3 ms·
I think the model might be a little bit misguided (having everything in one place is not necessarily a good thing, specialization and all) -- but open source an
by hardwaresofton 13y ago
I think the model might be a little bit misguided (having everything in one place is not necessarily a good thing, specialization and all) -- but open source and awesome? I'm down with that
- drone 13y agoAgreed, although there are more capable ERP systems out there of varying degrees of openness, I've found many of them suffer from one serious core flaw (for my needs): Failure to integrate effectively with Quickbooks or QBO (the latter being more likely for most ERP-like systems these days). I understand that some businesses need fewer advanced financial features, but every promise of "integrated one-stop back-end" has left me with having to have multiple processes for the same task. I wish more of these projects would integrate with common, effective, players in specialized areas rather than trying to "be everything to everyone" - a good ERP system these days would really be glue between the powerhouses moreso than replacements. Alas, this project looks to be struggling - no blog posts since 2011, and minimal activity over 2013 in github.
- X4 13y agoI wouldn't say the other software are more capable, but rather more featureful. The problem with OpenBravo and SugarCRM is that it's really really difficult to use. Every procedure depends on another procedure and you need a Book to get going. As a company that is a massive backshot when you have to teach existing employees. I argue that simplicity in the UI and clear workflows going through the entire application are essential for success, well and marketing. And tree.io had no good marketing, I hope it gets some fresh wind thanks to HN on Github.
- jacques_chester 13y agoSome ERP projects use single systems, some stitch together "Best of Breed". There's no consensus about which one is the best form of cash bonfire.
- X4 13y agoTree.io is simple, which allows for customization and specialization. :) I think you mistake all-in-one with complexity and non-adaptability. Centralization makes software vulnerable, that's right, but not this type of in-house centralization. Correct me if I am wrong. Even the best and most loosely coupled component-based software has one problem, it needs to be connected (glued if badly written) to other systems to make it useful. What this evolves to is a complex network of interlinked components. Similar to organic systems nature has invented. Ironic, that we humans create similarly working components that we're made out of.
- hardwaresofton 13y agoI can definitely see the value in connecting the systems -- that's without a doubt very important (and a very good reason Microsoft has a corner on the market) What I was more getting at was that by not focusing on interaction/dealing with centralization or supporting interaction between multiple services, teams usually move faster (less process, if no other gains -- no one has to check your outputs for compatability,etc), and get to do more feature-development. But then again, as a lazy person who loves open source stuff, any attempt at something so ambitious is awesome I think. I feel like a lemming for saying anything bad about it. [EDIT] - Taking another look at the tour -- It is pretty amazing. A lot of companies are charging for LESS functionality
- X4 13y agoYeah, I also kind of find it funny when companies charge for very simple invoice tools, when they could opensource it, and focus on their next mini-project instead. They could built a suite of tools that way, but hey "instant profit" is seductive.
- treeio 13y agoFor those who doesn't want to have their data in the hands of a third party it makes sense having everything in one system, and because it's open source you can easily extend it if need be.