. That is a bureaucrat's wet dream.
- javajosh 13y ago> winning the hearts and minds of the American public and convince them the surveillance state is a bad thing. Actually, no! While I agree it is a terrible thing, the even worse thing is that the surveillance state was created without the knowledge or consent of the public. That is, as bad as the first-order action was, the second-order precedent is far, far worse.
- fixxer 13y agoI don't understand your argument. I think you might have misread mine. I'm saying that in order to undo the surveillance state, you have to convince the general public that mass surveillance is bad. HN readers might realize it, but the average US citizen does not. BTW, "who will keep us safe" was sarcastic. Sorry if that wasn't obvious.
- osth 13y agoStill the best article I've seen on this whole affair was the one at foreigpolicy.com back on June 11: http://www.foreignpolicy.com/2012/06/11/to_protect_and_defend_obama_constitution http://www.foreignpolicy.com/2012/06/11/to_protect_and_defen... The US actually tried to impeach a president for lying about a sexual encounter with a White House intern yet does not seem to care much about a president who despite teaching Constitutional Law (G.W. Bush was not even a lawyer) does not appear to know his primary responsibility as president - to protect and defend the Constitution - and proceeds to violate the sworn oath of allegiance he took (twice) after being elected and reelected. Do we really care more about presidents who lie about sex scandals than presidents who violate their oath? Maybe we should change the oath to state "I do solemnly swear that I will not have sexual encounters with any White House staff." Under that oath, JFK would have been in clear violation. The Constitution is far more important than any single president, administration or election. I guess there are still some folks who might still believe that there's really been no obvious violations of the Constitution in the course of these surveillance programs. But then why did so many senior lawyers at DOJ, even the Attorney General himself, oppose and threaten to resign (or resign) over these programs when they learned about them years ago? How many more lawyers need to look at the facts and say, "Something is not right here," before we all agree to get to work and fix it? Bush Jr. too was at fault for what has taken place, but it's Obama who has been fully caught out (thanks to Snowden). Why should Obama be excused for this? The issue is not personal nor political (as it may have been with Clinton... as if he was the first president ever to cheat and to lie); it is a matter of protecting the Constitution. What higher calling is there for any public servant? And while it's unfortunate the issue has come to the public light during his term, this is much more important than Mr. Obama, his presidency, his administration, or his legacy. "Yes we scan." Time to stand down, my brother. EDIT: added "www." to link
- bennyg 13y agoThat link can't be found. Any mirrors?
- acqq 13y agoThe same site: http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2013/06/11/to_protect_and_defend_obama_constitution http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2013/06/11/to_protect_... "Now in his second term, President Obama insists that his counterterrorism policies differ markedly from Bush's. However, there are far more similarities than differences with regards to: non-battlefield targeted killings (an estimated 50 under Bush, and 387 under Obama); indefinite detention of suspected terrorists (approved by both through executive orders); broad surveillance authorities (as former NSA and CIA director Michael Hayden admitted on Sunday, 'NSA is actually empowered to do more things than I was empowered to do under President Bush's special authorization')" Impressive!
- enraged_camel 13y agoOver the past decade, the American justice system has become fundamentally - and in my opinion, irreversibly - broken. There has always been corruption in politics and justice, and that has been somewhat kept in check by the Constitution. But since 9/11, the corruption has become qualitatively different, because like you say, the government is no longer chained to the Constitution and can either interpret it liberally, or completely refuse to follow it using secret courts and gag orders and what have you. It's not just the magnitude of this problem that is stunning, but also the scope and the depth. For example, you have surely noted that the number of people who care about being subject to perpetual surveillance is alarmingly small. But from their perspective, when someone is having to work longer and longer hours just to keep their jobs, and they have to constantly worry about missing mortgage payments and losing their homes, and on top of that deal with various health problems (due to rising obesity rates, among other things), and being able to send their kids to college, and whether they will be shot by some cop while reading a book... it's actually no wonder that they simply don't have the mental bandwidth to care about some nebulous government entity listening their phone calls and reading their emails. I guess what I'm trying to say is that the current situation in America is the confluence of a great number of seemingly unrelated threads. And the reason we won't be able to solve the problems this time around is that the complexity of this ball of yarn is simply too great for any one individual to fully comprehend, much even solve.