5 ms·
This is exactly the kind of thing I've been curious about, regarding such "flat" companies like Valve and GitHub. I've never quite believed that things could g
by crazygringo 13y ago
This is exactly the kind of thing I've been curious about, regarding such "flat" companies like Valve and GitHub.
I've never quite believed that things could go so smoothly as they say. I'm not saying this article is necessarily true, but that I wish there were real research into the negatives of these kinds of management structures (or lack-of-management structures).
- _delirium 13y agoI know there is some study of it in left-wing political groups, both writing by people within such groups, and some sociological study of them by outsiders. One of the manifestations of dissatisfaction with both Leninism/Stalinism's ultra hierarchical style on the one hand, and the emergence of "union bosses" in the trade-union movement on the other, was a strong ideological attachment to radically non-hierarchical organization among groups like anarchists, council communists, etc. And one of the immediate problems that comes up is non-transparent, de facto cliques and networks of behind-the-scenes leaders. There's been a bunch of ink spilled on trying to come up with consensus-based organizational methods and best practices that aim to avoid that and produce "actual" non-hierarchy rather than just the superficial look of non-hierarchy. In some brief searching I haven't come up with any particularly good summary to point to, though, and I don't know if there's any consensus (ha ha) on whether any methods are more successful than others. In a different vein, there's a lot of academic stuff written on Scandinavian workplace management, which is not precisely flat, but has flattish hierarchies based more on rotating and interlocking committees, rather than boss-and-subordinates tree structures. The goal there seems to be to make the sub-groups that are making decisions overt, so informal cliques don't make the decisions. So there are a lot of committees, with rotating membership to make sure they don't develop into hierarchies. E.g. 5 people are chosen to be responsible for something like working conditions, or strategic direction, or integration of foreign workers, for a term of a year or two, and then a different 5 people will hold that power next year. A big controversy there is how much Scandinavian workplace management is tied to Scandinavian culture, i.e. would it work anywhere else?
- JamesArgo 13y agoIt's pretty obvious that hierarchy performs a necessary function. The focus should be on approximating a hierarchy of merit. Perhaps employees should be hired and tasks assigned by weighted vote, with a handicap for those who've performed well on a company betting market which predicts when x employee will finish a task and the quality of his/her work. The whole process could be made anonymous, provided the market is a play money affair.
- EthanHeilman 13y agoHierarchy introduces a bunch of serious problems, for instance: 1. information is often collected at the leaf nodes, so it must flow up the chain-of-command to be used effectively 2. power creates perverse incentives to distort information as it travels up the hierarchy, even when it doesn't information is distorted as it is compressed for fewer and fewer people (see executive summary) 3. hierarchies have to wait for signals to go up the tree and back down to act (which is why the US military has non-hierarchical decision making in places), this makes "tall" hierarchies slow to react 4. corruption of single node in a hierarchy can disrupt all nodes below or above it in non-obvious ways 5. hierarchies tend to have extremely critical nodes and cascading failure modes Use of such structures should always be considered within the framework of a trade-off.
- cobrausn 13y agoIn regards to points 4 and 5, 'flat' hierarchies still have nodes that are more connected than others and wield greater influence than others. These have the same failings.
- EthanHeilman 13y agoYes, and there is this notion of control points which allow you to extract sets of nodes in graphs as hierarchies. For instance this research: http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0044459 http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone... I would argue that well designed organisations or networks should have enough connections to route around/detect minor damage/corruption and quickly isolate the problem. For instance small world networks have this property http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small-world_network http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small-world_network . Not all nodes in flat human networks are likely to be equal in information flow, but a plurality of high degree nodes does somewhat mitigate cascading failure due to disconnection but may increase cascading failure due to interconnection such as viruses.
- makomk 13y agoAny time someone claims there's no power hierarchy within their group or organisation, I pretty much automatically assume they're mistaken and there's all kinds of informal power struggles going on. It seems to be true of groups as diverse as Wikipedia and the very early feminist groups, which claimed to be non-hierachical but really weren't.
- EthanHeilman 13y agoAll large groups have power struggles, but that doesn't mean they are hierarchies, they could be strongly connected graphs or other topologies (for instance voting on a referendum is both non-hierarchical and a power struggle).
- Aloisius 13y agoI've experienced a flat-like organization and I have to say, it was easily one of the worst experiences of my career. The company was setup like a collection of startups. You would pitch your ideas to executive management who would green light hiring and what not. You'd also borrow or entice engineers over to your group. When I joined, it sounded very interesting, but it was a complete nightmare. The executive management would green light things, but they'd green light 10x more than could be done by the engineering staff. The hiring queue was so long that you'd be lucky to see engineers hired for your project for 6 months. That meant stealing engineers from other groups which encouraged serious protectionism by doing things like say, loading down your group with busy work to keep your empire intact. It was a political nightmare because no one was really in charge, so everyone claimed ownership. You had review processes for every single step of development by whatever group claimed ownership over something you touched regardless of how trivial. The executive management rarely stuck their necks out making decisions. You had to prove something was better with data. The fact that data was easily manipulated didn't bother anyone, as long as they didn't have to take any blame. The thing is, the company itself is wildly successful and could be held up as a model for flat organizations if you didn't look too closely. But really, it is in spite of their organization rather than because of it.
- meowface 13y agoThat really does sound like the kind of thing that would look good on paper but be terrible in practice. What market is this company in, if I may ask?
- JanezStupar 13y agoBy the description and from other sources I would guess that this company is in markets such as: The Internet and Advertising.
- hrkristian 13y agoThe fact that Valve has stayed "small" might be the singlemost reason why they're actually pushing for alternative gaming options. Steam for Linux and the games that come with, do you figure that'd be the case today if the company had sold out like for instance Blizzard? Steambox/Piston? Yeah, no. It's a novel idea with some potential if they can get the module upgrading right along with a stable whatever Linux distro they end up going with, but no stakeholder og board of Scrooges would sign off on that stuff.
- michaelochurch 13y agoI'm getting older, and I've seen about 40 companies between places where I've worked, those I've advised, and places where I have some insider detail. I think that open allocation in terms of project mobility is the right way to go. I also think that flat structures are rarely truly that, and that they're certainly not resistant to fast growth (more than 20% per year). There's a paradox inherent in the fact that if there's no management at all, informal psuedomanagement appears and that's worse (because it's unstable and must compete to hold ground). What you want is minimalist, benevolent management that operates in the joint interest of the company and its people, but that seems to require a relatively rare lack of ego. You need a cultural shift to a maker's culture where people who build things are held in highest esteem, and the long-term builders/individual contributors have as much influence and credibility as management. It's pretty rare that one can do away with management outright, though. Someone has to protect the good.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- neilk 13y agoThere may be other options apart from flat-management versus hierarchical management. Management is basically there to provide accountability. But peer systems can also provide some accountability. Semco has an interesting model because they do insane things like allow employees to set their own salary. But your salary will be public, and if you can't prove to your peers on a regular basis that you are still needed, you will be asked to pack up your things. This is just one of the way that they've delegated management functions downwards, which by all accounts works very well. There is still an official hierarchy but it's more about mediating disputes or very high level strategy. http://www.freibergs.com/resources/articles/leadership/semco-insanity-that-works/ http://www.freibergs.com/resources/articles/leadership/semco...
- jongraehl 13y ago'certainly not resistant to fast growth' Do you mean the opposite? Either way - "certainly" is a cheap trick. Reasons please.
- incision 13y agoI've had a few experiences with flat organizations. Notably, the one which was proud to loudly proclaim it's flatness and openness was far and away the worst. It didn't quite fit the high school analogy, but it wasn't far off. In reality, the "flat", "open" structure was actually a concentric hierarchy radiating from The Boss. The Boss > The Inner Circle > Untouchables > Loyals > The Rest. As bad as that was, I'm still inclined to something generally flat given an exceptional leader to set the tone.
- smacktoward 13y agoGiven how rare heroes are, a system that relies on heroes to work properly is a system that doesn't work.
- incision 13y agoDoesn't work for mass duplication, sure. Also, I'd expect heroes to be small subset of exceptional people.
- __--__ 13y agoHow is this different from a traditionally structured office? The Boss is the CEO, the inner circle are the VPs. The Untouchables can be literally anywhere in the org, but generally have special titles, like "Director of Creative Direction". The Loyals tend to be management. The rest are the rank and file. All this really tells me is, given a lack of formal hierarchy, people tend to organize themselves into the exact same hierarchies that are formalized everywhere else.
- pekk 13y agoWhy are you specifically interested in the negatives and not in an overall accurate comparison?