3 ms·
Just like Patrick Smith thinks it's rash to indite the pilots of Flight 214 before we have all the data, I'd ask Pat to do the same for the victims, ahem, passe
by zaroth 13y ago
Just like Patrick Smith thinks it's rash to indite the pilots of Flight 214 before we have all the data, I'd ask Pat to do the same for the victims, ahem, passengers.
I don't think the emergency exit was some walk down the isle where a few people stopped to reach under their seats and grab their carry-on to save the inconvenience. From the pictures I saw of the cabin, the seats were torn loose, piled up on top of each other, and there was no 'center isle' left. However, it does seem that the condition of the cabin after the plane came to rest was highly variable depending on where you were sitting.
For all we know, passengers that were seen carrying bags outside the aircraft could have had to throw those bags down the chute to clear the egress. Or maybe they were in a state of panic and shock and were running on autopilot (if only the plane had landed that way).
I do think Patrick is on to something, that the increased level of automation makes it more likely that when the automation isn't there to help that accidents will happen. What I still don't get is flying 30 knots too slow on approach should have been ringing alarms all over the place, including in the tower, and yet no one noticed?
- Shank 13y agoI agree - I think a little more than the instrument landing system was offline during that period of time. Surely ATC had them on radar and could have easily seen them coming in way too slow to properly land.
- cpncrunch 13y agoThat's not ATC's job. A pilot should be able to land the plane himself/herself in visual conditions.
- mikeash 13y agoI'd be rather surprised if the radar could be useful in this capacity. You'd have to build a large database of all aircraft approach speeds, taking into account all the various factors (different weights and configurations) that could change. You'd also have to take into account wind speed and direction, since radar will measure ground speed, but airspeed is what matters. And not just wind, but wind at their precise altitude, which your ground weather station is not measuring. (Wind speed and direction can vary enormously over altitude, especially close to the ground, due to friction.) Finally, you'd have to catch it and communicate it in time to do something useful, which seems tough in this case, since the airspeed didn't get low until fairly shortly before the crash. I wonder if a simple and effective thing to do here would be to simply display a velocity vector, either in a HUD on the windscreen itself, or on some kind of video display in the cockpit. Just a symbol on the screen that shows exactly which way the airplane is headed at any given moment. When it's on a runway, that's where you'll touch down if nothing changes. When it's on a seawall before the runway, that's where you're going to crash unless you fix things. Maybe I'm underestimating the difficulty, but it doesn't seem like it would be too hard to construct one based on GPS and a forward-looking camera. Edit: thinking more about that last suggestion, more recurrent training for visual approaches would probably be a better idea. A normal human has a built-in velocity vector already. You look out the window and find the point on the ground that isn't moving relative to your view. That's the point you're headed toward. This is Aviation 101 stuff, literally one of the first things a pilot ever learns about landing an airplane. High and low comes later: the first thing you pay attention to is whether that non-moving point is, in fact, on the runway where you intend to touch down. (Or, because of the flare, slightly before where you intend to touch down.)
- epochwolf 13y agoATC would not know the stall speeds for every model and configuration of aircraft that land every day. That's not their job.
- rogerbinns 13y agoPeople also don't respond rationally when in shock. When SQ006 crashed there were reports of passengers sitting in their seats frozen instead of evacuating. On normal flights you spend hours or days before of being in the mindset to keep your valuables, medicine, money and identification on you (or within sight) at all times. Life will be miserable when you don't have those. A few minutes after landing they would have to collect them, and make sure to not to leave any behind before facing immigration etc. It is easy to see how in a state of shock, the instinct to what you have been doing and were concerned about kicks in. The cabin crew will shout at passengers to leave their stuff in an effort to overcome this. It should be noted that on this flight there are reports that some of the escape slides opened up inside the plane trapping the flight crew, hence there being fewer available at the beginning of the evacuation. Shock is a very strange condition. No matter how cool, calm, rational and effective we all think we will be, it isn't a predictor of what we will do.
- mturmon 13y agoThis piece by James Fallows is better than the OP and touches on your comment wondering why low airspeed was not noticed: http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2013/07/professional-pilots-on-the-san-francisco-crash/277563/ http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2013/07/professi... One supposition is that the normal system for correcting low airspeed was temporarily disabled. Key lines from the article I linked: "The 777 can catch you out with with what is known as the FLCH trap. When you are above the glide slope and need to get down in a hurry Flight Level Change (FLCH) is a useful mode to use." [...] "The 777 has autothrottle wake up, i.e. when the aircraft approaches a stall the power comes on automatically to almost full power. This gives pilots great confidence; however, autothrottle wake up is inhibited in FLCH. " Of course, time will tell, and we're all out of our depth in trying to understand what happened.