2 ms·
>He knows full-well the penalties of revealing classified information This makes about as much sense as the same argument from Airplane!: "They bought their ti
by Karunamon 13y ago
>He knows full-well the penalties of revealing classified information
This makes about as much sense as the same argument from Airplane!: "They bought their tickets, they knew what they were getting in to. I say, let 'em crash!"
It's not complicated. If a system is corrupt, any punishments that system may mete out for bringing that corruption to light are also corrupt, by default, and should rationally be opposed.
Keep in mind, we have the Manning example to look at. "Facing punishment" in this case equates to "being tortured".
I don't think you're seriously suggesting that he should just turn himself in to be tortured - that gains everyone nothing. So what is your angle?
- JonFish85 13y agoI wasn't making an argument as to whether he was right or wrong to do it, that's an argument for another thread. Sure there seem to be extenuating circumstances, but ultimately he did knowingly break a law. Regardless of whether you think it's just or unjust, a law is a law. Devout Christians seem to think that paying taxes that ultimately support abortion is immoral. If they don't pay their taxes, they're guilty of tax evasion regardless of how moral they feel it is. This is probably a bad example, but I'm just trying to illustrate a point here. Anyways, I was trying to say that the government isn't simply torturing Manning, there's a good reason for keeping him isolated. In a sense, he knew what he was doing, releasing troves of information that he had no legal right to release. He's going through the painful legal stuff now, but in a lot of ways I think he's better off isolated, rather than murdered by fellow inmates.
- Karunamon 13y ago>Regardless of whether you think it's just or unjust, a law is a law. Can I rephrase? A law is only a law. Followed by none, it has no power, revered religiously, it becomes an instrument of great pain and suffering. Opinion follows: Unjust laws should not be followed, or given any heed beyond condescension towards both the law and those who passed it.
- Shinkei 13y agoEven heard of July Nullification? Please read about it. Sometimes groups of citizens decide that a law should not be followed, and we are empowered to do that. The government is of the people, by the people and for the people. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification_in_the_Unite...
- tptacek 13y agoI wish people could stop conflating normative and descriptive arguments on HN, and I wish the textarea where HN comments were entered included a summary of the Fundamental Attribution Error fallacy. This comment makes both mistakes.
- Karunamon 13y agoThe descriptive argument in this case is irrelevant. Okay, he broke the law. Nobody here disputes that. So what? The entire point I was trying to make was that I don't think the average HN reader, whatever their level of dedication to rule of law (some more, some less), wants to see a guy tortured because he broke a law, less so when the law is being abused by a corrupt system in furtherance of its corruption. Not making this argument basically means that you're outsourcing your moral compass to a third party, a third party who often makes tenuous and outright backwards connections between moral principles and laws. All judgements aside, the normative argument is the only thing there's any kind of discussion or disagreement on. Making the descriptive one apropos of nothing carries the connotation that you value the rule of law above all else. I voted you up for whatever that's worth, but I wish you'd expand on what you mean. Oftentimes it seems you and I misunderstand each other.
- tptacek 13y agoI'm just sensitive to the notion that commenters are frequently attacked for their supposed motivations, usually read from tea leaves, by other commenters. It's not that being misunderstood is a great injustice, but rather that it makes it very difficult to make descriptive points on HN, since the forum is unnecessarily tilted towards normative judgements that is is frankly not well qualified to make. Moreover, descriptive comments often include "hard facts" data about the way things work, and are the product of some amount of research and analysis, which is valuable no matter what the commenter might believe. Normative comments very rarely have that value. Put simply: a comment describing the way things work isn't a strong indicator that the author of the comment wants things to work that way.
- Karunamon 13y ago