Youtube is fine in most aspects, but I would consider comment system one of the most broken things on the web, period. I know it's not easy to make good, given

Youtube is fine in most aspects, but I would consider comment system one of the most broken things on the web, period. I know it's not easy to make good, given the variety of audience and usage, much less "perfect", but I doubt anyone is even trying. How much of the quality of youtube comments can be attributed to this? Anyone wanting to make a point or responding to one would rather post the video in a forum and discuss it there. And considering that it's YOUtube, which means the initial idea was that people talk into their camera, and others respond with videos and comments, I wouldn't exactly call the comment system a gimmick either. It would be nice to at least theoretically be able to have actual discussion on important videos, right where the video is. But no ^^