3 ms·
Probably the day after we stop tolerating the even more egregious waste of life that occurs every day from mass over consumption of alcohol, tobacco, and, well,
by Terretta 13y ago
Probably the day after we stop tolerating the even more egregious waste of life that occurs every day from mass over consumption of alcohol, tobacco, and, well, food.[1]
Accidents are only 7th in the top 10 killers, and automobile accidents are a fraction of that category[2].
If we want to tackle major causes of death, this is the place to start:
1. http://www.policymic.com/articles/24365/9-leading-causes-of-death-in-the-united-states http://www.policymic.com/articles/24365/9-leading-causes-of-...
2. http://danger.mongabay.com/injury_death.htm http://danger.mongabay.com/injury_death.htm
- eterm 13y agoBut if you were to sample leading causes of death among 18-40yr olds then car accidents would be top. Smoking is abhorrent but it still tends to kill the older, car accidents kill young people.
- eddieroger 13y agoSmoking kills people slowly, whereas bike accidents are faster. That doesn't make either better or worse, and if anything, not really comparable.
- Bosence 13y agoI do feel though, that more innocent people are killed by other peoples driving mistakes than other peoples alcohol/smoking/diets.
- tylermac1 13y agoExactly this. Alcohol is linked to over 75,000 deaths per year [1] while bicycle related deaths are around 700 per year [2]. There needs to be much more focus on alcohol/tobacco related injuries than deaths. 1. http://www.cdc.gov/alcohol/fact-sheets/alcohol-use.htm http://www.cdc.gov/alcohol/fact-sheets/alcohol-use.htm 2. http://www.cdc.gov/homeandrecreationalsafety/bikeinjuries.html http://www.cdc.gov/homeandrecreationalsafety/bikeinjuries.ht...
- thwest 13y agoPersonal consumption is a completely different realm than dangerous systemic infrastructure decisions. I'll give someone the right to die fat and drunk on their own, but I absolutely abhor how our roads make murderers out of us.
- jlgreco 13y agoIt's called addiction. People who drink themselves to death cannot be said to be "choosing" to do that in any meaningful way.
- thwest 13y agoDrinking is a significant cause of death among non-addicts. Addicts are a small portion of consumers. Addicts are the exceptional case here.
- jlgreco 13y agoI am willing to wager that there are more alcohol related deaths involving chronic drinkers than there are binging college students who forget to vomit. We've just termed those deaths "acceptable" or pretend that they are "natural causes" because the victims tend to be in the second half of an expected lifespan.
- thwest 13y agoWell, I'm curious what the numbers actually are. Either way about it, I agree we should fight for addicts. I've lost two dear people to alcohol, and I'm fighting for a third right now. However, other than increased mental health care funding I struggle to imagine what governmental policy would have helped those I've lost. A sin tax would have done nothing for these people (hell, prohibition wouldn't have worked either). Legislating 1 meter barriers between auto and bicycle traffic is incredibly simple compared to attempting to legislate the psycho-social forces of addiction. We don't have to limit our social change to legislation but that's the mindset from first reply was made in.
- weland 13y agoOn the other hand, when it comes to alcohol and, to some extent, tobacco, one can at least make the plea that most of the damage isn't external. I can't kill anyone other than myself if I drink too much, whereas if I'm speeding on the road, chances are I'm going to kill whatever I smash into, not only myself. Of course, there's the added penalty related to the social consequences of alcohol consumption (e.g. alienating those around me and wrecking a couple of lives). Don't get me wrong -- I agree with your premise and with the point you are making -- but I think that, as far as the legal and public safety systems are concerned, traffic issues don't go into the same category as alcohol consumption. Alcohol consumption is primarily self-destructive, whereas dangerous driving is not (arguably, someone wearing a seatbelt and protected by airbags is probably safer than someone riding a bike when they get hit by a car). A good first step would probably be to discourage the superfluous use of cars. I passionately hate people who absolutely have to drive their cars over a distance they could cover, on foot, in thirty minutes, when they aren't really rushed by anything. Seriously, get off your lazy ass and walk, or at least take the bus...
- Terretta 13y ago> most of the damage isn't external There are real dollar costs to our overall quality of life from society's health self abuse expense. Excuse the graphic image, but a car accident is generally walk away or dead, while health care for the long term unhealthy keeps bleeding once it starts. "The motorist advocacy group AAA said accidents cost $164.2 billion each year, which based on the methodology used in the report comes to an annual per person cost of $1,051." (2008) By comparison, some other systemic costs: - $190 billion in annual medical costs due to obesity (2012) - CDC reports excessive alcohol consumption cost the U.S. $224 billion (2006) - Total annual public and private health care expenditures caused by smoking: $96 billion - Taxpayers yearly fed/state tax burden from smoking-caused gov’t spending: $70.7 billion - Productivity losses caused by smoking each year: $97 billion Obesity alone or alcohol alone cost us all more than accidents. I for one have other "quality of life" things I'd like to do with my money than subsidize "self destructive" choice. > I passionately hate people who absolutely have to drive their cars I clock under 4K miles a year, mostly long distance trips with four or more passengers. But I'm fortunate enough to live near NYC and use public transportation. It's a lot harder in most of the US. Comparing communities across the US and Europe, it seems the best way to affect driving culture is with community layouts that put food (groceries and restaurants) within easy walking distance.