5 ms·
The FISC is de-facto supreme. Due to the secrecy of its subject matter and rulings, nobody can prove standing to sue in the first place, so it's impossible to c
by modeless 13y ago
The FISC is de-facto supreme. Due to the secrecy of its subject matter and rulings, nobody can prove standing to sue in the first place, so it's impossible to challenge it in practice.
- joewallin 13y agoModeless, you are right. This court should be subject to the full light of day and a true adversarial process. All opinions published. With judges having to put their names on the opinions and own up to them.
- dfc 13y agoThe same can/should be said for "unpublished opinions"[1] of any court. I do not understand how in a common law system a judge can make a ruling and say "I don't want to be held accountable for this rash decision I just filed. Let's mark it unpublished and make sure it never has to undergo much scrutiny." [1] This is a different unpublished than FISC decisions. Instead of "unpublished" read as "non-precedential opinions." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-publication_of_legal_opinions_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-publication_of_legal_opinio...
- joewallin 13y agoI agree with you dfc. Not publishing opinions in this day and age is nuts. Everything should be published.
- DannyBee 13y agoThis doesn't make any sense. Constitutional injury does not occur because a judge interprets the law. Constitutional injury occurs when the government does something to you. If the government is the one surveilling you, you challenge that, and then you have standing. All existing decisions i'm aware of (except the one in the past few days), even the SCOTUS one, dealt with third parties making claims that they were "likely being surveilled". None of them could prove anything, because nobody has used the info against them. SCOTUS held that they could not establish standing, because they couldn't show it was actually happening. The parties wanted abrogation of the state secrets privilege to get the government to admit or deny whether they were being surveilled. IE It wasn't known surveillance targets suing, it was "a group of international organizations, lawyers, and media personnel" If you have a case where someone who was surveilled has been denied standing, i'd love to see it. So far, Jewell has not been denied standing in Jewell vs. The NSA
- modeless 13y agoApparently you have a non-standard definition of "surveilled"; perhaps the one James Clapper uses? The leaked Verizon FISA order clearly shows that practically everyone in the US has been surveilled by the NSA (every Verizon customer, and everyone who has ever called a Verizon customer). That means everyone has standing, and everyone whose standing was previously denied was wronged. But suppose the leak hadn't happened. Suppose the government kept secrets perfectly, and nobody could establish standing. Is your position really that the government should be able to violate the 4th amendment as much as it wants, as long as it's kept secret?
- DannyBee 13y agoThis is your assertion, not the current precedent. I am objectively talking about the current precedent and what it states, not what my definition or my position is. Do not confuse the two. Under current precedent, the answer to your questions are "No, not everyone in the US has standing" and "Yes, if they keep it secret enough that you can't prove it, you are fucked", at least given what SCOTUS has said. At least the latter question has been almost directly answered by SCOTUS. I may disagree, but that is the current law of the land. Congress could, of course, change that (as could SCOTUS)